Support NeoGAF

[TraBuch]

Am I imagining things or wasn't Hidden Agenda on the Sony pre-show? Jeff and Alex both said it wasn't.

 

[ThanksVision]

shadow of war will win goty, horizon will beat botw, and destiny 2 will take the number 10 spot over the new colossus in GB's most controversial list to date

e: actually i hope shadow of war wins the best old game of the year

 

[Antiwhippy]

Nah Yakuza will probably hit 10. Vinny and Alex are enjoying it a lot.

 

[hamchan]

Dan's hatred for Yakuza will prevent it from reaching the top 10 and he'll justify it by saying that technically he's the only one who played it.

 

[Tubobutts]

Nah Yakuza will probably hit 10. Vinny and Alex are enjoying it a lot.

But then Jeff will point out how neither of them played it and the one person that did says the playing part is bad and then he'll take it off the list while Alex and Vinny are distracted and no one will notice until the final list is published on the site and Brad just listed Destiny 2 ten times.

 

[darkside31337]

shadow of war will win goty, horizon will beat botw, and destiny 2 will take the number 10 spot over the new colossus in GB's most controversial list to date

e: actually i hope shadow of war wins the best old game of the year

I hope Horizon beats Zelda just because the salt would be immense.

Spoiler

(also because its a better video game)

Mario Odyssey should be the odds on favorite though.

 

[derFeef]

It's not even july folks.

 

[Antiwhippy]

It's not even july folks.

With no #content we need to entertain ourselves somehow.

 

[Backfoggen]

It's not even july folks.

Can't pre-sweat GotY early enough.

 

[darkside31337]

It's not even july folks.

Its the week after E3 theres nothing going on and people are bored.

 

[Ashby]

GOTY doesn't matter.

 

[Dineren]

Has anyone at GB ever tried to get a game they've only watched on to the top 10?

I hope Horizon beats Zelda just because the salt would be immense.

Spoiler

(also because its a better video game)

Mario Odyssey should be the odds on favorite though.

I like Zelda far more than Horizon and I would not be at all surprised if this happens, especially if Brad never goes back to it. Has anyone else put time into it besides Jeff (who ultimately didn't like it enough to finish it)?

 

[hamchan]

We all know Wolfenstein II is a lock.

 

[Antiwhippy]

I'm going to guess that there's no way that horizon hits top 5.

 

[oti]

I hope Horizon beats Zelda just because the salt would be immense.

Spoiler

(also because its a better video game)

You want a worse game to beat the game of the generation? 🤔

 

[JustSurvive]

I think all the games being discussed are going to make the list, here is my projected games (in no order) that make the top 10 assuming all the upcoming releases are as good as expected

- Horizon: Zero Dawn
- Breath of the Wild
- Nier: Automata
- Super Mario Odyssey
- Wolfenstein 2: The New Colossus
- Destiny 2
- Persona 5
- Yakuza 0
- Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle
- Splatoon 2

And these games will get discussed, but not make it:

- COD: WWII
- Assassin's Creed: Origins
- South Park: The Fractured But Whole
- Forza 7
- MvC:I/Injustice 2/Tekken 7
- Middle Earth: Shadow of War

 

[TraBuch]

Persona won't make it. The only people thatve beaten it are Ben and Alex, and neither are in love with the game. Ben in particular seems like he's only focusing on the negatives.

 

[Lunar FC]

We all know Wolfenstein II is a lock.

Needs to at least be top three to make up for the atrocity of The New Order not making the top 10 in the worst year in gaming history.

Edit: Since I got called an edgelord for ripping Zelda, I'll give it another shot today.

 

[Moaradin]

They will force Ben and Alex to cut either Persona or Nier and they will pick Persona to cut.

 

[imBask]

what if instead they force Ben and Alex to cut both and put Call of Duty on there? now we're talking

 

[ThanksVision]

it's gonna be funny when they throw complaints at shadow of war that could totally be applied to shadow of mordor

 

[Seventy70]

1. Breath of the Wild
2. Horizon: Zero Dawn
3. Wolfenstein 2: The New Colossus
4. Destiny 2
5. Super Mario Odyssey
6. Persona 5
7. Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle
8. Splatoon 2
9. Nier: Automata
10. (Some indie/fighting game)

My order. They have lots of Nintendo fans on staff now, so I'm sure BotW is going to get a big push. Super Mario Odyssey could go both ways, but as of now the game is looking very scattered and experimental.

OH shit! I forgot about PUBG. That's definitely going to be on the list. Top 5 probably.

 

[Hindl]

My order. They have lots of Nintendo fans on staff now, so I'm sure BotW is going to get a big push. Super Mario Odyssey could go both ways, but as of now the game is looking very scattered and experimental.

If Odyssey hits its potential it goes over BotW

 

[Antiwhippy]

Mario + Rabbids?

I'm looking forward to it but I don't expect it to be in top 10.

 

[Zaph]

Mario + Rabbids?

I'm looking forward to it but I don't expect it to be in top 10.

it's xcom (2012 goty) and mario (2015 goty).

2 + 5 = 2017 goty confirmed

 

[Lunar FC]

Mario + Rabbids?

I'm looking forward to it but I don't expect it to be in top 10.

Duders seemed crazy into it. I don't really see it, but it's not my type of game.

 

[Dangansona]

Am I imagining things or wasn't Hidden Agenda on the Sony pre-show? Jeff and Alex both said it wasn't.

It absolutely was and they called it some kind of board game when it's an interactive spiritual sequel to Until Dawn. Alex should be all over this game if he knew anything about it.

 

[Seventy70]

Duders seemed crazy into it. I don't really see it, but it's not my type of game.

Yeah, after the Mario in a Rabbids game shock factor wears off, you realize that it'll be a decent X-Com clone at best.

