• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Greece to hold referendum on austerity measures 5 July

Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Well, we're pulling into the end game now. Come midnight Wednesday, the die is cast.
 
What does this even change? Greece voting for Syriza already indicated they wouldn't take any more austerity.

It means that, if that NYT report was accurate and Djelblsmsmms did indeed try to say (paraphrasing) "my way or the highway" in the negotiations, now he'll be acutely aware that he isn't saying that to Syriza or Tsipras, but to Greece, and Greece's position is to tell him to get fucked.
 

cyberheater

PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
So it looks like a no vote.

What does that mean for Greece and staying in the Eurozone?
 

chadskin

Member
Two or three days ago there was a "leak" of a document where it showed how some of the media/tv companies planned to cook up polls, to support the Yes option. It was linked in this thread.
Of course you never know if the documents were legit or a fake.

But now, it may be the case the docs were in fact legit and the poll numbers were manipulated...

The polls are not done by the media but by independent institutes, often at the request of and financed by a media outlet. I'm not familiar with the Greek polling institutes but their results should be published in a more comprehensive, scientific format on the website of the institute as well, the media that requested/financed the poll "just" gets early access. There's nothing you can "hide", unless of course you accuse the institutes of manipulating those polled and/or the results of the polls which you'd need to legitimately prove.

The issue here seems to be 1) there's no previous data available for the polling institutes, it's a one-time referendum which are always a bit harder to predict and 2) possibly outdated methods of polling. But you'd have to look at each poll individually as well as all the data they'll get of the official results and, if done, exit polls to get a better picture of what exactly went wrong. It's sadly not an exact science like math. :)

BTW I predicted a 50%+ vote for "No"! Praise me! ;)

Judging solely by the January 2015 election result and the party's recommendation for the referendum - i.e. Syriza, ANEL and XA "No"; ND, Potami, PASOK, KIDISO "Yes" - it'd be 47.37% for "No" and 41% for "Yes" if we assume everyone votes exactly like the party they voted for in January recommends. 11.64% (includes KKE and other smaller parties) are therefore the unknown quantity. As KKE recommends its voters to spoil their ballots, I assume a majority of them will do just that or at least vote "No" which should be enough to put the "No" vote into 50%+ territory.
 

Ether_Snake

安安安安安安安安安安安安安安安
Yay, The Guardian:

Heads may soon be rolling in the opposition camp.

Demands are growing for Antonis Samaras, the main opposition leader and former prime minister to step down as head of the centre-right New Democracy party following the apparent victory of the ‘NO” vote, reports Helena.
The former finance minister Dora Bakoyannis has called Samaras demanding that he steps down with immediate effect, several media outlets are reporting.

There are signs that some traditional New Democracy party supporters deliberately voted no (when the party had urged Greeks to vote yes) out of protest against Samaras who has refused to resign.
 

Griss

Member
Tsipras actually did it, the madman. With so many people and parties (including so many in the Greek media) lined up against him I was sure he'd lose the referendum to the politics of fear, but the Greek people have backed him to get them out of this mess. That's astonishing courage, and I dearly hope it's rewarded. It was a kind of courage I could never imagine my people (Irish) coming up with. And a clear majority means a clear mandate. This is huge.

Finally the troika have met their match, and either a better deal within the EZ or economic freedom outside of it will now be the result. A yes vote would have achieved nothing but continuing the futile austerity and pain of the last 5 years. I'm over the moon about this.

Also, having read this thread for a week now I'd just like to say that if there was a GAF election I'd vote for Ether_Snake.
 

Morfeo

The Chuck Norris of Peace
Between a sure death and an unsure future, I know what I would have voted, and I am glad the greeks agreed. Lets hope the troika will show democracy some respect after this.
 

ElTorro

I wanted to dominate the living room. Then I took an ESRAM in the knee.
What does this even change? Greece voting for Syriza already indicated they wouldn't take any more austerity.

I don't see anything changing either.

