Obsidians entry wouldn't exist without bethesdas, and they set out to make an rpg first and foremost, which shows in the meh combat, so that is moot..70 hours in and you think bethesda should have just made another IP huh? You don't think thr fallout world and it's elements have anything to do with pulling you in?
Nobody is disagreeing with how bad the rpg elements are, they are cleay ruined overall,seemingly for no reason,but clearly, not everyones enjoyment comes soley from those admittedly ruined elements, and interestingly enough, the added elements are grabbing some members of the audience in a whole new way, beyond choosing an a dialogue choice where everyone in town will treat you prick or a hero , or using science to repair a sad robots blues.
There's progress despite its shortcomings, the flaws are so obvious and rote now its repeated every page as if its a new discovery
Truth is, Bethesda never promised anyone they were making the fallout of old, its their IP now, they are going in their own direction for better or worse.