Dead Rising is a dope fucking game. The time pressure turns it from a mindless open-world game into Supermarket Sweep, where you're planning out your path through the game to either see the most content, level up to make future playthroughs easier, get specific achievements done (which actually rewards you with in-game items), or get a certain ending. It has the best possible progression system
and setting that said gameplay could take place in, and it's got the brand of earnest campiness that only a Japanese developer could bring us.
2 irons out many of the rough edges and is definitely a better playing game, but most of the charm is lost since Chuck is a completely flat protagonist and they straight up ruin Frank's character in Off the Record by making him a stereotypical snarky video game protagonist. They both subscribe to the "video game developer" definition of cool and just rattle off one-liners after they kill psychopaths (which often come off as pale imitations of DR1 psychopaths) and dumb shit like that. Co-op is a whole lot of fun, but the sea of slot machines that is Fortune City gets a little tiresome, and combo weapons make the bosses a little on the easy side (and also turn the notion of finding and using standard weapons into a moot point).
Dead Rising 3 is the cynical "
we want the Call of Duty audience" sell-out game people feared it would be, but that manifests through the gameplay and not so much the aesthetic or attitude of the game. The irreverence remains despite the gritty facade you see at first glance, but anything that could be even remotely seen as challenging (the time pressure, escorting survivors, fighting psychopaths, finding weapons and health, etc) has been turned into a damn cakewalk. It's fun in its own right, but there's a reason a majority of the discussion around Dead Rising 4 has been "what the fuck are you guys
doing?"
Also restarting isn't even a must unless you want the best ending right away.
It's difficult, but you definitely can pull off an Ending S run from the start if you know where things like the shortcut and PP bonuses are. I managed to get the best ending and save everybody possible starting from level 1, so I think new players could get the best ending, especially if they focus on getting PP and doing the cases ASAP over saving everyone they can.