3. In na there was a thing called sel that was a closed scrim thing that was a disaster because there werent enough good players and bad ppl kept getting vouched in.
I feel you on your points, but I would argue SEL wasn't ruined because lesser skilled players were let in. It was ruined because those players simply cannot get along with each other in an environment that involves players from each team being on opposing teams. One game you face 3 from C9, the next 2 of your teammates are drafted to the enemy and you get two dudes from The Pleyz or whatever.
Basically, SEL devolved into them bitching about who got the worse player(s), even though 9 out of 10 players in the league were current pros, former pros, or pro adjacent. They expected to win every game. Not in the way you set out to win every game, they expected to be like "I'm the dope shit dawg watch me carry" and they quickly realize without their team behind them they can't do that. So...it was exactly like hero league. Sometimes you win the draft and the matchmaking, sometimes you don't. NA pros just can't stand that there is RNG/variance in matchmaking in a moba, but it's the same way in every moba to a larger or smaller degree.
I maintain that the skill gap between a lot of these players is minimal, if there is any at all for the vast majority of pros in NA who aren't on the top two or three teams. The good teams are good because three or four minimal gaps in skill (or the occasional measurable gap or two) add up. Throw in the teams with better players often having better shotcalling and confidence in their team and that leads to victory.
yeah I was thinking maybe ppl would tryhard for the rank but in general it doesnt seem like na is very good at this game
well at least until money comes thru
You keep saying NA, or the population in general isn't very good at the game and I don't buy that shit man. Of course 90% of players or so aren't even in Diamond, but that's probably the case in other MOBAs as well. Naturally, everyone will get better over time. Late adopters from other MOBAs will also theoretically up the skill pool. But having shitters in grandmaster or shitters in rank 1 or whatever isn't because the skill level is low, it's because it's a game that (like most games) can be bullrushed by taking the path of least resistance (OP heroes, exploiting group numbers, queueing at specific times, etc) for people who are willing to do that. Even those people aren't "bad", they are just worse than someone who used variety to get there and took their time to stop and learn.