I've yet to see a single person make a coherent argument to why it's good, much less GOTY material.
Or was that same, drawn-out, overly fucking long pickup animation which was reused for nearly every interaction in the game that fucking majestic to see over and over again over the course of 60+ hours?
Oh, I've played a lot of games. I've played a lot of bad games, and sometimes in those there's something worth enjoying, something exciting, something that makes up for the surrounding badness - or at least they tried. Tried to do something different.
DAI is simply, "let's put all the worse shit in MMOs into this bad RPG with a villain that is completely ineffective with a cast of characters that are all varying degrees of insufferable in their own unique ways."