• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Giant Bomb #16 | DO... DONK...

Status
Not open for further replies.
im with jeff, offsides is a stupid rule. if you hang back, you cost your team a defensive player so there's a risk reward to it.

it's not like basketball has been hurting due to this. It seems like a lousy rule invented by someone constantly on the losing end of the game whining that ITS NOT FAIR, like those people who complain that throws aren't fair in fighting games.
 

DanRyckert

A good strange little man
I'm a little surprised Dan didn't know the US women are the best in the world. Not because it's information he would seek out, but because at some point in the past decade he must have accidentally heard that enough for it to stick in the "U! S! A!" part of his brain.

Rooting for anything soccer-related is thoroughly un-American.
 

Archaix

Drunky McMurder
im with jeff, offsides is a stupid rule. if you hang back, you cost your team a defensive player so there's a risk reward to it.

it's not like basketball has been hurting due to this. It seems like a lousy rule invented by someone constantly on the losing end of the game whining that ITS NOT FAIR, like those people who complain that throws aren't fair in fighting games.


Offside is like 90% of the reason I wouldn't ever watch soccer as more than an oddity.

Rooting for anything soccer-related is thoroughly un-American.


But if the US wins the men's and women's world cup I'm pretty sure legally everybody else has to call it soccer for four years. That seems like it should be right, at least. Then you'd be rooting both for the US and for the goal of annoying soccer fans all over the world. That's gotta be worth something.
 

GavinGT

Banned
Look, I couldn't tell you who won the Super Bowl last year, or the World Series, or the Stanley Cup, or the....basketball one.
 
If offside didn't exist, with how accurately midfielders and defenders can distribute the ball nowadays from pretty much any distance, you'd just have a long ball game with target men trained specifically to win the ball in the air. Goal poaching shouldn't be rewarded.
 
America cares so little about soccer and/or women's soccer that the only reason I know USA won is because some of the japanese accounts I follow on twitter were talking about it.

I had to learn that the USA was good at soccer via Japanese musicians and game devs.
 

GavinGT

Banned
If offside didn't exist, with how accurately midfielders and defenders can distribute the ball nowadays from pretty much any distance, you'd just have a long ball game with target men trained specifically to win the ball in the air. Goal poaching shouldn't be rewarded.

But, like Jeff said, why not just have two offsides lines like they have in hockey?
 

Archaix

Drunky McMurder
If offside didn't exist, with how accurately midfielders and defenders can distribute the ball nowadays from pretty much any distance, you'd just have a long ball game with target men trained specifically to win the ball in the air. Goal poaching shouldn't be rewarded.



Putting the ball in the goal should be rewarded and encouraged.

Look, I couldn't tell you who won the Super Bowl last year, or the World Series, or the Stanley Cup, or the....basketball one.


I couldn't either, but I still knew the women won the world cup this summer because it was all over actual news and social media in ways that those other championships aren't.
 

Mature

Member
I absolutely love their sports games quick looks. Especially when they have little familiarity with the actual sport.
I was just thinking this while watching the FIFA quick look. Danny's occasional frustration with Dan is really good too.
 

Myggen

Member
But, like Jeff said, why not just have two offsides lines like they have in hockey?

The few times I've watched hockey I'm always really confused about how offside works, but I don't care enough to look it up. So I'm just surprised every time there's an offside.

edit: Also, this FIFA 16 QL was really good. But I'm not really a fan of the game itself, feels like they're just making it slower and slower each year.
 
Finished base Destiny last night. Might have been one of the worst final bosses I've ever seen in my life. Fuck.

The Crota and House of Wolves stuff was considerably better than the main story missions, but wow am I glad I didn't pay $90 with tax for this last year.
 

GavinGT

Banned
The few times I've watched hockey I'm always really confused about how offside works, but I don't care enough to look it up. So I'm just surprised every time there's an offside.

If any player on the offensive team crosses the other team's blue line before the puck, that's an offside.
 
If offside didn't exist, with how accurately midfielders and defenders can distribute the ball nowadays from pretty much any distance, you'd just have a long ball game with target men trained specifically to win the ball in the air. Goal poaching shouldn't be rewarded.

that sounds like a more exciting game to watch. having watched that argentina vs chile match during the summer i was bored to tears with the lack of anything happening at all. maybe throw out some of the more restrictive rules that penalize the better fielding team that favors a more balanced game and let people get wrecked
 

tchocky

Member
But, like Jeff said, why not just have two offsides lines like they have in hockey?

In a way they have it since you can not be offside in your own half.

If they removed the offside rule defenders would never be able to leave the edge of their own box becaause for example Barcelona would just leave Messi, Neymar and Suarez at the edge of the box so the defense would have to stay back and the opponents would do the same which leaves only the midfielders in the middle 80 yards it would be awful football.
 

GavinGT

Banned
Oh okay, seems easy enough. But with how fucking fast hockey is it'll probably still confuse me.

It's confusing when the defense knocks the puck out of their zone even for just a second, forcing everyone on offense to leave the zone before the puck can go back in.
 
Oid7QQ6.gif
 

AcridMeat

Banned
Also, this FIFA 16 QL was really good. But I'm not really a fan of the game itself, feels like they're just making it slower and slower each year.
They kind of artificially slowed it down because pace has been such an overpowered thing the last few years. At least now I've had way more plays that resembled the real thing in terms of build up and reward than previously, when I could just run past to the goal. A ton of fast players had their speed ratings nerfed, it's a bit ridiculous.

I like it because I can finally use slow players who are really good otherwise.
Hockey seems like the best sport.
With how bad the referees are in basketball, it kind of is.
 

Myggen

Member
They kind of artificially slowed it down because pace has been such an overpowered thing the last few years. At least now I've had way more plays that resembled the real thing in terms of build up and reward than previously, when I could just run past to the goal. A ton of fast players had their speed ratings nerfed, it's a bit ridiculous.

I like it because I can finally use slow players who are really good otherwise.

Yeah, that's how it feels like. Ronaldo was so overpowered last year, even with how good he is in real life. But turns out I like my football games at a certain pace, this year just feels so fucking sluggish to me.
 

Ianan

Member
Does anyone else wish O'Dwyer worked at Giant Bomb full time? He's pretty much the only person that makes me go to Gamespot though, he just fits perfectly with the GB Crew.
 

strafer

member
Does anyone else wish O'Dwyer worked at Giant Bomb full time? He's pretty much the only person that makes me go to Gamespot though, he just fits perfectly with the GB Crew.

He's the only guy I could pick out in a lineup of Gamespot members.

I have no idea about the other guys and girls.
 

Zaph

Member
Does anyone else wish O'Dwyer worked at Giant Bomb full time? He's pretty much the only person that makes me go to Gamespot though, he just fits perfectly with the GB Crew.

Would be nice to see more of him, yeah, but this way GB 'gets' him without having to include him in their budget.

He's the only guy I could pick out in a lineup of Gamespot members.

I have no idea about the other guys and girls.

Mary is Giant Bomb as fuck too. Peter Brown is another gaming oracle like Jeff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom