Blargonaut
Banned
acohrs, WhereAreMahDragonz, Kawl_USC, Crab, *Splinter or Faddy. The socialite, the guerrilla, the know-it-all, the muscle and the sidewinder.
Next?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Gafia 3 [Mafia] | Welcome to Lynchwood Acres
- Thread starter Ourobolus
- Start date
acohrs, WhereAreMahDragonz, Kawl_USC, Crab, *Splinter or Faddy. The socialite, the guerrilla, the know-it-all, the muscle and the sidewinder.
Next?
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
You don't lynch a PR claim at this point that can be verified (though that's suspect since they can be roleblocked). Also, blow hot air somewhere else, him retracting doesn't matter in the least. Either he is scum or he isn't, if he's not then scum sin't going to suddenly believe if he say "hey! j/k! lolol"
We can't verify Bronx either way. For example, suppose both Stanley and Bronx are scum. If they're both alive tomorrow, it could just be because Stanley was never poisoned in the first place. Nevertheless, Bronx would be busy claiming he cured Stanley and we would be busy buying Bronx's claim. This is my point: we fundamentally cannot verify Bronx. Whether or not we lynch him depends on what you think of his claim.
Blargonaut
Banned
This is an opportunity, folks, don't squander it!
Crab, you're here, you know how to ask questions.
Crab, you're here, you know how to ask questions.
Blargonaut
Banned
Am I being too earnest, is that it? Crab, tell me, am I being too earnest?
Blargonaut
Banned
Sorian, I'm just waiting. C'mon, c'mon.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Despite Sorian's post it was never Swamped.
1) If Swamped is town, no one will go to bat for her.
2) If Swamped is scum, her teammates will ignore her and go elsewhere.
Blargonaut
Banned
You all want D1 back, is that it? I can give that to you, I can give you D1 back. Do you want D1 back?
You all want D1 back, is that it? I can give that to you, I can give you D1 back. Do you want D1 back?
yes pls wtb time machine
Blargonaut
Banned
It's okay, I understand. You're typing, typing it out.
I'm the muscle? Nice.
I thought it was between me and you for Sidewinder?
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
Why are you worth saving Stan?
because town deaths equals sooner win for scum. tends to be a god idea to prevent those when possible.
why, whatever other reason could there possibly be?
SERIOUS SIDENOTE
if poison = neutral, stan = scum not impossible
but zzz obviously not ez to prove so back to the regular programming
hold up lemmie make sure im reading this right, your saying that if the poisoner is a neutral, then you can be sure im not scum?
i dont follow that logic at all.
Blargonaut
Banned
I'm the muscle? Nice.
I SAID CRAB IS THE FUCKING MUSCLE, *SPLINTER
DID YOU SEND ME THAT MESSAGE?
WHO THE FUCK ARE YOU
Blargonaut
Banned
*Splinter, what is your Role? Your Alignment, what is it? By "who are you", I was asking what your Role-name is, *Splinter. Do you have Power(s)? What is your Power(s)?
Blargonaut
Banned
yes pls wtb time machine
fine
I'm you, Blarg.*Splinter, what is your Role? Your Alignment, what is it? By "who are you", I was asking what your Role-name is, *Splinter. Do you have Power(s)? What is your Power(s)?
We all are.
Blargonaut
Banned
I'm you, Blarg.
We all are.
Finally.
So tell me, what did Ourob write as my Role-self's flavour text? I've been dying to know, just tell me while you're still in-game so I don't have to get you flipped, thanks.
Despite Sorian's post it was never Swamped.
swamped (3)
sorian 62 (135)
verelios 396 (1234)
crab 1207
ccs 1275
blargonaut 1297 (1303)
kalor 1317
End of day Crab votes to make it 2 on Swamped.
Vere unvotes -seems legit since that is an early vote
So back to 1. CCS then moves to Swamped (and this is where the fake momentum seems to come from). Sorian for some reason wants Swamped but never put his vote there
Blarg does a drive by vote/unvote.
So Swamped was a legit threat to be lynch for 6 posts.
Kalor's vote comes in after me and Natiko put our votes on squidy which had made it a clear squid vs crab situation.
Once those votes play out it is 4 on Crab and on Squidy. Pretty quickly Kawl and Stan come in and push it over the top.
If you want to look for votes that saved Swamped I don't think you will find any (unless you want to count Blarg who was just messing with ties imo)
If you want to look at votes that saved Crab then you have CCS, Me, Natiko, Stan and Kawl.
Natiko flipped town (and I know I'm town) so that leaves me with 3 candidates for scum mates if we flip Crab scum. CCS is my top target but I haven't rule out the other 2 as well.
We can keep pretending that Swamped wasn't a thing but that's all hindsight. In the moment, she was just as likely as Crab and Squidy was the surprise.
We can't verify Bronx either way. For example, suppose both Stanley and Bronx are scum. If they're both alive tomorrow, it could just be because Stanley was never poisoned in the first place. Nevertheless, Bronx would be busy claiming he cured Stanley and we would be busy buying Bronx's claim. This is my point: we fundamentally cannot verify Bronx. Whether or not we lynch him depends on what you think of his claim.
Yeah, if no one else gets poisoned that's a pretty clear sign. There's murky water everywhere, for example a person getting killed and poisoned in the same night so obviously none of it is a perfect science but jumping at any PR claim on day 2 is just bad play.
Blargonaut
Banned
spoilers for Westworld
Blargonaut
Banned
I mean, not on this page
Ignore that
Ignore that
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
oh yeah, before i dissapear for the day i should probably say something thats not about my possible imminent death, i may be able to keep up, but work is hectic right now so no promises.
well, i still really feel that CCS is scum, its more my gut than my mind saying this, but its saying it pretty darn loudly.
im kinda losing my town vibe on crab, though that just may be to compete disagreement on bronx
oh i should say, even if my life didnt depend on it, i think i believe bronx, given both his play in the last few games, and the way day 1 played out for him, a panic claim like that makes the most sense to me than any bizarre scum gambit.
nin, please speak more, give us anything buddy, anything at all.
i dont know if i said this earlier, but iv pretty much turned around on faddy (from scum lean to town, for those not keeping score at home), quite liking his play now.
everything else gets a ehhhhhh from me for now.
well, i still really feel that CCS is scum, its more my gut than my mind saying this, but its saying it pretty darn loudly.
im kinda losing my town vibe on crab, though that just may be to compete disagreement on bronx
oh i should say, even if my life didnt depend on it, i think i believe bronx, given both his play in the last few games, and the way day 1 played out for him, a panic claim like that makes the most sense to me than any bizarre scum gambit.
nin, please speak more, give us anything buddy, anything at all.
i dont know if i said this earlier, but iv pretty much turned around on faddy (from scum lean to town, for those not keeping score at home), quite liking his play now.
everything else gets a ehhhhhh from me for now.
Blargonaut
Banned
I neeeeddd somethinnng to shitpossstt oonnnnnnnnnn, ughhhhhhhhhhhhhh
I need material, please
Am I supposed to be commenting on Bronx right now? Or Crab, Swamped? CCS? Is that it?
shhhhiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiitttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
I need material, please
Am I supposed to be commenting on Bronx right now? Or Crab, Swamped? CCS? Is that it?
shhhhiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiitttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
Blargonaut
Banned
WHAT KIND OF 24-PLAYER GAME HAS ONLY ONE NIGHT-KILL ON THE FIRST NIGHT
I mean, granted there's allegedly Poison, but c'mon
HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO WORK WITH THIS
THIS
ISN'T
POSSIBLE
I mean, granted there's allegedly Poison, but c'mon
HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO WORK WITH THIS
THIS
ISN'T
POSSIBLE
Blargonaut
Banned
Oh, I'm supposed to being reading your posts, that's it
of course
of course
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
UNVOTE: Bronx-man
In the interests of avoiding tunnelling, I'm going to re-examine D1's end. I still want to lynch Bronx, but there's diminishing returns setting in now for my focus. So I'll be examining some other cases as we speak.
In the interests of avoiding tunnelling, I'm going to re-examine D1's end. I still want to lynch Bronx, but there's diminishing returns setting in now for my focus. So I'll be examining some other cases as we speak.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
WHAT KIND OF 24-PLAYER GAME HAS ONLY ONE NIGHT-KILL ON THE FIRST NIGHT
I mean, granted there's allegedly Poison, but c'mon
HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO WORK WITH THIS
THIS
ISN'T
POSSIBLE
Also, this is actually a really good point which I missed. There will definitely be more kills than this. At a kill per night, we'd be here for a very long time indeed. I don't think the poisoner would be multi-hit; it's normally a scum role and giving scum two consistent kills is highly unusual. So there's probably another killing role of some variety that went AWOL last night. Something for any protective roles or blocking roles to bear in mind about their targets, certainly.
