• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Hi-Def Media Lovefest: The war is over and we can all go home.

Status
Not open for further replies.

StoOgE

First tragedy, then farce.
Petrarca said:
Let me clarify the bolded part, are you interested more in what Universal has to offer versus what Disney + Sony + FOX + MGM + LionsGate have?

wow, this is the first time anyone has ever put it this way.

Thanks for your contribution to this thread.
 
StoOgE said:
wow, this is the first time anyone has ever put it this way.

Thanks for your contribution to this thread.

It bears repeating, since Mana seems to think it's about pie charts and not about movies for some people.
 

Petrarca

Banned
StoOgE said:
wow, this is the first time anyone has ever put it this way.

Thanks for your contribution to this thread.


you're doing a nice job so far replacing VanMardigan, keep up the good work, you may end up where he is at one day
 

Cosmic Bus

pristine morning snow
Petrarca said:
Let me clarify the bolded part, are you interested more in what Universal has to offer versus what Disney + Sony + FOX + MGM + LionsGate have?

Basically, yes, especially when combined with the availability of Warner, Paramount and Magnolia's films. I don't have any interest in anything from Disney or Columbia (perhaps if the latter weren't so deadset against releasing catalog titles); Fox and MGM both have films I like, but again, they aren't ones on high-def, they're only releasing them on DVD.
 

ManaByte

Gold Member
Hotarubi said:
Basically, yes, especially when combined with the availability of Warner, Paramount and Magnolia's films. I don't have any interest in anything from Disney or Columbia (perhaps if the latter weren't so deadset against releasing catalog titles); Fox and MGM both have films I like, but again, they aren't ones on high-def, they're only releasing them on DVD.

Yup the combined catalogs of Universal, Warner, Paramount, and Dreamworks for me. I'll still have a BRD player for Disney stuff though.
 

Petrarca

Banned
ManaByte said:
Yup the combined catalogs of Universal, Warner, Paramount, and Dreamworks for me. I'll still have a BRD player for Disney stuff though.

Your library disagrees with what you just said, you bought most of dual-format Warner movies on blu-ray, and some of the Sony and Fox movies on blu-ray
 

ManaByte

Gold Member
Petrarca said:
Your library contradicts with what you just said, you bought most of dual-format Warner movies on blu-ray, and some of the Sony and Fox movies

Maybe it's because I had Blu-Ray long before I had HD-DVD? Ya think?
 

thaivo

Member
ManaByte said:
Yup the combined catalogs of Universal, Warner, Paramount, and Dreamworks for me. I'll still have a BRD player for Disney stuff though.

Same goes for me. The present studios supporting HD-DVD are more than enough to keep me happy. Disney only really means Pixar to me, but only because I love Pixar.

I know it's not likely, but I'd love to see Saving Private Ryan in HD..
 
ManaByte said:
Yup the combined catalogs of Universal, Warner, Paramount, and Dreamworks for me. I'll still have a BRD player for Disney stuff though.

The only stuff from Disney that I'm really looking forward to is Ratatouille. Saw it last night, what an awesome movie. One of Pixar's best yet. I won't own Cars again. Pirates 3...I'll buy it just to own all three even though I have absolutely no hype watching it (I didn't even watch the whole sequel yet, and I own both the DVD and BD versions :lol).
 

Kolgar

Member
yacobod said:
for owners of both formats, which are you going to be picking up 300 on next week?

hd-dvd or brd

fight!!!

I faced that question today as I preordered my copy from Amazon. For just four bucks extra, I decided it made more sense to get the HD DVD version as it's playable in SD-DVD players and comes with extra interactive content.

