• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Football•Soccer•Fútbol•Fussball Thread 2010/2011 |OT2|

Status
Not open for further replies.

Clegg

Member
MPW said:
oh we do!

next season there is potential for 7 el clasicos (kicking the season off with 2 barca vs madrid in supercopa!)
As good as that sounds on paper I dont think the clasicos lived up to all the hype that they got.But at least its better than than the 50 Old Firm derbies every fucking season
 

MPW

Member
GQman2121 said:
Yes please. I do not want to have to sit through another bitchfest in the CL again. They can save that for their league fixtures.

don't like barca's beautiful diving/play acting + messi scoring vs 10 men real madrid? nonsense!
 

Messi

Member
No diving and play acting from barca when they tore madrid a new asshole in november last year :0

but I agree the diving was terrible, but madrid were also playing a very rough game. both teams can be ashamed of themself for those games.
 

ShogunX

Member
MPW said:
oh we do!

next season there is potential for 7 el clasicos (kicking the season off with 2 barca vs madrid in supercopa!)

The name should be changed after the shit we had to witness last season. La Mierda would be a more fitting name.
 

GQman2121

Banned
MPW said:
don't like barca's beautiful diving/play acting + messi scoring vs 10 men real madrid? nonsense!
I never had any respect for Sergio, but Villa and, especially Alves were just disgraceful over both legs.
 

Lightning

Banned
Messi said:
The booing last year was wierd to me, I think the transfer stuff had started at that point and arsenal were having none of it. Fab will fit in great at barca and will someday replace xavi (unless that whole cloning thing pans out) I think he is worth the 40 million to be honest. Rosell is being a dick saying he devalued since last year, but it seems like a negotiating tactic. I have a wierd feeling fab is going nowhere because he is not willing to hand in the transfer request (understandibly so) arsenal also dont want to lose their captain.
To be honest I don't think Rosell is that interested in buying back Fabregas yet. He says a price that is too low because he know that Arsenal won't sell for that price but in the meantime Fabregas gets more frustrated, contract winds down, player refuses to extend, and before you know it when the time comes that Rosell does want the player he will get him for a fraction of his true value knowing there is nothing Arsenal can do to keep him.


If Arsenal want to cash in on Fabregas they will need to get his value higher and the only way to do that is get City, Chelsea, Real Madrid etc... to bid for him. Arsenal will need to make a decision on Cesc in the next 12mths and tbh as much as it hurts and I love the player I am in favor of getting rid of him to the highest bidder and focusing on talent but hopefully not from Spain.

As for now, Cesc should be stripped of the captaincy immediately.
 

Clegg

Member
Lightning said:
To be honest I don't think Rosell is that interested in buying back Fabregas yet. He says a price that is too low because he know that Arsenal won't sell for that price but in the meantime Fabregas gets more frustrated, contract winds down, player refuses to extend, and before you know it when the time comes that Rosell does want the player he will get him for a fraction of his true value knowing there is nothing Arsenal can do to keep him.


If Arsenal want to cash in on Fabregas they will need to get his value higher and the only way to do that is get City, Chelsea, Real Madrid etc... to bid for him. Arsenal will need to make a decision on Cesc in the next 12mths and tbh as much as it hurts and I love the player I am in favor of getting rid of him to the highest bidder and focusing on talent but hopefully not from Spain.

As for now, Cesc should be stripped of the captaincy immediately.
I know that theres the whole Catalan connection between Cesc and Barca and that they do want him at the Camp Nou,but Cesc is not the same player he was 18 months ago.I know he's had injuries but whenever I've seen him play he looked like he was just going through the motions and that his heart wasn't in it.Personally I think Rosells valuation of Cesc is closer than Arsenals.As of right now Fabregas isn't a 45-50 million pound player.
 

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
Today:

  • River Plate plays against Belgrano to remain in the Primera División
  • Gold Cup Semifinals - United States vs Panama, Honduras vs Mexico
  • Copa Libertadores final at São Paulo - Santos vs Peñarol
 
Clegg said:
I know that theres the whole Catalan connection between Cesc and Barca and that they do want him at the Camp Nou,but Cesc is not the same player he was 18 months ago.I know he's had injuries but whenever I've seen him play he looked like he was just going through the motions and that his heart wasn't in it.Personally I think Rosells valuation of Cesc is closer than Arsenals.As of right now Fabregas isn't a 45-50 million pound player.
True but at just 23 there is so much ahead of him. I find it hard to believe he can't rediscover that form and even go beyond it.

Arsenal should hold on to him (so long as he is still interested in the club which I believe he is). Going for 35m in the current Market is a joke. In terms of quality/potential he is the best buy since the Market got crazy since Ronaldo IMO.
 

PaulLFC

Member
Raphael Honigstein on Twitter:

"FIFA internal report: "overwhelming evidence of bribery". FIFA off. statemnt: "presumption of innocence maintained, no further investigation""

Typical.
 
Messi said:
anelka-drogba.jpg


One of these will go :(
I'd put my money on Anelka.


Chriswok said:
And that will further make it difficult for any of the young lads at Chelsea to break into the squad. Despite having one of the best youth setups in English football, I find it hard to believe they'll ever successful develop any home grown talent. You've had one or two show promise, but they'll never get more then 5 games a season!
I wouldn't be so sure. This is the last summer of big spending, we're only going to get a few players. After his FFP kicks in and we can't buy big every year. Some of the youth coming up now look great and with the ageing squad they're chances of getting a go are probably better than ever.

I don't think AVB would have taken the job unless it's understood that he's in charge. He doesn't strike me as the type who would take it if he thought otherwise. I think things at Chelsea are changing. We will see.
 

Clegg

Member
farhatraza said:
True but at just 23 there is so much ahead of him. I find it hard to believe he can't rediscover that form and even go beyond it.

Arsenal should hold on to him (so long as he is still interested in the club which I believe he is). Going for 35m in the current Market is a joke. In terms of quality/potential he is the best buy since the Market got crazy since Ronaldo IMO.
You're probably right about Fabregas.He's not played up to his potential for a while but when he does he is the best midfielder in the league by far.He just needs to reaffirm that status and as a fan of football I hope he does because when he's on song he's a joy to watch.Now United need a good midfielder desperately.Some of my friends think Giggs should be in central midfield but realistically he only has one good season left in him.Lass Diarra is available I think.I would love to see Schweinsteiger for United but thats just a pipe dream unfortunately
 

offshore

Member
Kylehimself said:
I think things at Chelsea are changing.
When you launch a 22m bid for a player when have neither a manager or a director of football, I would say that things are not changing at Chelsea at all. AVB will be undermined and discarded by Roman just like every Chelsea manager before him. But if AVB is sacked early, the guy will be in line for a large pay-off, will quickly bounce back somewhere else, so he probably won't be too bothered.
 

MPW

Member
Regulus Tera said:
Today:

  • River Plate plays against Belgrano to remain in the Primera División
  • Gold Cup Semifinals - United States vs Panama, Honduras vs Mexico
  • Copa Libertadores final at São Paulo - Santos vs Peñarol

i hope neymar flops, penarol wins and madrid don't sign neymar aka robinho 2.0
 

Judderman

drawer by drawer
Regulus Tera said:
Today:

  • River Plate plays against Belgrano to remain in the Primera División
  • Gold Cup Semifinals - United States vs Panama, Honduras vs Mexico
  • Copa Libertadores final at São Paulo - Santos vs Peñarol

So much soccer today, and the family wants to watch So You Think You Can Dance. FFFFFUUUUUUUUU.
 

Blackhead

Redarse
Clegg said:
You're probably right about Fabregas.He's not played up to his potential for a while but when he does he is the best midfielder in the league by far.He just needs to reaffirm that status and as a fan of football I hope he does because when he's on song he's a joy to watch.Now United need a good midfielder desperately.Some of my friends think Giggs should be in central midfield but realistically he only has one good season left in him.Lass Diarra is available I think.I would love to see Schweinsteiger for United but thats just a pipe dream unfortunately
No, you really don't. Schweinsteiger shits the bed when put under pressure—he makes Carrick look potty-trained—and that's exactly what you don't need when facing Barcelona (to be fair, he'd be great in 95% of the other match-ups Man Utd are likely to be in). Man Utd has two problems in central midfield: goal scoring and mobility i.e. speed. The goal-scoring problem is doesn't need be resolved because it is adequately compensated by the threat from the wingers/strikers but Carrick, Anderson, Giggs, Fletcher and Park, good passers and disciplined defensively they may be, just can't keep up with Barca's movement nor do they have the dribbling ability to escape Barca's pressing.
 