Blargonaut
Banned
CRABBBBBB
I can whine better than you, Craaaaaaaab
But I think your whine is more fruitful, ha
get it
It's another food joke
hahahahaha
I can whine better than you, Craaaaaaaab
But I think your whine is more fruitful, ha
get it
It's another food joke
hahahahaha
Blargonaut
Banned
ooh I forgot to type acorns instead of acohrs in my top-of-the-page listings, there goes my food joke cred
I think Blarg is telling the truth about receiving a note. His desperation to find out who sent it seems very genuine. Why do you think the 'Blargonaut' character sent it to you?
I don't think so.
This is just like DR3 day 2 when he claimed he had been doused by an arsonist.
Also, this is actually a really good point which I missed. There will definitely be more kills than this. At a kill per night, we'd be here for a very long time indeed. I don't think the poisoner would be multi-hit; it's normally a scum role and giving scum two consistent kills is highly unusual. So there's probably another killing role of some variety that went AWOL last night. Something for any protective roles or blocking roles to bear in mind about their targets, certainly.
A poisoner is only barely functionally different than an arsonist. There is nothing setting it up as a for sure scum role. I'm also re-evaluating because between this hard stance on a PR claim and that slight push at role fishing, maybe I gave you too much credit day 1.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
Kawl, what do you think of Sorian?
I don't think so.
This is just like DR3 day 2 when he claimed he had been doused by an arsonist.
And I'd have to agree here if I'm being honest. Blarg is fun and all but I'll wait until day 3 before believing that something happened to him over night. Surprised Swamped is interested though.
Blargonaut
Banned
Also, this is actually a really good point which I missed. There will definitely be more kills than this. At a kill per night, we'd be here for a very long time indeed. I don't think the poisoner would be multi-hit; it's normally a scum role and giving scum two consistent kills is highly unusual. So there's probably another killing role of some variety that went AWOL last night. Something for any protective roles or blocking roles to bear in mind about their targets, certainly.
So many words for something I just realized while on this 50ppp page
Sorian, attack Crab pls
So many words for something I just realized while on this 50ppp page
Sorian, attack Crab pls
Sir, yes, sir.
Blargonaut
Banned
I think Blarg is telling the truth about receiving a note. His desperation to find out who sent it seems very genuine. Why do you think the 'Blargonaut' character sent it to you?
It's true, all of it
I need to know what my flavour text is, Swamped
I want to know what my words taste like
Greater love hath no man, than he who lays down his life for his friends.
Crab, j'accuse!
Sorian, j'accuse!
Stan, j'accuse!
Verelios, j'accuse!
WAMD, j'accuse!
Are we all teammates?
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
If I'm scum, then fuck are my team up for early busses alright. I can count the people defending me on the fingers of one pincer.
Are we all teammates?
These are indeed my famous five.
Disclaimer: my gut reads are less accurate than throwing darts at a fucking wall.
Blargonaut
Banned
wait, why would Blarg send me this message
Blarg wouldn't have such a shitty, shitty Power
Ourob wouldn't write Blarg like that
Blarg wouldn't have such a shitty, shitty Power
Ourob wouldn't write Blarg like that
Blargonaut
Banned
These are indeed my famous five.
Disclaimer: my gut reads are less accurate than throwing darts at a fucking wall.
I KNOW I'M IN THIS GAME
ARE YOU?
I KNOW I'M IN THIS GAME
ARE YOU?
I am beyond the game.
Beyond time.
Beyond death.
Only the gut reads are real.
I am the Force and the Force is with me.
I don't think so.
This is just like DR3 day 2 when he claimed he had been doused by an arsonist.
And I'm guessing there was no arsonist in that game? UGHHHH
It was a weirdly elaborate(why) ruse to...do somethingAnd I'm guessing there was no arsonist in that game? UGHHHH
I don't think so.
This is just like DR3 day 2 when he claimed he had been doused by an arsonist.
And I'm guessing there was no arsonist in that game? UGHHHH
Keep in mind Blarg was also town despite all of that.
As of right now I don't have a strong read on him one way or another. He is one I plan to look at in greater detail this evening.Kawl, what do you think of Sorian?
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
As of right now I don't have a strong read on him one way or another. He is one I plan to look at in greater detail this evening.
I would have thought you'd have been on him already, he's the obvious player to be checking up on.
Blargonaut
Banned
And I'm guessing there was no arsonist in that game? UGHHHH
I didn't know that at the time