• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Hi-Def Media Lovefest: The war is over and we can all go home.

Status
Not open for further replies.
There were so many similar responses to my post, that I won't bother quoting them all. Basically, I understand that the majority of rumors from everyone, on both sides of this format war, are just that- rumors. However, sadly, FUD does work, sometimes, and with so many big companies with a stake in the matter, there is a lot of funding in disinformation. Hence, the safest thing for me to do is to not sell my current collection of Blu-ray movies, but suspend further purchases for the time being. I'm not the type of person who absolutely needs new releases day-and-date. If I really wanted to see a movie that badly, I'd have seen it in theaters already. If Blu-ray ends up on top, I'm golden, and can pick up the movies that I held off on. If HD DVD wins, then I'm not too deeply invested in Blu-ray, and can make the switch with minimal loss.

I'd only sell my Blu-ray movies, if it became clear that Blu-ray lost too much studio support, and would inevitably fold. Without mainstream support, there's no reasonable expectation that Blu-ray players will be available in the future. I'd doubt PS4 would even include Blu-ray, if Blu-ray lost the format war. Sony already dropped backwards compability with its latest PS3 skus, so it's not farfetched to think it could be the same with PS4. If HD DVD won, and went mainstream, then building a PS4 with HD DVD would be a bigger incentive to more people, than being backwards compatible with PS3. While true, that Sony has lost several format wars, before, they were never too proud to join the winning side when the war was over.

I think the next best thing to one side winning over the other, would be for dual-format players/writers to become the standard like it is with DVD+/-R. In fact, that may even be the ideal scenario, since no one would lose, and everyone who wasn't already neutral could start picking up movies that were exclusive to the opposite format.
 
Sh0k said:
Thanks all, I just placed an order with Amazon for the 4 Potter movies, they are hard to pass at $10. a piece and free shipping. I will put my Potter DVDs on eBay tonight.

Anybody owns the Resident Evil trilogy on BD ? How is the transfer quality ? Best Buy has the Trilogy for $59. + tax

Picked it up yesterday.
The PQ on RE3 is easily 4.5-5 * depending on how anal you are.
Haven't been able to watch the first yet.
 

kaching

"GAF's biggest wanker"
mrklaw said:
theres a separate thread for HD movie stuff. Lets keep this one on-topic. I.e a complete mind-fuck driving headfirst out of control into the potential but unlikely melodramatic meltdown which is CES.
I look forward to the CES fallout, should make for more converts to my recently formed Church of the Latter-day Dual Format Players.

AlteredBeast said:
Let's propose a moratorium on Warner HD-DVD or Blu-Ray exclusivity rumors until after CES, ok?
nah.
 

Forsete

Member
Sh0k said:
What do you guys do with your old DVD movies, do you buy HD movies only if you don't have them in DVD or do you double dip on some titles ? I'm tempted to get the 4 Potter movies on BDs with the Amazon BOGO, but I already own them in DVD ... I hate to double dip :(

Keep them.

I havent replaced any DVDs yet, though I will get Master and Commander on BD, a movie I already own on DVD. So that will be the first.
 

Argyle

Member
avaya said:
Just had a peruse of HighDef Digest. Man...

It's the new AVS. All the "special" people have migrated to a new home after the draconian measures that the AVS mods instigated.

You can find Amir, rdjam, Kosty and that MidnightWatcher (joke character surely...) there. They are running their "replication lines hur hur" viral attack at the moment, managed to derail many threads with some of the most creative obfuscation you can imagine. :lol

Yeah, I read the smackdown forum a bit the last couple of days and I won't be returning...it really is the same BS that was on AVSForum before the purge.

I was amazed that MidnightWatcher survived on AVSForum - seems like he spends most of his time there now helping people upgrade the FW on their HD DVD players. :)
 
rage1973 said:
Is anyone planning on going to CES? I will be there from Sunday to Tuesday.

I'm here right now. I'm currently typing this backstage (or, to be more accurate, upstairs in) the Microsoft booth on the show floor.

OMG TEH INSIDER!!!
 
Battlezone said:
I'm here right now. I'm currently typing this backstage (or, to be more accurate, upstairs in) the Microsoft booth on the show floor.

OMG TEH INSIDER!!!

Xbox Ultimate/Toshiba 360/Warner HD DVD exclusive confirmed?
 