The stalemate at the negotiation table will likely continue. From the point of view of the creditors, they have already moved away from their original demands as much as they say they can account for (like decreasing the target surplus from 3% GDP to 1% GDP). And Tsipras can't agree to that deal or any deal that is worse than that. Additionally, the fact that the 2nd bailout program has expired will make the next steps only more complicated and time-consuming.

If that stalemate continues, the ELAs won't increase any further, and Greece will default on its upcoming payments.
 

cyberheater

PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
I guess that means that the rest of europe will continue to pump a shitload of money into a country that don't want / is unable to fix it's broken economy.

Probably because a Eurozone country can't been seen to fail.

Dark days ahead for greece. They don't want austerity, but now it will be forced upon them and much worse than had they agreed to reforms.

Didn't they just vote not to have this done to them?
 
I don't see anything changing either.

The stalemate at the negotiation table will likely continue. From the point of view of the creditors, they have already moved away from their original demands as much as they say they can account for (like decreasing the target surplus from 3% GDP to 1% GDP). And Tsipras can't agree to that deal or any deal that is worse than that. Additionally, the fact that the 2nd bailout program has expired will make the next steps only more complicated and time-consuming.

If that stalemate continues, the ELAs won't increase any further, and Greece will default on its upcoming payments.

I would say that the referendum gives the other EU states just the political legitimation of pushing Greece out in whatever way.
 

ElTorro

I wanted to dominate the living room. Then I took an ESRAM in the knee.
Didn't they just vote not to have this done to them?

If you don't have any money and just took a piss at the only people left willing to lend you money, then 'austerity' is not something that is done to you. You just don't have any money left, at least not for imports. You can spend as much of your new currency as you can get from taxes, but you won't be able to spend it on anything that is not produced inside the country. And Greece doesn't produce a lot.
 

Ether_Snake

安安安安安安安安安安安安安安安
Tsipras actually did it, the madman. With so many people and parties (including so many in the Greek media) lined up against him I was sure he'd lose the referendum to the politics of fear, but the Greek people have backed him to get them out of this mess. That's astonishing courage, and I dearly hope it's rewarded. It was a kind of courage I could never imagine my people (Irish) coming up with. And a clear majority means a clear mandate. This is huge.

Finally the troika have met their match, and either a better deal within the EZ or economic freedom outside of it will now be the result. A yes vote would have achieved nothing but continuing the futile austerity and pain of the last 5 years. I'm over the moon about this.

Also, having read this thread for a week now I'd just like to say that if there was a GAF election I'd vote for Ether_Snake.

lol, I would probably get a negative result, as in -X%.

edit: For those wondering what's next, obviously the Debt Cut is now on the table, thanks to the IMF report + No vote.
 

erale

Member
I invite you to look at where nearly all of that money was actually going.

Go on. But don't quote Varoufakis and his 90% of the money went to european banks.

Yes some money went back to the actual loaners (I know it's shocking that they want their money back). But a lot of money went into creating new jobs in the government and also raising government employees wages.
 

KHlover

Banned
Hope European politicians respect the Greek decision and stop wasting more money dragging them along in this pitable state. At this point a full crash seems like the better option for everyone involved tbh. Harsh times ahead in Greece, but I hope they can pull through.
 
When in doubt, remember that Google Translator has an option to speak words. And that the pronunciation tends to be correct for major languages.
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
what? no. it's "oche" as in the English e (not i) and ch like in Chanukka but softer.

No way. I was in Cyprus two weeks ago and everyone says okie but with the k muffled.
 
o-chee should be right for English speakers.

Btw, Greeks are partying like there's no tomorrow.

gjn81wvxqsq6yzcwubok.png
 
Good luck to Greece I guess. Back to negotiations, but now with no money in the bank.

edit: For those wondering what's next, obviously the Debt Cut is now on the table, thanks to the IMF report + No vote.
I don't see that as very obvious. The Greeks might be for that, but the other Euro countries need to explain that somehow to their populations. Won't be easy.