Had all things been equal, I'd have gone Blu-ray because it seems to have a leg up in the format war and I feel better about playing HD movies in my PS3 than my 360. :p
 

yacobod

Banned
Petrarca said:
Let me clarify the bolded part, are you interested more in what Universal has to offer versus what Disney + Sony + FOX + MGM + LionsGate have?


youve got a point, but you also have to admit that most of those studios have been lacking in the release department, i mean FOX hasnt really released shit, when they finally do it will be all good tho

for the time being tho, universal has released a lot of quality stuff, prolly the most out of any studio
 

yacobod

Banned
Petrarca said:
you're doing a nice job so far replacing VanMardigan, keep up the good work, you may end up where he is at one day


i like how he insinuates that you're gonna end up getting banned like Van

i often wonder how this guy avoids getting banned with all the shit he says
 

Crayon Shinchan

Aquafina Fanboy
If I owned both BD and HD-DVD, it would mean that I couldn't wait for HD-DVD to die, and was ok with my HD media been scattered on 2 disparate formats.

If that was the case, how is it a question? the HD-DVD version, with more features is the obvious answer.

... but because I do care about the longevity of the format; and that I dislike having a collection of movies that I need to play on a specialised or an outdated player, I don't own a HD-DVD.
As an extension to that; if you gave me a HD-DVD player now, I'd still buy the BD version of 300, even though, I like the IME extra content, because I know, in the future, I'll want to play 300 on any player, not just the one HD-DVD player I have.
 
3899.jpg


5.1 PCM, 6.1 DTSES.

Why PCM wasn't 6.1 I have no idea. Whatever, it should still sound super.
 

Suikoguy

I whinny my fervor lowly, for his length is not as great as those of the Hylian war stallions
DarkJediKnight said:
[img.]http://dvd.themanroom.com/images/covers/bluray/large/3899.jpg[/img]

5.1 PCM, 6.1 DTSES.

Why PCM wasn't 6.1 I have no idea. Whatever, it should still sound super.

Wow, you certainly used the right word to describe that movie :lol
 

Days like these...

Have a Blessed Day
Ignatz Mouse said:
If I had both, I'd get the HD-DVD.... but I'm not into the movie, so I am not even getting the BD. I may rent it, but I didn't think it was very good.

Surprisingly enough I agree with my good friend mouse. I didnt care for the movie either and I won't be getting it. I wouldn't mind Sin City though. Is that out for blu ray? I know its not for hd.
 
Taken from AnimeonDVD

AoD said:
Anime Blu-ray in the UK (03:02 PM EDT): Though it's a tentative list according to studio representatives, the Sony Pictures UK site lists several anime releases planned for Blu-ray in the next couple of quarters. On January 7th, 2008 they list Cowboy Bebop, PAPRIKA and Steamboy. November 5th has a listing for Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children (which is likely to be simultaneous worldwide release) and a September 25th release for Tekkon Kinkreet.

All of these licenses are also owned by Sony in North America, so it's safe to say they're coming.

ty_hot said:
So, both hddvd and bd are in 1080p resolution, right?

what's the cinema resolution?

Film has a higher resolution than the current output of HDTV.
 

el Diablo

Banned
Big-E said:
Top Gun is a definite first day purchase and will be the fourth version of the film that I have bought.

Heh, third for me. Got the original DVD, the 2 disc special edition, and this one, i also own it on VHS if that's worth anything :lol.

Anime Blu-ray in the UK (03:02 PM EDT): ....November 5th has a listing for Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children (which is likely to be simultaneous worldwide release).....

Hope so, i never bought this cause i figured a BD version would be along sooner or later. Say what you want about the plot etc. but this should look and sound sick in HD.
 

Petrarca

Banned
The dominoes are falling? After Target and Blockbuster, another 3rd party retailer goes blu-ray exclusively

http://www.videobusiness.com/article/CA6463556.html

BJ's Wholesale Club stores to carry Blu-ray exclusively

JULY 26 | East Coast chain BJ’s Wholesale Club will drop HD DVD from its shelves and carry the Blu-ray Disc format exclusively by the fourth quarter, according to sources at the retailer and several Hollywood studios.

Sources said the chain will carry Blu-ray exclusively at all its 170 stores, although it continues to carry both formats on its Web site.