 

[Giganteus]

Dan's hatred for Yakuza will prevent it from reaching the top 10 and he'll justify it by saying that technically he's the only one who played it.

..Alright, now I'm convinced. Vinny/Alex need to take the controller in BitE.

 

[daveo42]

We all know Wolfenstein II is a lock.

After 2014, there's no guarantees if you aren't Destiny, Zelda, or Mario.

Persona won't make it. The only people thatve beaten it are Ben and Alex, and neither are in love with the game. Ben in particular seems like he's only focusing on the negatives.

I'll be disappointed if it doesn't make the top 10. Meaning it definitely won't, especially because there's no way Vinny will be done with the game come GotY.

 

[Antiwhippy]

Yeah, after the Mario in a Rabbids game shock factor wears off, you realize that it'll be a decent X-Com clone at best.

No problem with that, especially on the go.

 

[Lunar FC]

Dan's hatred for Yakuza will prevent it from reaching the top 10 and he'll justify it by saying that technically he's the only one who played it.

Has Dan turned on the game? He was super into it in the first few eps that I watched.

 

[patapuf]

Yeah, after the Mario in a Rabbids game shock factor wears off, you realize that it'll be a decent X-Com clone at best.

That sounds pretty good to me.

There was a real dearth of good Strategy games for the 3DS.

 

[oti]

Yeah, after the Mario in a Rabbids game shock factor wears off, you realize that it'll be a decent X-Com clone at best.

Sounds top 10 to me. Also seeing how crazy polished it is.

 

[Antiwhippy]

Now that the SRPG train might get rolling on the switch with Disgaea 5 and mario + rabbids, I just need more weeb rhythm games and dungeon crawlers and JRPGs and the switch will fulfill my prophecy of a Vita 2.0.

When they start releasing Neptunia games on the switch you'll know that the end is nigh.

 

[oti]

Now that the SRPG train might get rolling on the switch with Disgaea 5 and mario + rabbids, I just need more weeb rhythm games and dungeon crawlers and JRPGs and the switch will fulfill my prophecy of a Vita 2.0.

When they start releasing Neptunia games on the switch you'll know that the end is nigh.

No.



Noooooooooooooooooooooooo.

 

[Meguro]

C'mon Oti.
At least let us get a new Miku game for Switch.

 

[AuthenticM]

Has Dan turned on the game? He was super into it in the first few eps that I watched.

He said he likes the story and the tone of the game, but hates playing it.

I remain of the opinion that the duders should take turns playing the series. Alex or Vinny should play Kiwami, then the other plays 2, then Dan can play 3 if he feels like it.

 

[Antiwhippy]

I already own 3 rhythm games on the switch.

2 of them weeb.

You can't stop this train.

I seriously hope dj max respect gets on the switch too.

 

[oti]

C'mon Oti.
At least let us get a new Miku game for Switch.

Nein.

Elite Beat Agents I allow but not this devil.

He said he likes the story and the tone of the game, but hates playing it.

I remain of the opinion that the duders should take turns playing the series. Alex or Vinny should play Kiwami, then the other plays 2, then Dan can play 3 if he feels like it.

I remain of the opinion that they shouldn't play all Yakuza games.

 

[Antiwhippy]

If you want Dan to actually hate the series let him play 3.

 

[AuthenticM]

I remain of the opinion that they shouldn't play all Yakuza games.

That's a bad opinion.

 

[Giganteus]

He said he likes the story and the tone of the game, but hates playing it.

I remain of the opinion that the duders should take turns playing the series. Alex or Vinny should play Kiwami, then the other plays 2, then Dan can play 3 if he feels like it.

Do you really want them to play that much Yakuza? I love BitE, but going through that much Yakuza is insane to me. INSANE.

I remain of the opinion that they shouldn't play all Yakuza games.

"I'm not stricken with utter madness."

 

[Hindl]

Now that the SRPG train might get rolling on the switch with Disgaea 5 and mario + rabbids, I just need more weeb rhythm games

Iffy but I'll allow it

dungeon crawlers

ok

and JRPGs

I can mess with this

When they start releasing Neptunia games on the switch you'll know that the end is nigh.

NOOOOO

Nein.

Elite Beat Agents I allow but not this devil.



I remain of the opinion that they shouldn't play all Yakuza games.

Rhythm Heaven is pretty alright too

 

[Fantastapotamus]

You can deny it all you want but deep in your heart you already know that neither Persona 5 nor Yakuza will be in the Top 10.

I remain of the opinion that they shouldn't play all Yakuza games.

It was crazy to even say this to begin with. It won't happen.

 

[oti]

Iffy but I'll allow it
ok
I can mess with this

NOOOOO

Rhythm Heaven is pretty alright too

I love Rhythm Heaven!

 

[jambo]

PUBG for GOTY.

It even rhymes.

for the record I don't watch Colin Moriarty I was just being an edgelord

 

[daveo42]

When they start releasing Neptunia games on the switch you'll know that the end is nigh.

Nobody wants those. Not even you. I'd be fine with more VNs tho. Bring all the VNs to the Switch and I'll pick one up.

 

[ferunnico]

I have played over 90 hours of Persona 5, and I'm probably only a couple hours away from seeing the credits. But I haven't played it in weeks, and somehow I have lost all interest to actually go back and finish it. Is that weird?

 

[Fantastapotamus]

Nobody wants those. Not even you. I'd be fine with more VNs tho. Bring all the VNs to the Switch and I'll pick one up.

Let's start by bringing actually good games to the Switch first

I have played over 90 hours of Persona 5, and I'm probably only a couple hours away from seeing the credits. But I haven't played it in weeks, and somehow I have lost all interest to actually go back and finish it. Is that weird?

You have no idea how often that happens to me.