Support NeoGAF

IJoel · Nov 6, 2004

Edit: BTW, this was taken from the TeamXbox forums.

Guns N' Poops · Nov 6, 2004

...explosion

Definately too low., if true.

snapty00 · Nov 6, 2004

Wouldn't that cause suicide rates to increase?

Do The Mario · Nov 6, 2004

I don't think thats real

*buys some popcorn

Hiro_Kunimi_80 · Nov 6, 2004

http://www.gamespot.com/misc/editorschoice/

Fake

no " halo 2 "
no " prince of persia ps2 "

Duke Juan the Beast · Nov 6, 2004

Pikmin 2 > Halo 2

LA BOMBE BOMBE!

edit: nuts, it would have been fun

IJoel · Nov 6, 2004

Hiro_Kunimi_80 said:
http://www.gamespot.com/misc/editorschoice/

Fake

no " halo 2 "
no " prince of persia ps2 "

It was supposedly taken down.

captainbiotch · Nov 6, 2004

How controversial!

Now just wait for the Gamespot hate.

*chomp*

Edit: Shucks

Grubdog · Nov 6, 2004

Pikmin 2 > Halo 2

edit: bah, beaten

well then, Paper Mario > Halo 2

Redbeard · Nov 6, 2004

That would be impossible to photoshop. It must be real!

snapty00 · Nov 6, 2004

Redbeard said:
That would be impossible to photoshop. It must be real!

An easier way would be just to grab the HTML, insert a couple of table rows with data, and then type the URL in the address box at the top of the browser to make it appear that it's coming from the real source.

But who knows if that's what they did.

thorns · Nov 6, 2004

the names of the images makes me think that they're fake though..
halowned.jpg and halo2flops.jpg

Project Midway · Nov 6, 2004

OMG! I'm now getting GCN and Metroid Prime instead.

Kon Tiki · Nov 6, 2004

Project Midway said:
OMG! I'm now getting GCN and Metroid Prime instead.

Smart man.

Obviously it is fake. Halo 2 ... Editor's choice? Does not make sense.

Kon Tiki · Nov 6, 2004

Joe · Nov 6, 2004

A) http://www.2and2.net/Uploads/Images/Untitled5.png

B) http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v516/yo-wassup/halowned.jpg

image A lists call of duty and gta double pack (xbox) while image B does not. how come?

image A has metroid prime 2 echoes at 9.9???? :lol

silly nbots.

Kon Tiki · Nov 6, 2004

B is a horrible horrible fake.

COD and GTA DP show up for me.
http://www.gamespot.com/misc/editorschoice/

IJoel · Nov 6, 2004

Yes, it's quite easy to fake this. It's actually more likely than not that it's fake, considering the hour.

RETURN MY POPCORN!

HARRRRRRRRR

Kon Tiki · Nov 6, 2004

Joe said:
image A has metroid prime 2 echoes at 9.9???? :lol

Whoa. Good eye. 9.9 Damn.

Joe · Nov 6, 2004

oh no...

http://img131.exs.cx/my.php?loc=img131&image=notagain.jpg

Project Midway · Nov 6, 2004

Ninbots are getting desperate. :lol

And I cant blame them.

gollumsluvslave · Nov 6, 2004

That took all of 10 minutes...

It probably is 9.1 tho

Kon Tiki · Nov 6, 2004

Hmm

http://www.gamespot.com/xbox/action/halo2/review.html

Says 'blank'.

Normally when a game's review is not up it says 'page not found'. Like this, maybe it was there.

Vitten · Nov 6, 2004

So what ? I'll never understand the obsession some people have with game sites or magazines not giving the score they want a certain game to have.

It's as if they feel personally insulted or something.. very strange..

Zaptruder · Nov 6, 2004

These are the same bastards that gave AC5 a 8.3 (8.5?) score! Fuck 'em!

Hitler Stole My Potato · Nov 6, 2004

bo'dastalie · Nov 6, 2004

Says 'blank'.

Normally when a game's review is not up it says 'page not found'. Like this, maybe it was there.

cheque not cleared yet ?