Clegg

Member
Greyface said:
No, you really don't. Schweinsteiger shits the bed when put under pressure—he makes Carrick look potty-trained—and that's exactly what you don't need when facing Barcelona (to be fair, he'd be great in 95% of the other match-ups Man Utd are likely to be in). Man Utd has two problems in central midfield: goal scoring and mobility i.e. speed. The goal-scoring problem is doesn't need be resolved because it is adequately compensated by the threat from the wingers/strikers but Carrick, Anderson, Giggs, Fletcher and Park, good passers and disciplined defensively they may be, just can't keep up with Barca's movement nor do they have the dribbling ability to escape Barca's pressing.
Realistically no team right now is capable of negating the Barcelona midfield.In relation to Schweinsteiger you are right in saying he does bottle it under pressure sometimes but in terms of the Premier League he'd massively inprove Uniteds midfield who had some shockers last season against weaker opposition.Who could United realistically sign to improve their midfield in the league and in Europe?
 
Clegg said:
Realistically no team right now is capable of negating the Barcelona midfield.In relation to Schweinsteiger you are right in saying he does bottle it under pressure sometimes but in terms of the Premier League he'd massively inprove Uniteds midfield who had some shockers last season against weaker opposition.Who could United realistically sign to improve their midfield in the league and in Europe?
Owen Hargreaves with working knees :(
 
offshore said:
When you launch a 22m bid for a player when have neither a manager or a director of football, I would say that things are not changing at Chelsea at all. AVB will be undermined and discarded by Roman just like every Chelsea manager before him. But if AVB is sacked early, the guy will be in line for a large pay-off, will quickly bounce back somewhere else, so he probably won't be too bothered.
What's the big deal? A 22m bid was never going to get accepted anyway. Why not put the wheels in motion to possibly sign a world class player? We haven't followed it up since. And realistically, how much interest we really had is purely speculation on the media's part. Nobody know's what goes on behind our doors because the club never speculates. Chelsea only ever release news when the job's done. Gourlay said in a statement about a week ago that the managerial issue would be sorted within' a few weeks and sure enough it was. There's a lot going on behind the scenes. Making a bid for an excellent player is hardly a sign of bad things to come.
 

Clegg

Member
anonnumber6 said:
Owen Hargreaves with working knees :(
Right now I'd accept Hargreaves with one working knee.He could've been brilliant at United.He had a great first season then he broke himself.So is there anyone we could realistically sign to improve the central midfield?Also Daniel Taylor from the Guardian has tweeted that Ashley Young has just had his medical for United.Thats one new player at least.Good signing.
 

Blackhead

Redarse
Clegg said:
Realistically no team right now is capable of negating the Barcelona midfield.In relation to Schweinsteiger you are right in saying he does bottle it under pressure sometimes but in terms of the Premier League he'd massively inprove Uniteds midfield who had some shockers last season against weaker opposition.Who could United realistically sign to improve their midfield in the league and in Europe?
Well, it depends on the approach taken. If you play a 4-4-2 (with Giggs and Carrick as the two central midfielders to boot) then it ain't going to work. Trying to match Barca at their own game, like Arsenal did, is iffy at best and honestly the arse were riding their luck for most of the tie (the 2-1 win really should have been in Barca's favor). If you put in 3 defensive midfielders, like Madrid did, then Barca's midfield can be negated, and indeed they were, but who really wants to take that desperation route. I think, or at least I hoping, that what Mourinho has in mind is stuffing the midfield with creative mobile passers (hence the purchase of sahin etc) and playing say 5 in the middle against Barca's 3 (or 4 if Mess is included) just so they can keep the ball and clog the lines when barca has it. We'll find out next season.
 

