It's not always that binary (Simple).
I kind of agree with him and I think it wrong that he is accused of being a troll because he doesn't see the 'dramatic' change that you or others may see, is there no middle ground?, Yes I can see there is a difference but I'm not a graphics expert and on the surface to me it doesn't look a lot different and I'm being genuinely honest, I think it's just a case of different people have a different scales of what they consider largely different.
I've seen people on here say that a game with no AA compared to a game with 4xAA is a massive difference, others would barely see it, I look at those two pictures and yes they look different in many respects but they also look very similar also, I mean they are the same game for a start with many similar components in them, for some people that is enough to be classified as similar, they are not seeing the extra 'tech' in the images.
You have to imagine sometimes that not everyone perceives things as you do.