Oni Jazar

Member
I think I'm going to be skipping out on the Blu-ray BOGO - Shame there's no Harry Potter OOTP in there or I would have bitten. I *did* end up buying Lost Season 3 after reading the review at High Def Digest. It looks like this writer's strike may give me lots of free time to re-watch! :)
 
The Main Event said:
Xbox Ultimate/Toshiba 360/Warner HD DVD exclusive confirmed?

I can neither confirm nor deny anything.

I keep tripping over large piles of money and empty hats. I wonder where they're for.
 

Meier

Member
Opus Angelorum said:
5 stars for picture? Wow.

I know Agent Dormer bit on a PS3 in large part because of Lost in Blu-Ray and his jaw ached from dropping so hard. Striker Obi is tempted to do the same.. heck I'm tempted for Ratatouille, but a new PC is my next big purchase.
 

nerbo

Member
How long has this thread been arguing about rumored Warner exclusivity in either direction now? A year? Christ, put this bs aside and give this thread a purpose, like BOGO's and transfer quality on releases.
 

Dante

Member
Oni Jazar said:
I think I'm going to be skipping out on the Blu-ray BOGO - Shame there's no Harry Potter OOTP in there or I would have bitten. I *did* end up buying Lost Season 3 after reading the review at High Def Digest. It looks like this writer's strike may give me lots of free time to re-watch! :)


Lost Season 3 on Blu Ray blew my fukkin mind. Easily my best Blu Ray purchase so far.
 
There's a new flash CES promotional video up on bluraydisc.com

Most interesting part is the credits... :D :D :D

In case you didn't catch it...
BATMAN BEGINS!
 
nerbo said:
How long has this thread been arguing about rumored Warner exclusivity in either direction now? A year? Christ, put this bs aside and give this thread a purpose, like BOGO's and transfer quality on releases.
I believe the thread you want is called Hi-Def movies. This is the Rob Enderle Suicide Watch Part Deux. Big difference. :D
 
Cold-Steel said:
There's a new flash CES promotional video up on bluraydisc.com

Most interesting part is the credits... :D :D :D

In case you didn't catch it...
BATMAN BEGINS!
fapfapfapfapfapfapfapfap

Too bad I already bought the HD DVD version long ago. This is awesome though, it's pretty much confirmation that WB won't be going red.
 

Snah

Banned
Cold-Steel said:
There's a new flash CES promotional video up on bluraydisc.com

Most interesting part is the credits... :D :D :D

In case you didn't catch it...
BATMAN BEGINS!


Woot :D

More evidence that Warner won't make ANY move at CES.

Can't wait for Batman Begins and V for Vendetta. Been waiting on those releases for a LOOONG time...Hopefully they're not just copies of the HD-DVD, but new transfers to take advantage of blu-ray.
 

Chiggs

Gold Member
Snah said:
Woot :D
More evidence that Warner won't make ANY move at CES.


Okay, well, let's just mark 2/6/2008 on our calendars now. Warner Bros Earnings Conference 2008 - It will be legendary!
 
Cold-Steel said:
There's a new flash CES promotional video up on bluraydisc.com

Most interesting part is the credits... :D :D :D

In case you didn't catch it...
BATMAN BEGINS!
87310te.jpg


7wyfb7o.jpg


Picked up the Resident Evil box yesterday along with Hitchhiker's and the Incubus Blu-Ray. I also got the little bag that Best Buy was giving away and was able to use the $20 BB and a $5 Disney coupon on the order. I also got the RE bag that the store was giving away as well as the cashier's phone number. Well, someone's phone number. It was stored in the bag's pocket and was a girl's writing. No idea why it was there. it was local, though. :lol

Today I got HP5 (since it was $25), Shoot 'Em Up, and Pan's Labyrinth also using the $20 coupon.
 

B-Ri

Member
bune duggy said:
87310te.jpg


7wyfb7o.jpg


Picked up the Resident Evil box yesterday along with Hitchhiker's and the Incubus Blu-Ray. I also got the little bag that Best Buy was giving away and was able to use the $20 BB and a $5 Disney coupon on the order. I also got the RE bag that the store was giving away as well as the cashier's phone number. Well, someone's phone number. It was stored in the bag's pocket and was a girl's writing. No idea why it was there. it was local, though. :lol

Today I got HP5 (since it was $25), Shoot 'Em Up, and Pan's Labyrinth also using the $20 coupon.

when are those pictures from?

lol aeonflux blu ray on the bottom, oh my god im gonna start a rumor!!!! PARAMOUNT BACK TO BLU AZOMOSMZOXGMDSGO

im kidding guys im kidding. Awesome to see Batman Begins making its way to blu-ray, i really want it.
 

Sylar

Banned
Got my AMAZON BOGO HDDVD s today...

Fear and Loathing
Casino

I never saw Casino before, and i'm a huge Scorsece(SP?) fan, so should I like it? I mean, i'm one of the five people who like The Last Waltz second to Goodfellas. :lol

Also received my favorite movie ever today in HDDVD - Scanner Darkly. Now just awaiting my $4.99 Eternal Sunshine and the five free HDDVDs!
 

AlteredBeast

Fork 'em, Sparky!
So a Scanner Darkly is really a good movie, then? I wanted to see it in theaters, but had no one to go with me that I could legitimately see enjoying the movie. :(

I almost want to blind buy it...
 

B-Ri

Member
AlteredBeast said:
So a Scanner Darkly is really a good movie, then? I wanted to see it in theaters, but had no one to go with me that I could legitimately see enjoying the movie. :(

I almost want to blind buy it...

eh, its alright. It was its style and the fact it takes place here in my area (orange county, and irvine) that drew me to it.

but take my opinion with a grain of salt i guess, im one of those over analytical film majors
 
looking at the Lost S3 Blu-Ray in the store, there appears to be two versions. One of them is in a box and the other is just the case by itself. The price is the same otherwise so is it just an aesthetic thing?
 

Sylar

Banned
AlteredBeast said:
So a Scanner Darkly is really a good movie, then? I wanted to see it in theaters, but had no one to go with me that I could legitimately see enjoying the movie. :(

I almost want to blind buy it...


Retarded if you haven't read the book, amazing if you have.

Seriously, the movie on it's own without the book has so many plot holes and changes that it just doesn't make sense. If you read the book before hand or afterwords you instantly get it and it becomes amazing. Better than Blade Runner, atleast PKD adaptation wise.
 

Snah

Banned
Interesting new quotes from studio executives:

http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/questex/hom123007/index.php?startpage=48


Ron Sanders, Warner
"Unfortunately, the dueling formats created an information logjam in what should have been our conversation with consumers."

Steve Einhorn, New Line
"Dueling formats have restrained our ability to launch large-scale, industry wide marketing initiatives"


If Warner/New Line truly feel this way, then the choice is pretty obvious at this point, and I really do hope they make it sooner rather than later.
 

kaching

"GAF's biggest wanker"
nerbo said:
How long has this thread been arguing about rumored Warner exclusivity in either direction now? A year? Christ, put this bs aside and give this thread a purpose, like BOGO's and transfer quality on releases.
In 25K worth of posts, I think we can do both.

Cold-Steel said:
Most interesting part is the credits...
Support coming in for my bet about CES... :)
 
Things are certainly looking positive for Blu-ray. Warner could stay neutral as long as I get my Batman Begins and Matrix (just the first one).

I'll be there (CES) and bring back photos. :D

Whatever happened to Bad Boys 2 BTW? I saw it in a Blu-ray Disc trailer and got pissed off cause the transfer looked fucking AMAZING.
 

p_xavier

Authorized Fister
Shamlessly stolen from highdefdigest. This is exactly what Penton Man said in his post.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/content_display/film/news/e3i9bec9b085abfbfbf5119f26a8a231ee1

Jan 3, 2008
Christopher J. Cookson has been named president of Sony Pictures Technologies. He arrives from Warner Bros. Entertainment, where he served as chief technology officer as well as president of the Warner Bros. Technical Operations division.

In his new role, Cookson will oversee the development and implementation of the studio's technology policy and processes. He will also serve as Sony Pictures' chief liaison with other Sony Corp. businesses in the area of technology. The position is a new one at Sony Pictures, and Cookson will report to Michael Lynton, CEO and chairman of Sony Pictures Entertainment, and Amy Pascal, co-chairman.

"One key responsibility for Chris is his role as technology liaison with Sony Corporation and its businesses," Lynton said. "That is a crucial part of Sir Howard Stringer's vision of 'Sony United,' whereby the people and companies of Sony work closely together to bring content and hardware together as we move from the analog to the digital age."

Cookson began his career with Warners in 1992 and was named CTO in 1999. Earlier in his career, he was vp and GM of operations and engineering at the CBS Television Network in New York. Before that, he worked for 10 years at the ABC Television Network, where he won an Emmy for his work as director of the ABC and International Olympics Broadcast Centers.

Cookson holds more than 30 U.S. patents, including several involving DVDs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom