• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

[Kotaku] It's Time To Stop Giving Xbox Boss Phil Spencer A Pass

feynoob

feynoob

Banned
Ass of Can Whooping Ass of Can Whooping today is your day. You defeated evil phil
Bring It Reaction GIF by reactionseditor
 
IDKFA

IDKFA

I am Become Bilbo Baggins
havoc00 said:
If Phil has integrity at all, he should step down right now and cast the blame for this on Satya Nadella and Amy Hood, the only 2 people at Microsoft who could have overrode him on this decision. If he doesn't, that tells me he made this decision and that his words were lies all along. Personally I always suspected he was a liar, always did give me used car salesman vibes, but I was willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for a long time. That benefit ends now.
Click to expand...

First, that would be career suicide. Nobody is going to want to hire him if he throws his toys out of the pram and blames others. He needs to fall on the sword.

Second, everyone knows Spencer is a snake oil salesman. For all we know Nadella and Hood might have wanted to take action, but Phil most likely stringed then along with:

"Guys. Trust me. I'm Phil Spencer" then proceeded to wow them by swinging his dick around.
 
HeisenbergFX4

HeisenbergFX4

Gold Member
graywolf323 said:
HeisenbergFX4 HeisenbergFX4

is this what Ybarra would actually say behind the scenes?
Click to expand...
They did disagree on a few things and Ybarra problem was he wasn't so much of a yes man to Phil and did not mind telling Phil when he thought something was a terrible idea.

Not all of Mike's ideas were bangers too though

I will say well before the current consoles launched Mike wanted Xbox to push the whole DLSS like tech and lead the way so to speak but was shot down

Funny we are about to enter an era of dueling techs like that
 
digoutyoursoul

digoutyoursoul

Member
HeisenbergFX4 said:
They did disagree on a few things and Ybarra problem was he wasn't so much of a yes man to Phil and did not mind telling Phil when he thought something was a terrible idea.

Not all of Mike's ideas were bangers too though

I will say well before the current consoles launched Mike wanted Xbox to push the whole DLSS like tech and lead the way so to speak but was shot down

Funny we are about to enter an era of dueling techs like that
Click to expand...

Can you elaborate on what some of these ideas were? I remember a report in Windows Central about an Achievement system overhaul that was like a career XP sort of thing and it looked pretty awesome and in depth.

We are still waiting for Achievements to be improved on , they even said this in late 2021

www.trueachievements.com

Achievements "top of mind for us as we look to the road ahead," says Xbox's Jason Ronald

Xbox director of program management, Jason Ronald, recently spoke on the Iron Lords Podcast about the last 20 years of Xbox, the most notable of which was Game DVR and the achievement system.
www.trueachievements.com www.trueachievements.com

Jason Ronald hasn’t said a word about it since
 
HeisenbergFX4

HeisenbergFX4

Gold Member
digoutyoursoul said:
Can you elaborate on what some of these ideas were? I remember a report in Windows Central about an Achievement system overhaul that was like a career XP sort of thing and it looked pretty awesome and in depth.

We are still waiting for Achievements to be improved on , they even said this in late 2021

www.trueachievements.com

Achievements "top of mind for us as we look to the road ahead," says Xbox's Jason Ronald

Xbox director of program management, Jason Ronald, recently spoke on the Iron Lords Podcast about the last 20 years of Xbox, the most notable of which was Game DVR and the achievement system.
www.trueachievements.com www.trueachievements.com

Jason Ronald hasn’t said a word about it since
Click to expand...
They bumped heads often over games one of the bigger ones I have said before here so not revealing anything new is the Halo Infinite first screening for them and Mike actually chuckled and asked where the real trailer was and Phil green lit it

Mike said he told Phil they couldn't release that and these comments were made to a few of us before the actual reveal

Mike wanted Xbox to go super heavy into BRs once PUBG started popping off and pretty sure that was before Fortnite and Phil wasn't interested

Mike HATED interacting with the Xbot zealots of the world and did his best not to attend the silly luncheons but he has gotten together with actual gaming friends but those pic didn't need to be on social medias

Mike did think that remote play would be huge for Xbox and would let me (and a couple of others) have access to his home consoles and let people play his games on Mixer while he was at work

That last move got a guy perma banned for Xbox for putting Mikes ultra rare cars from Forza for sale then buying them on his private account
 
Oppoi

Oppoi

Member
If only you could see Phil's tears you guys... he cares too much about gaming... this decision was the hardest thing he ever had to suffer through... Please remember the gaming T-shirts... remember the photos of Phil and his staff all smiling... How dare you all attack him like this?
 
CoreyFlawless

CoreyFlawless

Member
As long they keep gamepass going and growing it. They should be fine. I would had agree to this, but since kotaku brought it up. Then nah, Xbox must be doing something right then 🤣
 
digoutyoursoul

digoutyoursoul

Member
HeisenbergFX4 said:
They bumped heads often over games one of the bigger ones I have said before here so not revealing anything new is the Halo Infinite first screening for them and Mike actually chuckled and asked where the real trailer was and Phil green lit it

Mike said he told Phil they couldn't release that and these comments were made to a few of us before the actual reveal

Mike wanted Xbox to go super heavy into BRs once PUBG started popping off and pretty sure that was before Fortnite and Phil wasn't interested

Mike HATED interacting with the Xbot zealots of the world and did his best not to attend the silly luncheons but he has gotten together with actual gaming friends but those pic didn't need to be on social medias

Mike did think that remote play would be huge for Xbox and would let me (and a couple of others) have access to his home consoles and let people play his games on Mixer while he was at work

That last move got a guy perma banned for Xbox for putting Mikes ultra rare cars from Forza for sale then buying them on his private account
Click to expand...

Thanks for the info

And interestingly they tried to blame the pandemic for that poor Halo showing when the lockdowns had only come into effect a couple of months beforehand.

He hyped Crackdown 3 and wanted the IP to the in the same ball park as the likes of Gears. The game was…well it’s there for everyone to experience I’ll say that much.

I’m tired of the circus surrounding this guy , all I ever wanted was Xbox to be as good if not better then Sony and then Sony try to do better then then, vice versa, you know, strive to be the best for our time and money. Unfortunately certain people and influencers twist that as “toxic console war” because they know Xbox isn’t bringing it.
 
Last edited:
Katatonic

Katatonic

Member
Man, I loved the OG xbox. It had its place next to the other companies' offerings. Then the 360 happened and that dude came out with a shaved head and earring, those gross pics of Greenberg in bed, the shill media that suddenly were all in on xbox and laughing at other companies who were at least trying their best, the aggressive anti Sony marketing on TV shows, the calling people 'tards if you bought the basic 360 system, the influx of little children acting like bullies online, the AA batteries, the cult like fanbase that wasn't there for the OG. I remember getting banned from a music forum just cuz I expressed my concerns about xbox. Never gotten so dogpiled in my life. End of an era.
 
HeisenbergFX4

HeisenbergFX4

Gold Member
digoutyoursoul said:
Thanks for the info

And interestingly they tried to blame the pandemic for that poor Halo showing when the lockdowns had only come into effect a couple of months beforehand.

He hyped Crackdown 3 and wanted the IP to the in the same ball park as the likes of Gears. The game was…well it’s there for everyone to experience I’ll say that much.

I’m tired of the circus surrounding this guy , all I ever wanted was Xbox to be as good if not better then Sony and then Sony try to do better then then, vice versa, you know, strive to be the best for our time and money. Unfortunately certain people and influencers twist that as “toxic console war” because they know Xbox isn’t bringing it.
Click to expand...
I have said this here before but leading into this gen I was able to speak and even game with Phil in a friend no PR type of setting and the guy really loves what he does and really does love Xbox as a brand

His love for what he does is super infectious to those around him and I was so pumped up for Xbox leading into the launch of the Series X

But time and time again he simply has not been able to identify a game thats in trouble leading up to launch and I am over his schtick
 
CoreyFlawless

CoreyFlawless

Member
ShadowkillXNA said:
It's losing subscribers, not growing.
Click to expand...
When was this? If anything it had flat line? Maybe 1mil of them crazy hardcore use to be Xbox fans like jumping ship liken TimDog. But most ppl that don’t care bout that, that like game pass and got game pass on pc. Gamepass should be fine
 
SJRB

SJRB

Gold Member
Little Chicken said:
Is it time for fresh blood? Maybe. Phil has done a lot of good things.

Phil is a victim of not being a profit-thirsty sociopath in an industry that demands it.
Click to expand...

Pretty sure the hundreds, maybe even thousands of people who lost their jobs are more a victim than the Microsoft Xbox CEO.
 
Pejo

Pejo

Member
Guys calm down, this is still just the tail end of Don Mattrick's decisions that he made... *checks notes* about 11 years ago.

GAF told me multiple times that Phil's leadership still hasn't trickled down yet.

I have always been suspicious of Phil's leadership capabilities, and despite him being passionate about his job, he is fucking terrible at it.
 
T

Thief1987

Member
How we won't give a pass to an exec in a gamer t-shirt? HE IS A GAMER, he is one of us, don't touch him with your dirty hands kotaku.
 
diffusionx

diffusionx

Gold Member
It's incredible that a guy who rose up the corporate ladder for Microsoft was able to convince people he was the chill uncle of vidya. For that alone he deserves the job.
 
Last edited:
BlackTron

BlackTron

Gold Member
Punished Miku said:
I still think he's the best man for the job right now. Xbox is in uncharted territory in terms of transitioning from being a platform holder, running a major sub, planning a PC UI, all while a lot of customer demographic and development cost elements in gaming are just as rapidly shifting for everyone. They're literally in the middle of a transformation of every aspect of their business, that he's executing. Would be pretty ridiculous to put in a new person in the middle of that. Not sure what anyone realistically expects to happen there.

Tango will go down as the worst thing under his tenure though. Even the Xbox console dying itself is not that big a deal when they'll be positioned on PC.

Once they've transitioned to a fully 3rd party publisher, it's not going to really matter who runs it. Every 3rd party publisher CEO is the same. Profit driven entirely, and looks to new trends. That's all that will be left to do and they'll get someone else.
Click to expand...

Yes, the best man for the job of using Phil Spencer's arm to pass a torch over to a new man would be, coincidentally, Phil Spencer
 
Punished Miku

Punished Miku

Human Rights Subscription Service
BlackTron said:
Yes, the best man for the job of using Phil Spencer's arm to pass a torch over to a new man would be, coincidentally, Phil Spencer
Click to expand...
Well they could put in an interim CEO like Sony did right now. Personally I dont think it would be an improvement.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Locked
Xbox Boss Phil Spencer to Kick Off PAX West 2024 With Storytime Speech
2
87
5K
TheThreadsThatBindUs replied
Xbox Boss Phil Spencer Addresses Studio Closures: "I have to run a bussiness"
Game Dev 2 3 4
151
9K
simpatico replied
VGC: "Phil Spencer, for so long cast as Xbox’s saviour, may ultimately be remembered as the man who killed it.”
Opinion Business 2 3
142
14K
March Climber replied
Phil Spencer Has Now Been Head of Xbox for 10 Years; We Look Back at His First Decade
4
1K
Oppoi replied
IGN: Phil Spencer Has Now Been Head of Xbox for 10 Years; We Look Back at His First Decade
Opinion Analysis 2 3
130
11K
ZehDon replied
Top Bottom