I try to agree with you there, and always push to accept that people have different opinions than me...but my brain won't let me! Obviously, these subjective opinions don't matter, but man I liked that movie haha. The first time I saw it, I wasn't blown away, but my appreciation for it increased when I learned all the stuff that happened behind the screen and how much of the stunt work wasn't accomplished with wires or CG. The practical effects and insane stunt work are what I think should be its hallmarks. I didn't really like the character designs either, but the color design in it is just incredible. It's very pretty.
Princess Bride is great, though I know a lot of people who hate it. It's pretty goofy, and Andre the Giant is a treasure in it.