Seriously, if 9.1 is true then it's a bit lowish, because Halo2 is much more enjoyable as Halo for me because of the better framerate.

radioheadrule83 · Nov 6, 2004

Hitler Stole My Potato · Nov 6, 2004

I'll take a large bag of plain BS please. No butter.

Funky Papa · Nov 6, 2004

@ Oli's cousin

deadhorse32 · Nov 6, 2004

Society said:
Hmm

http://www.gamespot.com/xbox/action/halo2/review.html

Says 'blank'.

Normally when a game's review is not up it says 'page not found'. Like this, maybe it was there.

http://www.gamespot.com/gamecube/action/metroidprime2/review.html

He is right ! 9.1 is true

luxsol · Nov 6, 2004

So if it was true and they deleted it, does that mean when they post the review score again and it has a higher score that the higher score was given because of possible ad revenue taken away (or something along those lines)? OMG!... something something (too sleepy to think of something clever)!!

Pedigree Chum · Nov 6, 2004

If 9.1 is the true score, it will cause this forum to implode.

GSG Flash · Nov 6, 2004

The reason why it says blank is because they have the review finished, so they have the review page ready to just put the review in they did it with fable. When is GS's review going up anyways?

TheGreenGiant · Nov 6, 2004

radioheadrule83 said:

That had me laughing out loud. Good work. Funny

Sai · Nov 6, 2004

GSG Flash said:
When is GS's review going up anyways?

Sunday at noon Pacific, if I remember correctly.

TheGreenGiant · Nov 6, 2004

GSG Flash said:
The reason why it says blank is because they have the review finished, so they have the review page ready to just put the review in they did it with fable. When is GS's review going up anyways?

It's meant to go up on Sunday. Not long now!

:eats popcorn:

by the way. 9.1 is a great score from Gamespot. Absolutely splooglicious.

bitwise · Nov 6, 2004

GSG Flash said:
The reason why it says blank is because they have the review finished, so they have the review page ready to just put the review in they did it with fable. When is GS's review going up anyways?

sunday.

Bregor · Nov 6, 2004

Why not just wait a day- then you will know for sure what the score is.

Redbeard · Nov 6, 2004

9.1 is impossible; that would mean Halo 2 isn't even as good as Riddick.

SantaC · Nov 6, 2004

:/ and I was half-through making popcorn.

TheGreenGiant · Nov 6, 2004

just wanted to add that that user's net surfer top bar is full of junky ads. Urgh.

ced · Nov 6, 2004

Redbeard said:
9.1 is impossible; that would mean Halo 2 isn't even as good as Riddick.

Yeah this is my problem with reviews, they are just not consistant.

I mean GS gives the original a 9.7, and from all accounts Halo 2 is leaps and bounds better. The only complaint Ive seen is the texture pop in, and a cliffhanger ending.

Oh well wait for tomorrow I guess.

GSG Flash · Nov 6, 2004

TheGreenGiant said:
just wanted to add that that user's net surfer top bar is full of junky ads. Urgh.

That's what the guy gets for using anything other than firefox

Ghost · Nov 6, 2004

Hopefully it'll score the same as Halo did back in 2001

Deg · Nov 6, 2004

Its a 9.9 according to someone on another forum.

TheGreenGiant · Nov 6, 2004

Ghost said:
Hopefully it'll score the same as Halo did back in 2001

and waht's that. Too lazy to search

Firefox? Is it really better?

thorns · Nov 6, 2004

TheGreenGiant said:
and waht's that. Too lazy to search

Firefox? Is it really better?

firefox + google toolbar add-on rocks, but it can be a problematic on SOME sites, it's quite rare though. it's hard to go back to ie after tabbed browsing though..

Solid · Nov 6, 2004

Deg said:
Its a 9.9 according to someone on another forum.

I also think it will get 9.9, or 9.8. Not under 9.7, that's for sure.

bitwise · Nov 6, 2004

"I believe this news"

Support NeoGAF

Gamespot Halo 2 Review Score Leaked!? Popcorn Inside!

Member

Banned

Banned

Unconfirmed Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Banned

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

FUNK-Y-PPA-4

Bad Art 

Member

Banned

Nobody ruins my family vacation but me...and maybe the boy!

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Nobody ruins my family vacation but me...and maybe the boy!

Chili Con Carnage!

Banned

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Similar threads

Bad Art