That's how Palmer plays. I've seen nothing out of the ordinary so far.
Also I don't think you understood my point about Salva.
He probably is town due to hitting Hyper in the way you described, but you pointed Palmer voting Salva as a bad thing because Salva led Hyper to lynch. This was before he flipped. Salva's claim was ridiculous which he even admits. I basically don't see any solid evidence between linking Palmer being suspicious and him making a vote on Salva yesterday.
Palmer can defend himself well enough, so that's all I'm saying on it. I just want you to understand my thinking.
To be fair, the only other time I've acted like an asshole was in Archer when EzekelRage(confirmed town) started getting weird when we were so close to victory. It was distracting us from getting our goals accomplished, i.e. kill Mike, then Quantum.
I've definitely been worse this game, and I'm trying to tone it down, cause being angry is just going to throw town off it's game even further. So I apologize to those I called idiots or whatever else.
Think about it from my perspective though. Half a dozen times now people have openly admitted they want to lynch me but have no evidence to support it. My voting yesterday is the closest thing to evidence posted, and that offends me for a different reason. Basically, the scum player you guys want me to be this game is just a terrible scum player.
I hate Palmer but I like him :*
Sorry! I do like you, but your play this game has been confusing to me compared to previous games.
Palmer, how does it feel to have a reputation that shields you from scrutiny? That must be pretty badass.
Anyway, the next best thing I can do after actually lynching scum is narrowing down the list of potential scum, because that also gets us closer to victory, so it is important to me that we establish that Salva's town, Palmer aside.
I had to earn the reputation. It wasn't just given to me.
I'm inclined to believe Salva is town, but I'm less sure of that than I am of Cabot, nin, or splinter. I trust him slightly more than Kalor though. I still feel like we're in a decent spot right now. We have 11 players, and about half of them are somewhat known quantities. Probably only 2 scum left, so we have wiggle room still.
Last minute scrambling forced Hyper to come up with a claim that was utter bullshit and would have gotten him killed the next day. It takes away the advantage of mafia, which is scheming.
We got a bit lucky with Hyper too though. Imagine how terrible that all would have been if he flipped town. We ended up with 4 role claims after all. My biggest worry is that Kalor and Hyper were BOTH scum, and Kalor's doublevote was them bussing him. The main reason I think this is that he has a voting power, which seems like an Electorate thing. Just something I'm keeping in mind.
She has no vote but can silence people? What role could that possibly be?
Did anyone else have thoughts on this? A 1-shot silence ability seems underpowered, especially if Ouro is letting the silenced person use image macros. I think it's more likely that the person either got blocked, or decided not to use it again last night. It being used on Cabot seems fairly clear that it's not a town ability. We have reason to expect that BSP was blocked last night. If it was her ability, and it seems possible, using it on Cabot confirms she's working against us.
As for the fluff of being able to silence people and not being able to vote, I'm not certain.