Hope European politicians respect the Greek decision and stop wasting more money dragging them along in this pitable state. At this point a full crash seems like the better option for everyone involved tbh. Harsh times ahead in Greece, but I hope they can pull through.
It's not just about the Greek people. Taxpayers of the other countries are the ones paying that money if it doesn't get paid back.
 

ElTorro

I wanted to dominate the living room. Then I took an ESRAM in the knee.
I would say that the referendum gives the other EU states just the political legitimation of pushing Greece out in whatever way.

The unwillingness to give somebody money on their terms instead of your own is now an active act of pushing somebody out? If Europe wanted to push Greece out, they could have done that much earlier before they gave Greece hundreds of billions of Euros, the equivalent of many, many Marshall plans.

It's fair to say that Europe's plans over the last five years haven't worked out, at least not in Greece, but demonizing the other members of the Eurozone as being unwilling to help is unwarranted.
 

Rourkey

Member
Probably because a Eurozone country can't been seen to fail.



Didn't they just vote not to have this done to them?


When they start printing their own currency inflation will rocket, they won't be able to buy the things they once did, whole industries will go to pot, unemployment will go through the roof, things are about to get a lot worse at least in the short term.
 
The unwillingness to give somebody money on their terms instead of your own is now an active act of pushing somebody out? If Europe wanted to push Greece out, they could have done that much earlier before they gave Greece hundreds of billions of Euros, the equivalent of many, many Marshall plans.

It's fair to say that Europe's plans over the last five years haven't worked out, at least not in Greece, but demonizing the other members of the Eurozone as being unwilling to help is unwarranted.

As long as it is clear that said hundreds of billions were not poured into the greek economy or used to help those who were suffering. They were used to pay out external loans and effectively bail out banks and other private creditors. It is a big help, no doubt, but let's not present it as if all that money was given directly to Greece.
 
The unwillingness to give somebody money on their terms instead of your own is now an active act of pushing somebody out? If Europe wanted to push Greece out, they could have done that much earlier before they gave Greece hundreds of billions of Euros, the equivalent of many, many Marshall plans.

It's fair to say that Europe's plans over the last five years haven't worked out, at least not in Greece, but demonizing the other members of the Eurozone as being unwilling to help is unwarranted.
The whole 'fuck Merkel, Dijselbloem, etc' is not really helping in getting support from other countries indeed. Greece is in a bad state, but it's not like Spain, France, Italy, etc are doing so amazing and they are paying part of those debts.

As long as it is clear that said hundreds of billions were not poured into the greek economy or used to help those who were suffering. They were used to pay out external loans and effectively bail out banks and other private creditors. It is a big help, no doubt, but let's not present it as if all that money was given directly to Greece.
It was not, and it was a big giant mistake. Those banks should have taken the loss or worked out some other solution. But that doesn't change where the money came from and who is paying for it.
 

chadskin

Member
henrikenderlein: Sad scenario, but likely: Tsipras asks for Prog3. Institutions (& Bundestag) say NO as reply to OXI. Stalemate & #Grexit. Tsipras blames EU.
https://twitter.com/henrikenderlein/status/617760238008180736

noahbarkin: #German #CSU hardliner #Michelbach tells @Reuters he does not see basis for further aid for #Greece if "no" vote wins
https://twitter.com/noahbarkin/status/617757793337143296

MatinaStevis: What I'm getting from people who voted "no" is that they overwhelmingly believe Tsipras & his promise of a new negotiation starting tomorrow
https://twitter.com/matinastevis/status/617761774230745089
 

Ether_Snake

安安安安安安安安安安安安安安安
Good luck to Greece I guess. Back to negotiations, but now with no money in the bank.


I don't see that as very obvious. The Greeks might be for that, but the other Euro countries need to explain that somehow to their populations. Won't be easy.

Of course they most likely won't agree to it, but the thing is I doubt the Troika's offer would be much different either way, they know the most meaningful move they can make it debt cut. So it's that or Drachma really. The Euro would probably not rise if Greece drops the Euro, because it would not increase confidence in the currency since it would set quite a precedent, so I think it's the most likely outcome for the near term. Germany should be happy with that in the end since the currency would stay low, or lower.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom