Maybe my memory is failing, but I don't think Mr.Mr. performed that well on digital charts (Definitely not as good as Lion Heart). I would reply to the 2nd paragraph, but I don't get your point.
Wasn't one of the reasons why it flopped is coz it came out around the same time as 2NE1's Crush?
I remember SM even had bullshit reasons as to why the MV looks like a low budget college project... something about losing their files or whatever lol.
What really pisses me off is that SM isn't even trying with them, with all their other acts getting better material (even Suju). I'm starting to think that this has more to do with SNSD being more involved in the releases, instead of leaving everything to the SM masterminds, that have being on point with Shinee and Red Velvet.
This.
I'm pretty sure SNSD got a chance to use Dumb Dumb for their own release but they're idiots and passed it off to Red Velvet.
Sure, Dumb Dumb is definitely an f(x)/RV track than a SNSD track, but if they're smart they would've realized the magic behind this track, but they're not and they went to boring, no effort tracks like Party and LH.
Dumb Dumb as a SNSD track could've been IGAB 2.0 and that would've been fncking amazing and I'd be back as a fan. I'm glad they're dumb though, RV deserves more love than SNSD does these days.