• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Giant Bomb |OT31| I Think it Might Be for Show

S

Strax

Member
imBask said:
Guys i'm watching The Shining

I don't think I like Kubrick movies, i'm bored out of my mind, just like I was when I watched 2001... And i'm really into space stuff and horror movies, that makes it even weirder
Click to expand...

The Shining is one of my fav. movies, top 3 stuff, so I can't understand being bored by it. I get people not liking it but I've never heard people thinking it's boring before. I've never viewed The Shining as horror, to me it's more like a thriller with 1-2 horror scenes/moments. 2001 on the other hand might be the most boring 'mainstream' film ever made unless you're really into filmmaking.
 
G

Gozer the Gozerian

Member
Piston Hyundai said:
they say the best wrestling characters are just the people who portray them turned up to eleven, so I think it goes without saying that Patrick far and away had the best gimmick at the Rumble
Click to expand...

DI01MSsUQAA1jA0.jpg:large
Click to expand...

.
 
A

alr1ght

bish gets all the credit :)
Guys, I will ruin The Shining. When they're outside in the bitter winter cold, no one's breath can be seen. They're all androids.
 
F

Fevaweva

Member
Like all of Kubrick's adaptations, he butcher's the source material for the worse. The Shining, the novel, is at least a million times better than the film.
 
B

BreezyLimbo

Banned
Fevaweva said:
Like all of Kubrick's adaptations, he butcher's the source material for the worse. The Shining, the novel, is at least a million times better than the film.
Click to expand...

They both stand by their own merits, tho. If I watch the movie its not because I want to see an adaptation of the book, and if I read the book its not because I want to read the source material of the movie.
 
F

Fevaweva

Member
BreezyLimbo said:
They both stand by their own merits, tho. If I watch the movie its not because I want to see an adaptation of the book, and if I read the book its not because I want to read the source material of the movie.
Click to expand...
There is 'adaptation' and there is casting Jack Nicholson as a character whose descent into madness is supposed to be a shock.
 
S

Strax

Member
Fevaweva said:
Like all of Kubrick's adaptations, he butcher's the source material for the worse. The Shining, the novel, is at least a million times better than the film.
Click to expand...

Given that The Shining is genarally thought of as one of best movies ever made I think most people are willing let that slide the things he changed. I wish more film adaptations would cut out or change things in novels that don't work, are too long or unnecessary. To Kill a Mockingbird and LOTR would've been terrible movies without all the changes and cuts made.
 
B

BTA

Member
Death Metalist said:
781QCfH.png


I'm all set.
Click to expand...

Ah, I didn't consider donuts. I just bought a cherry pie and some coffee (well, "caffe macchiato") gelato to have with it.

That combined with the garbage I've already eaten today means it's probably best that I didn't consider buying some mini donuts or something.
 
H

Human Trashcan

Banned
Fevaweva said:
Like all of Kubrick's adaptations, he butcher's the source material for the worse. The Shining, the novel, is at least a million times better than the film.
Click to expand...

I have not read the book but The Shining is a fucking brilliant film regardless of how true it is to the novel. The Godfather's not true to the novel either, does that make it bad by default?
 
E

ElectronicOldMen

Banned
Fuck reverence to source material tbh, it super rarely works out. Be creative, do your own thing with it. Being overly slavish to material created in another medium is a hindrance way more often than a help.
 
Z

Zaph

Member
ElectronicOldMen said:
Fuck reverence to source material tbh, it super rarely works out. Be creative, do your own thing with it. Being overly slavish to material created in another medium is a hindrance way more often than a help.
Click to expand...

Yup. If the source material was always held sacred, we wouldn't have the second best film of all time - Starship Troopers
 
T

tryagainlater

Member
Staying true to The Hobbit book would have made a pretty boring fucking movie. I don't blame Jackson for trying to expand on what reads like a summary of a longer story. I do blame him for a lot of the shit in those movies though.

Still not as bad as sexy Shelob though.
 
B

bomma_man

Member
Human Trashcan said:
I have not read the book but The Shining is a fucking brilliant film regardless of how true it is to the novel. The Godfather's not true to the novel either, does that make it bad by default?
Click to expand...

ElectronicOldMen said:
Fuck reverence to source material tbh, it super rarely works out. Be creative, do your own thing with it. Being overly slavish to material created in another medium is a hindrance way more often than a help.
Click to expand...

Zaph said:
Yup. If the source material was always held sacred, we wouldn't have the second best film of all time - Starship Troopers
Click to expand...

Finally, good opinions in this thread
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Oppenheimer debuts in Japan ༼ ༎ຶ ᆺ ༎ຶ༽
Science
41
4K
Winter John replied
Giantbomb gives their opinion on diversity in the gaming industry
Drama Community Cringe 2 3 4 5 6
271
23K
kapshin replied
Accessories giant Turtle Beach acquires rival PDP in $118 million deal
Business
11
944
Quasicat replied
Jeff Grubb: "I got the rumor about Epic Mickey Rebrushed from the same source that said Metroid Prime 4 is coming this year"
Rumor
31
2K
hepfom replied
Jeff Grubb: A new Astrobot game might release later this year
Rumor 2
80
5K
Ar¢tos replied
Top Bottom