A spokesperson for the chain didn’t immediately return calls for comment.

BJ’s' move follows Target and Blockbuster, both of which have announced they will increase the presence and support of Blu-ray in stores. Both chains, however, will continue to carry HD DVD movies to some extent.

At this moment, to someone considering hi-def, buying HD-DVD is just not a wise decision
 

Chrono

Banned
Sorry for asking this question here but it's not worth a thread and I really don't have time to look through 50 page threads about PS3 scaling...

How do I get the PS3 to upscale anime and keep the aspect ratio? I'm trying to watch the Fullmetal Alchemist movie, and it's 4:3 but the only way to get the correct aspect ratio is by turning off the scaling... Thanks for any help and sorry again.
 

duckroll

Member
Chrono said:
Sorry for asking this question here but it's not worth a thread and I really don't have time to look through 50 page threads about PS3 scaling...

How do I get the PS3 to upscale anime and keep the aspect ratio? I'm trying to watch the Fullmetal Alchemist movie, and it's 4:3 but the only way to get the correct aspect ratio is by turning off the scaling... Thanks for any help and sorry again.

Huh? The FMA movie is 16:9, not 4:3. What are you smoking?
 

painey

Member
djkimothy said:
Whatttt!!!? Phooey. :(

cant believe it! I live in england which is crazy too :)

by the way im hearing a few people complaining that 300 HD-DVD doesnt work correctly on the 360 add-on.. people saying it messes up around chapter 14.
 

djkimothy

Member
painey said:
cant believe it! I live in england which is crazy too :)

by the way im hearing a few people complaining that 300 HD-DVD doesnt work correctly on the 360 add-on.. people saying it messes up around chapter 14.

Can you tease us with some photos? Or is that against the rules?
 

Chrono

Banned
duckroll said:
Huh? The FMA movie is 16:9, not 4:3. What are you smoking?

http://www.amazon.com/dp/B000FS2VZO/?tag=neogaf0e-20

^I looked at that page and I guess thought my monitor was stretching the image... Also, the menu screen has a different aspect ratio so that screwed things up. I'm viewing all of this on a monitor too so that could be part of it.. >_>;; Anyway I just tried it on my PC with media player classic and yeah it's 16:9.
 
this will sound ****ed up but I actually went back and canceled my preorder for HDDVD of 300 and got the Blu-ray version instead....

realized PiP wasn't enough for me =/
 

Petrarca

Banned
AgentOtaku said:
this will sound ****ed up but I actually went back and canceled my preorder for HDDVD of 300 and got the Blu-ray version instead....

realized PiP wasn't enough for me =/


I called that common sense
 

rubso

Banned
AgentOtaku said:
this will sound ****ed up but I actually went back and canceled my preorder for HDDVD of 300 and got the Blu-ray version instead....

realized PiP wasn't enough for me =/
you thought it has a PiP only ?
 

ManaByte

Gold Member
AgentOtaku said:
this will sound ****ed up but I actually went back and canceled my preorder for HDDVD of 300 and got the Blu-ray version instead....

realized PiP wasn't enough for me =/

So you decided to get a version with less extras?
 

Forsete

Member
Petrarca said:
The dominoes are falling? After Target and Blockbuster, another 3rd party retailer goes blu-ray exclusively

http://www.videobusiness.com/article/CA6463556.html

BJ's Wholesale Club stores to carry Blu-ray exclusively



At this moment, to someone considering hi-def, buying HD-DVD is just not a wise decision

Sorry, non-news.. Not important!!

Where is that "flesh wound" pic when you need it? :D

Edit: Do you guys always look at the extra content? I think the only movie where I have checked the extra content was the Cuckoo's Nest (DVD) and some stuff on Casino Royale (BD) because I was bored. Mostly I just ignore that section of the movie. :lol

Oh and I played the Pirates dice game on one of the PotC BD discs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom