• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Halo |OT 23| Thruster is Love, Thruster is Life

willow ve

Member
The TTK definitely does not need increasing in 5. It's almost too fast as it is.

I agree. The beta at times was lacking the pacing of the 4SK BR battles. This could easily be due to the fact that every game I played had shit tiers of K-Mart DSL lag.


Cross posting with updated data.

This just in!

Battlefield 4, a game released 427 days, or 1 year, 2 months, and 1 day ago, is beating Halo MCC in population.

How can I be sure?

Your Xbox can tell you. Go to the game store and there will be a section of top games right now. BF4 is at the end of the list. MCC is no where on the list.

BF4 right now? 20,095 people are playing.

MCC? Below that.

343, how could you fuck this up?

Ouch. Get it fixed. Give it out on Games with Gold. I'm not even kidding.
 
Too late I already won. Take that you fucks!

Seriously though, pretty fun and there was actually decent competition. Gotta pick up my medal later today. I'll snap a pic for you bums.

Ha, awesome! Is there a video record of the brutal geometry slaying laid down this day?
 
Cross posting with updated data.

This just in!

Battlefield 4, a game released 427 days, or 1 year, 2 months, and 1 day ago, is beating Halo MCC in population.

How can I be sure?

Your Xbox can tell you. Go to the game store and there will be a section of top games right now. BF4 is at the end of the list. MCC is no where on the list.

BF4 right now? 20,095 people are playing.

MCC? Below that.

343, how could you fuck this up?
#wedad
 
Cross posting with updated data.

This just in!

Battlefield 4, a game released 427 days, or 1 year, 2 months, and 1 day ago, is beating Halo MCC in population.

How can I be sure?

Your Xbox can tell you. Go to the game store and there will be a section of top games right now. BF4 is at the end of the list. MCC is no where on the list.

BF4 right now? 20,095 people are playing.

MCC? Below that.

343, how could you fuck this up?

That's really a shame :( It really upsets me that the game didn't have a proper launch. The first few weeks a Halo game comes out are always great because the population is huge and the community is thriving. The MCC really just soured everyone, understandably, and we'll never have that pre launch hype back and nothing 343 does(although I do appreciate getting ODST free) will be a big enough apology for what happened. :/
 

Sephzilla

Member
Cross posting with updated data.

This just in!

Battlefield 4, a game released 427 days, or 1 year, 2 months, and 1 day ago, is beating Halo MCC in population.

How can I be sure?

Your Xbox can tell you. Go to the game store and there will be a section of top games right now. BF4 is at the end of the list. MCC is no where on the list.

BF4 right now? 20,095 people are playing.

MCC? Below that.

343, how could you fuck this up?

MCC needs so much positive PR to revive interest in it that I don't think 343 will even bother
 

SaganIsGOAT

Junior Member
Sad that such a small population is being split between 4 games... Should have just done H2A MP.

Make it Free to Play at this point.
 

Welfare

Member
The sad thing is that if the game has 20,000 concurrent users on at a single time, the multiplayer is extremely dead, as you would be assuming all 20,000 of those users are in matchmaking, and not in Campaign, forge, customs, or Spartan Ops.

There are 11 playlists in MM. That means if everything was equally split, only 1,818 are in a playlist.

1,818

Now of course, playlists aren't equal, so some playlists might be over 2,000, but you still must factor in that there are other modes in MCC besides matchmaking.

Just assuming 70% of all players are in matchmaking (a very high percentage), that's only 14,000 players, or an average of 1,272 players in each playlist.

Like holy shit, not only is this game dead, but it's DEAD.

I find it appalling that 343 let this game get into this situation, and is so fucking worried, they won't even let its user base look at the population numbers in each playlist to see if it's even worth a damn to search in multiplayer.

343 might be working on matchmaking, but you can't fix a low population.

#addinpopulationcounter
 

HTupolev

Member
Probably should clarify. I would have rather taken just a single working H2A (for its anniversary) than the broken package we ended up with.
Right. Obviously.

FUNKNOWN would prefer having online CE MP in crappy condition over having H2A MP working well.

Personally I'd agree with him, if the alternative is no online CE console MP at all ever. Though if there'd been a possibility for it being launched right as part of a second package later, I'd gladly take that over the botched launch we got.
 
That's Titanfall levels of dead playlists.

Deader than Titanfall imo. Being a game without datacenter selection, if you live in a less populated region by Xbox Live standard, you are stuck matchmaking in that tiny region, in my case Asia, which has very low Xbox One adoption rate, while on Titanfall I never have trouble finding games due to being able to choose servers and having a working MM code. My last MCC game was 2 months ago and since then I was never able to play in one match.
 

CliQ

Member
Probably should clarify. I would have rather taken just a single working H2A (for its anniversary) than the broken package we ended up with.

I will re-enforce FUNKNOWN. Having CE on XBL worth it. The fact that I can play BG CTF on live is really all I need.

seriously I could play that and only that until I die

Oh and Vin if you want to go to my xboxclips for the video that would help me. I'm crazy busy at work still.
 

jem0208

Member
Cross posting with updated data.

This just in!

Battlefield 4, a game released 427 days, or 1 year, 2 months, and 1 day ago, is beating Halo MCC in population.

How can I be sure?

Your Xbox can tell you. Go to the game store and there will be a section of top games right now. BF4 is at the end of the list. MCC is no where on the list.

BF4 right now? 20,095 people are playing.

MCC? Below that.

343, how could you fuck this up?

A game which was broken a year ago, is beating a game which is broken now.


I think the MCC can come back from this. Fix the multiplayer and combine that with a price drop and the population can bounce back. Just like it did with BF4.
 

-Ryn

Banned
That population...

Yeah they're gonna need to pull some marketing magic if they expect to get people back on the MCC. Maybe release the game with Halo 5 day 1 for free? Something that will make everyone know it's fixed.

10/10 would snuggle
co signed

I just spat my drink out, because this happened to me:

The MCC is self aware of it's current state. LMAO
Is this real!?
 

VinFTW

Member
I will re-enforce FUNKNOWN. Having CE on XBL worth it. The fact that I can play BG CTF on live is really all I need.

seriously I could play that and only that until I die

Oh and Vin if you want to go to my xboxclips for the video that would help me. I'm crazy busy at work still.

no problem, i know just the one I want to use
 

Ramirez

Member
That population...

Yeah they're gonna need to pull some marketing magic if they expect to get people back on the MCC. Maybe release the game with Halo 5 day 1 for free? Something that will make everyone know it's fixed.

Once 5 hits, this game will be lucky to have 10K on at a time.
 
So, I was going through the Elite halopedia page for some references and rediscovered this:

Elites-concept-art-issac-hannaford.jpg


They look Bionicle as hell, but I'd love to fight a dedicated squad of specialist Elites - kind of a foil to a group like Noble Team - that had armor configurations like these.
 

Fuchsdh

Member
Once 5 hits, this game will be lucky to have 10K on at a time.

I think the whole appeal of the MCC is a modern platform to play the Halo games some people are far more interested in than Halo 5. In which case, they'll still be playing/will return if the issues are solved.
 

Ramirez

Member
I think the whole appeal of the MCC is a modern platform to play the Halo games some people are far more interested in than Halo 5. In which case, they'll still be playing/will return if the issues are solved.

I think a lot of people liked Halo 5 more than they thought they would, and a lot have moved on from MCC and ain't coming back. Barring a GWG release, I don't see this game ever having a huge population. I thought so at first, but I never imagined it would still be broken a few days away from Feb.

RIP was what would show up on Halloween I believe.
 
That population...

Yeah they're gonna need to pull some marketing magic if they expect to get people back on the MCC. Maybe release the game with Halo 5 day 1 for free? Something that will make everyone know it's fixed.


co signed


Is this real!?

Yeah releasing it with 5 would be great but I think doing an April or May games with gold release would get a population back and get people ready for 5 later in the year.

I'm still hoping this next patch is worth anything too, I've been dropped out of three Halo 4 games this morning (selecting new host lol) and it's hard enough to get into the games still.
 

-Ryn

Banned
Once 5 hits, this game will be lucky to have 10K on at a time.
True...

Like Fuch said I can still see a lot of people who weren't interested in 5 come back if they can see the game is working. A free release of sort is really one of the only ways I can see it working well though.

Yes. It's one of the random (I think) signs, that can appear on Valhalla on certain dates.

I didn't know this was in rotation which makes it hilarious.
I never even knew that was a thing!
That's really cool lol

Yeah releasing it with 5 would be great but I think doing an April or May games with gold release would get a population back and get people ready for 5 later in the year.

I'm still hoping this next patch is worth anything too, I've been dropped out of three Halo 4 games this morning (selecting new host lol) and it's hard enough to get into the games still.
Fingers crossed dude

An early summer Games with Gold release could certainly be a great way to do it if the game is fixed by then. Summer Vacation could bring in a lot of new players at the least.

So, I was going through the Elite halopedia page for some references and rediscovered this:

Elites-concept-art-issac-hannaford.jpg


They look Bionicle as hell, but I'd love to fight a dedicated squad of specialist Elites - kind of a foil to a group like Noble Team - that had armor configurations like these.
That'd be really cool actually.

I second this
 
MS will never give out MCC. Not if they really plan to make it the main hub for classic Halo. At the most, a free weekend like Sunset Overdrive had, probably late summer. Marketed as "practice" before Halo 5 launches.
 

RBK

Banned
Cross posting with updated data.

This just in!

Battlefield 4, a game released 427 days, or 1 year, 2 months, and 1 day ago, is beating Halo MCC in population.

How can I be sure?

Your Xbox can tell you. Go to the game store and there will be a section of top games right now. BF4 is at the end of the list. MCC is no where on the list.

BF4 right now? 20,095 people are playing.

MCC? Below that.

343, how could you fuck this up?

As long as I can find matches without any issues(not due to the game being broken), stuff like population total doesn't really worry me.

With that said, they should remove the HCS, H2A Rumble, and Team Slayer playlists so you don't stretch out the user base. If they decide to keep HCS, find a way to incorporate Team Hardcore into as well.
 

RBK

Banned
MS will never give out MCC. Not if they really plan to make it the main hub for classic Halo. At the most, a free weekend like Sunset Overdrive had, probably late summer. Marketed as "practice" before Halo 5 launches.

Maybe years down the line to a potential Halo 6 release.

No time soon though.
 

wwm0nkey

Member
So when is that patch going to hit?

Also I do think we will see a relaunch of the game sometime down the road and it will be sooner rather than later. They messed up hard and the only way to get people back on will be with a relaunch.
 
SO are people purposely dropping out of matching in MCC, or are they getting booted due to networking issues, Cuz that seems to be my only issue with MCC other then long wait times.

I seriously hate player drop outs
 

dwells

Member
Man, that population news is not good. Especially since all I want is Team Hardcore, which has historically had a disproportionately low player count.
 

TTUVAPOR

Banned
Cross posting with updated data.

This just in!

Battlefield 4, a game released 427 days, or 1 year, 2 months, and 1 day ago, is beating Halo MCC in population.

How can I be sure?

Your Xbox can tell you. Go to the game store and there will be a section of top games right now. BF4 is at the end of the list. MCC is no where on the list.

BF4 right now? 20,095 people are playing.

MCC? Below that.

343, how could you fuck this up?

Does that just mean top games sold? I don't think you can garner population numbers from that list.
 

Booshka

Member
HCS for H2A is essentially dead too because of this awful launch and population. So on to waiting (yet again) for next Halo game to rekindle competitive Halo.
 
SO are people purposely dropping out of matching in MCC, or are they getting booted due to networking issues, Cuz that seems to be my only issue with MCC other then long wait times.

I seriously hate player drop outs
Because there's no quit penalty, so people are quick to drop out of games if things don't go their way.
 

TTUVAPOR

Banned
HCS for H2A is essentially dead too because of this awful launch and population. So on to waiting (yet again) for next Halo game to rekindle competitive Halo.

Were you competing in HCS or are you playing the HCS playlist?

They need to turn on the ranks in these playlists to make them worthy of playing in.

I'm tired of playing with split-screeners...they always either suck or quit out.
 

Welfare

Member
Does that just mean top games sold? I don't think you can garner population numbers from that list.
There are 2 sections.

Top Paid

Most Played

Most played is top games right now.

Just checked. MCC is now on the list! #10 in fact. But BF4 is #9.

So right now MCC has less than 27,645 players on.
 
Because there's no quit penalty, so people are quick to drop out of games if things don't go their way.

seriously its ridiculous. I get it some time i get upset to. but really people just stick it out. I mean the only time i leave mid game if ever is when half my team drops out. By then there's no point in staying except to get massacred.

Also i love how even if i stay the whole team acts like there bad asses for kill one dude when its 4v1. Wow good job. It's so stupid
 
Top Bottom