I don't like Michelle because most of her raves/reviews are of the companies she's affiliated with, most make-up she uses in her videos now is by them a lot of the times! Lisa does vogue and big time celebrities and doesn't need youtube money. She has no reason to lie.
I've never liked the way Michelle does make-up even when she wasn't trying as hard. Too many layers, TOO much powder and her way of doing eye make-up is just awful.
I like Lisa because in a lot of her videos she uses very little foundation sometimes only on her chin where she's dark, and very very thin layer of it. She uses a lot less powder, minimal eye make-up. Most beauty girls on youtube put so much stuff on their faces, no wonder their skin looks so horrible without make-up. Moisturiser, sunscreen, primer, thick layer of foundation and a lot of powder etc etc. Lisa mostly only uses a primer that has has primer/sunscreen/moisturiser qualities all in one and then a tiny bit of thin layer of very sheer foundation on her chin and very very little powder on the T-zone.
Everything she's recommended has done amazing things for my problematic skin! I have VERY dry dull skin that is quite lazy when it comes to getting rid of dead skin, scrubs/harsh exfoliators can be quite harmful to the skin and can cause scratches and broken capillaries which is why I don't really use it. I got Dermalogica cream exfoliator on her recommendation and it is AMAZING for getting rid of those dead cells without all that scrubbing. Her skin care videos are amazing.