The voice is just another instrument.
Yorke's voice on Reckoner is one of my favourite things ever. That song is a masterpiece.
I can see why one would dislike Oasis, but not The Killers =(
Anyway, if you were dragged to one of their concerts, I'm sure you'd enjoy it.
I've seen them before haha! I just think they're very bland. He has a technically pretty good but unremarkable voice, I just don't feel like there's anything special about them whatsoever. Mr Brightside's quite fun to sing in a club, but they're just extremely boring. Radiohead, even if they're what you could describe as boring I suppose, musically they're incredible; the National Anthem, Myxomatosis, Paranoid Android, Climbing Up The Walls. I don't even recognise anything instrumentally fantastic in the Killers' songs.