I dont see how anything but PUBG wins GOTY. I feel like everything else has had a detractor where as the most detraction PUBG got was Rorie saying the jank was a little too much.... while saying he thought the game was a ton of fun.
Everyones played it and everyone likes it. Even new people like it. Will on the bombcast? Loves PUBG. Gary Whitta on the bombcast? Loves PUBG. Abby already seems way into it. Dan plays it constantly, Jeff really likes it, Vinny really likes it, Brad really likes it, Ben likes it, even if Mario is 10/10, by the time GOTY is around, there will likely be several staff members that havent played it.