DominoKid

Member
ooh Belarus went up on Spain

edit: i dont have the faintest idea how they decide on work permits but i cant imagine he'd have trouble getting one since he's an established international and he's been in Spain since 08.
 

Clegg

Member
Greyface said:
Well, it depends on the approach taken. If you play a 4-4-2 (with Giggs and Carrick as the two central midfielders to boot) then it ain't going to work. Trying to match Barca at their own game, like Arsenal did, is iffy at best and honestly the arse were riding their luck for most of the tie (the 2-1 win really should have been in Barca's favor). If you put in 3 defensive midfielders, like Madrid did, then Barca's midfield can be negated, and indeed they were, but who really wants to take that desperation route. I think, or at least I hoping, that what Mourinho has in mind is stuffing the midfield with creative mobile passers (hence the purchase of sahin etc) and playing say 5 in the middle against Barca's 3 (or 4 if Mess is included) just so they can keep the ball and clog the lines when barca has it. We'll find out next season.
Which is why United need to either change their tactics when playing against the biggest
clubs in Europe or sign someone who can provide them with something different.Also playing 5 midfielders across the line against Barcelona is a good idea but Im not sure if Madrid have the players for that,Ozil is a great player in attack but patchy in his defensive duties.It also means that they play with one less forward which would be a detriment to Ronaldo who I think prefers playing off a striker.
 

Mastadon

Banned
DominoKid said:
ooh Belarus went up on Spain

edit: i dont have the faintest idea how they decide on work permits but i cant imagine he'd have trouble getting one since he's an established international and he's been in Spain since 08.

AFAIK, to get a work permit, a player has to play in 75% of his countries international games in the past two years, and be in a top 100 ranked country.

I guess these rules are relaxed slightly following an appeal though, not sure.
 
Clegg said:
Which is why United need to either change their tactics when playing against the biggest clubs in Europe or sign someone who can provide them with something different.

Clegg said:
So is there anyone we could realistically sign to improve the central midfield?Also Daniel Taylor from the Guardian has tweeted that Ashley Young has just had his medical for United.Thats one new player at least.Good signing.


It's really just Barcelona that are provably beyond the reach of our midfield based on the last season, though. (Of course, our away form wasn't good, but that was a pretty universal failing throughout the team.) Carrick-Giggs dominated Chelsea and would have had a decent chance against RM. However, Giggs's passing ability is flowering at the very twilight end of his career (where he can only play every other game) and with Scholes gone, Fletcher coming back from poor form/injury, Anderson yet to advance out of his mode of perpetual potential, Gibson leaving, Hargreaves released and Carrick nearing 30, it's fairly obvious that a reinforcement or two would be helpful. Cleverley will be one, but someone who provides reliably consistent quality will probably be in that bracket, too. At least, until the youth wellspring that won the FA Cup blooms.

There's plenty of realistic signings in that position out there beyond the media darlings of Modric and Sneijder - Defour, M'Vila, Marvin, Ninis, etc. But the summer is yet to start in earnest.

And that's two players - the unplanned Jones and now Young - about done so far. De Gea, too, probably, next week.
 

Mastadon

Banned
dc89 said:
City have made another improved bid for Sanchez as the Barca deal hits a snag!

£35M upfront and £4m in various payments over a period of time. Says that United are still interested but they are not prepared to match City's bid.

Multiple sources on this one but here is just one of them:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2006769/Alexis-Sanchez-hope-Manchester-City.html


Would love to see Sanchez in the PL, but honestly can't see him turning down Barca.
 

Fady K

Member
Kylehimself said:
Just woke up to see this. So good!
Help Me! said:
Nice! Gonna be a long wait to the start of the season...

I know, right? Looking forward to talking about the next season's games with you guys. As a Chelsea fan, this is one of the best news I've heard in a long time.

Messi said:
looks like bojan is going to roma on a 10 million euro, 5 year contract deal, barca keeping a buy back clause.

:(

Seems like it's bound to happen, which sucks cause Bojan is quite the player and I wanted to see him grow in Barcelona rather than out.

Kylehimself said:
It would be fair to say that near the end Ancelotti wasn't very inspiring. I think that's why we got rid of him, more so than because of the lack of silverware.

I agree - I love Ancelotti, and wish he didn't have to go - especially in the way he was fired. But the problem I felt was the lack of motivation on his part rather than the trophies. In the last few games, there simply wasn't enough motivation. Sure, they lost out the chance to earn the Premiere League cup - but the enthusiasm was definitely lacking - and to be honest the coach seemed bored at the end :( That's one thing I'll always miss about Mourinho - he was always hyper and ready for action.

Messi said:
anelka-drogba.jpg


One of these will go :(

Can't be Drogba. It better not be. He has been the glimmer of hope in most of the games. In the Champions league quarter finals, no one tried as much as he did. Chelsea need him. It would be great to see him under Villa Boas' guidance.
 

dc89

Member
Mastadon said:
Would love to see Sanchez in the PL, but honestly can't see him turning down Barca.

But Barca offered a lower cash offer and they offered that Jefren guy, who has personally said he doesn't like the idea of leaving Barca to go to Udinese. That's the snag. They've not even agreed a transfer fee yet!

'It is clear that I do not like the idea of leaving Barcelona for Udinese,' the 23-year-old told Spanish radio station RAC1.

‘I have spent the past seven years at Barcelona and it was my dream to succeed here.

'I don't think I will make it here, though, and it looks like I have to start looking elsewhere.'

So I think there's a chance!
 

Fady K

Member
Messi said:
No diving and play acting from barca when they tore madrid a new asshole in november last year :0

but I agree the diving was terrible, but madrid were also playing a very rough game. both teams can be ashamed of themself for those games.

At the very least, Barca destroyed Man United without any diving, and against all 11 players. What a beautiful game that was :)
 

Clegg

Member
Tim the Wiz said:
It's really just Barcelona that are provably beyond the reach of our midfield based on the last season, though. (Of course, our away form wasn't good, but that was a pretty universal failing throughout the team.) Carrick-Giggs dominated Chelsea and would have had a decent chance against RM. However, Giggs's passing ability is flowering at the very twilight end of his career (where he can only play every other game) and with Scholes gone, Fletcher coming back from poor form/injury, Anderson yet to advance out of his mode of perpetual potential, Gibson leaving, Hargreaves released and Carrick nearing 30, it's fairly obvious that a reinforcement or two would be helpful. Cleverley will be one, but someone who provides reliably consistent quality will probably be in that bracket, too. At least, until the youth wellspring that won the FA Cup blooms.

There's plenty of realistic signings in that position out there beyond the media darlings of Modric and Sneijder - Defour, M'Vila, Marvin, Ninis, etc. But the summer is yet to start in earnest.

And that's two players - the unplanned Jones and now Young - about done so far. De Gea, too, probably, next week.
I agree that our midfield probably isn't as weak as I made it out to be,but it certainly isn't strong enough in comparison to other teams.I was only 9 when United won the treble but even then I could see that the midfield of Keane,Beckham,Scholes and Giggs was something special.Our midfield now is miles behind those four.The youth players like Cleverley,Morrison and Pogba have the potential to be stars but it's still a bit too soon for them right now.I think Defour would be a good option but the way things are in the transfer market Standard aliege would probably ask for 25 million and theres no way United would pay over the odds for him like that.

Edit:I forgot about Jones to be honest.He struck up a great partnership with Smalling for England at the under 21's which bodes well for the future.I've heard that the de Gea deal is done and all that's left for him to do is switch agents on the first of July.
 

dc89

Member
Fady K said:
At the very least, Barca destroyed Man United without any diving, and against all 11 players. What a beautiful game that was :)

I liked how it shut that Man U fans up for one solitary second!
 

Fady K

Member
dc89 said:
I liked how it shut that Man U fans up for one solitary second!

I felt the same thing when Man City beat Man U in the FA Cup semi - it was a beautiful game, and it was nice to see that Man City today is nothing like the Man City of the past few decades.
 

WJD

Member
Fady K said:
I felt the same thing when Man City beat Man U in the FA Cup semi - it was a beautiful game, and it was nice to see that Man City today is nothing like the Man City of the past few decades.

lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom