• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga News/Discussion |OTE| Thought it was a smut paradise, it was shounen hell

Status
Not open for further replies.

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I hope it's a short one.

Failure of a Heroine volume 5


This keep being one of the better shojo I'm reading at the moment. Between the silly facial expressions everyone makes (as shown up there), the way the interactions between the characters are handled and the whole idiocy of the premise it manages to stay fresh and funny while moving the plot forward, building the characters steadily and creating interesting situations.
I see that the scanlations have really picked up the pace since I last looked and are even getting close to the last volume. Given how the official release in Italy has been coming out slowly, resisting the urge to check scans is gonna be hard.
That girl better be going "OH HO HO HO HO"
 
Haha. Popping up in different Jump manga after the end of Medaka Box would be the most fitting Ajimu conclusion I can think of.

I would love to see this.'

Our Love counseling

Hey look what I found. Tosh's debut work (In jump not H). Art style stirs up some nostalgic memories.
 

Kurita

Member
I hope it's a short one.

Failure of a Heroine volume 5


This keep being one of the better shojo I'm reading at the moment. Between the silly facial expressions everyone makes (as shown up there), the way the interactions between the characters are handled and the whole idiocy of the premise it manages to stay fresh and funny while moving the plot forward, building the characters steadily and creating interesting situations.
I see that the scanlations have really picked up the pace since I last looked and are even getting close to the last volume. Given how the official release in Italy has been coming out slowly, resisting the urge to check scans is gonna be hard.

Man I really need to start reading it....
 
Soma

Damn that's a hell of a pick for the first match. Seems like something that Elite Ten dude would have some "extra" involvement with imo.

Will this be where Alice joins the others (lol) or is she still too strong.
 
MncibQ6.jpg

Infinite Stratos (YUUKI Homura) 8

Had to look up what an AGP was.

If that's what this is, then I may have found another Houki comrade.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Soma

Damn that's a hell of a pick for the first match. Seems like something that Elite Ten dude would have some "extra" involvement with imo.

Will this be where Alice joins the others (lol) or is she still too strong.

I don't actually understand Eizan's goal here. There was some kind of feud with Soma, but he's mostly helping him get farther so far. Perhaps he just wants to build up his reputation so he can have a Shokugeki with him with his Elite 10 seat on the line? Is there a prize involved in the tournament? I could validly see Soma actually getting on the E10 by beating him since he's literally the lowest ranked guy in the E10 who isn't Erina.

But in any case, Alice is about to get Worfed.
 

Antiwhippy

the holder of the trombone
I don't actually understand Eizan's goal here. There was some kind of feud with Soma, but he's mostly helping him get farther so far. Perhaps he just wants to build up his reputation so he can have a Shokugeki with him with his Elite 10 seat on the line? Is there a prize involved in the tournament? I could validly see Soma actually getting on the E10 by beating him since he's literally the lowest ranked guy in the E10 who isn't Erina.

But in any case, Alice is about to get Worfed.

You know that saying, the higher they are the harder they fall.

Though I expect soma to thwart whatever he tries to pull anyway.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
You know that saying, the higher they are the harder they fall.

Though I expect soma to thwart whatever he tries to pull anyway.

I'm just suspecting maybe he wants Soma to win so he can take it from him in a Shokugeki. If he just wanted him expelled, it would be a matter of just demanding it in a battle (which Soma wouldn't turn down.) Its also possible he just wants him to win so that his reputation will go up and then he'll try and force Soma to be his underling (which is supposedly his gimmick.) In any case, as long as we don't go back to "Soma gets expelled if he loses!" its fine.
 
I don't actually understand Eizan's goal here. There was some kind of feud with Soma, but he's mostly helping him get farther so far. Perhaps he just wants to build up his reputation so he can have a Shokugeki with him with his Elite 10 seat on the line? Is there a prize involved in the tournament? I could validly see Soma actually getting on the E10 by beating him since he's literally the lowest ranked guy in the E10 who isn't Erina.

But in any case, Alice is about to get Worfed.

Seems he's trying to gauge his abilities by pushing people he thinks are stronger than Soma and if they win against him he can act as Soma isn't worth his time plus fulfill his promise of crushing Soma's progress? Plus with his connections he might be trying to do it without getting his hands dirty (all of a sudden some random mook is in the finals and we know jack shit about him)

But we all know Soma is the MC so he's gonna have some plot armor to help with that.


@ bold: she must join the Harem at some point :p
 

Antiwhippy

the holder of the trombone
I'm kinda hoping that he actually gets expelled at some point.

Then he goes on a training arc with a trickster mentor his dad will introduce.

Complete that shounen circle.
 

upandaway

Member
Shokugeki no Soma

I don't actually understand Eizan's goal here. There was some kind of feud with Soma, but he's mostly helping him get farther so far. Perhaps he just wants to build up his reputation so he can have a Shokugeki with him with his Elite 10 seat on the line? Is there a prize involved in the tournament? I could validly see Soma actually getting on the E10 by beating him since he's literally the lowest ranked guy in the E10 who isn't Erina.

But in any case, Alice is about to get Worfed.
At worst she'll get beaten in a fuzzy way that won't actually "prove" anything, similar to Hayama winning last time. It's still way too early in the manga to start drawing powerlevel lines.

About the dude, we don't actually know anything about his motivations or goals besides "that dude's kinda annoying" so who knows what's going on. But I agree that if the way to get into the E10 is by a shokugeki with one of them, he's going down. I'm also guessing whenever he does, it'll be after Erina passed him (or proved her superiority to him in a roundabout way).

We're still clueless about this whole scenario. Is this tournament to replace the graduating E10s? Is it going to involve unseating the current ones? Are there gonna be more than one in the tournament who can get in? How the hell did Erina get in before this tournament? Will there be more chances after this tournament aside from waiting a year? Is there even an equivalent tournament for the second years or is this the last chance (outside of E10s betting their status in a fight)?

Man I'm still waiting for Soma's Doujima to happen. If it ends up being Erina that would just be silly. Isshiki could do it though.
 
I'm kinda hoping that he actually gets expelled at some point.

Then he goes on a training arc with a trickster mentor his dad will introduce.

Complete that shounen circle.

Get expelled, get forced to go through some training arc his dad sets up on the condition if he passes it, he'll get back in.

Passes it and he'll grown and we can see everyone else grown as well during the time he was gone.

A win/win.

Unless Erina was part of the training arc.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Shokugeki no Soma


At worst she'll get beaten in a fuzzy way that won't actually "prove" anything, similar to Hayama winning last time. It's still way too early in the manga to start drawing powerlevel lines.

About the dude, we don't actually know anything about his motivations or goals besides "that dude's kinda annoying" so who knows what's going on. But I agree that if the way to get into the E10 is by a shokugeki with one of them, he's going down. I'm also guessing whenever he does, it'll be after Erina passed him (or proved her superiority to him in a roundabout way).

We're still clueless about this whole scenario. Is this tournament to replace the graduating E10s? Is it going to involve unseating the current ones? Are there gonna be more than one in the tournament who can get in? How the hell did Erina get in before this tournament? Will there be more chances after this tournament aside from waiting a year? Is there even an equivalent tournament for the second years or is this the last chance (outside of E10s betting their status in a fight)?

Man I'm still waiting for Soma's Doujima to happen. If it ends up being Erina that would just be silly. Isshiki could do it though.

As far as I can tell, that is considered a valid way to get onto the Elite 10 (since Isshiki did sort of imply he could challenge him if he had adequate compensation), but obviously some of them just graduate, so I guess you get...appointed? (or they have a tournament?) Perhaps you can't simply "leapfrog" a particular person, either. I wouldn't be surprised that beating Seat 9 doesn't make you Seat 9, it makes you Seat 10 and Seat 9 just gets booted.

I don't think so, in terms of a second year tournament. All of the people we've seen in it are first years, so I don't think its an open event.
 

Antiwhippy

the holder of the trombone
Get expelled, get forced to go through some training arc his dad sets up on the condition if he passes it, he'll get back in.

Passes it and he'll grown and we can see everyone else grown as well during the time he was gone.

A win/win.

Unless Erina was part of the training arc.

This. THIS is going to happen.

I'm sure of it.
 

Kieli

Member
Soma needs plot armor? The fuck is this shit.

That boy is the real deal. He's a prodigy AND survived 500 fights with the motherfuckin' Asura.

Alice is but a one measly stepping stone to his ultimate goal of world domination.
 

Kieli

Member
Get expelled, get forced to go through some training arc his dad sets up on the condition if he passes it, he'll get back in.

Passes it and he'll grown and we can see everyone else grown as well during the time he was gone.

A win/win.

Unless Erina was part of the training arc.

Yeah, I like this one the most. Have him lose a Shokugeki and get expelled. Time-skip of a few years where he travels all over the world like his pops to level up.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
This. THIS is going to happen.

I'm sure of it.

Except his dad doesn't have the authority to just let him back in. I honestly think they're going to really tone down the "everyone is expelled" stuff.

Yeah, I like this one the most. Have him lose a Shokugeki and get expelled. Time-skip of a few years where he travels all over the world like his pops to level up.

It's a high-school waifu series. I think that would kind of defeat the whole idea. There isn't a bigger arc than Soma going to Tootsuki.
 

scy

Member
Are we that desperate for a Soma timeskip? Don't think we need one. Can just drag things out for going through the ranks. Maybe add an underground group.
 

duckroll

Member
The new arc for Silver Spoon is "Four Seasons". Arakawa is definitely done with the Spring/Summer/Fall/Winter format. I suppose this new arc will cover the entire second year. Good to know she's smart enough not to recycle the same formula for another school year. This is gonna be good. :D
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
The new arc for Silver Spoon is "Four Seasons". Arakawa is definitely done with the Spring/Summer/Fall/Winter format. I suppose this new arc will cover the entire second year. Good to know she's smart enough not to recycle the same formula for another school year. This is gonna be good. :D

I really hope so. I thought the Winter arc dragged on a lot with very little resolution of any of the remaining stuff.

Are we that desperate for a Soma timeskip? Don't think we need one. Can just drag things out for going through the ranks. Maybe add an underground group.

The School itself is pretty much the Hogwarts of the series. I don't think its relevant what Soma does outside of it; the Shokugeki battles unique to the school are in the title.
 

scy

Member
The new arc for Silver Spoon is "Four Seasons". Arakawa is definitely done with the Spring/Summer/Fall/Winter format. I suppose this new arc will cover the entire second year. Good to know she's smart enough not to recycle the same formula for another school year. This is gonna be good. :D

So one big arc?

The School itself is pretty much the Hogwarts of the series. I don't think its relevant what Soma does outside of it.

The only outside the school stuff we'll care about will involve more magiccooking. Like, a return to the hometown to torture that poor childhood friend.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
So one big arc?



The only outside the school stuff we'll care about will involve more magiccooking. Like, a return to the hometown to torture that poor childhood friend.

I'm just going to be disappointed if Alice joins the harem. Its a lot more interesting when your ultra large cast has more complicated relationships than:

Every female ---> MC <------ oblivious
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I bet anything that Soma's mom was also a tsundere.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Pretty sure Alice will join the harem just to spite Erina.

I don't think anyone knows about Erina's secret Somalust other than Isshiki (its probable that Hisako does also, but doesn't say anything about it)
 
After watching almost all of the anime (should finish it tomorrow), I'd quite like to read the Hyouka novels. Hopefully a Western publisher or something will pick it up and release translated versions of the novels. It's really fascinating, and I love Chitanda.

I'd like to read any of the nuances of the story the anime may have missed and if the mysteries are more complex in written form.

And if there's any romance :3
 
After watching almost all of the anime (should finish it tomorrow), I'd quite like to read the Hyouka novels. Hopefully a Western publisher or something will pick it up and release translated versions of the novels. It's really fascinating, and I love Chitanda.

I'd like to read any of the nuances of the story the anime may have missed and if the mysteries are more complex in written form.

And if there's any romance :3

3 novel volumes are translated. And 1 volume of the manga is done too.
 
3 novel volumes are translated. And 1 volume of the manga is done too.

sure, but are they published and released for purchase? I like to purchase light novels if I can, otherwise I'm willing to wait a bit until I know one way or another if we'll get a legitimate release or not.

I like having the physical book to read.

But thanks for the heads up :)
 
One of the other points is that there are people who share common lewd interests that may not be following the thread that closely, so they can just peer into the list and see what A Huge Battleship is reading and think, "It's probably porn" and "Reading". That's the reason why I label each link with a poster name.
Woah, back up a sec, when did I become the resident porn guy? I'm as pure as distilled water lapped up from the hands of an angel. Is it the avatar? It's the avatar isn't it?

Rock Paper Scissors 1

O21JHrQ.jpg


Harem series set in a floating academic city in the Pacific, where kids with superpowers reside. Too early to say for sure how it'll develop, but the setting's home to 1,048 student councils so they'll probably be beating the bananas out of each-other at some stage. I lost count of the number of panty shots about halfway through. Based on a light novel and will likely be bad. Added to backlog.
 
The new arc for Silver Spoon is "Four Seasons". Arakawa is definitely done with the Spring/Summer/Fall/Winter format. I suppose this new arc will cover the entire second year. Good to know she's smart enough not to recycle the same formula for another school year. This is gonna be good. :D

Oh that's cool, a sped up second and probably third year would be pretty interesting especially if a good chunk of that time is spent on studying for exams anyway.
 

Necrovex

Member
I've started to read manga again (I needed a break from powering through Words of Radiance), so I started up on reading through One Piece again (the arc right after Thriller Bark). I plan to read Oyasumi PunPun once I catch up on One Piece. I am also debating to finally read through Shaman King.

What is the overall thoughts on SK? I heard the ending is bad, but is it now a moot point due to the sequel? I read a few volumes of it during high school (five-to-six years back) and enjoyed it.
 

scy

Member
Woah, back up a sec, when did I become the resident porn guy? I'm as pure as distilled water lapped up from the hands of an angel. Is it the avatar? It's the avatar isn't it?

Rock Paper Scissors 1

Harem series set in a floating academic city in the Pacific, where kids with superpowers reside. Too early to say for sure how it'll develop, but the setting's home to 1,048 student councils so they'll probably be beating the bananas out of each-other at some stage. I lost count of the number of panty shots about halfway through. Based on a light novel and will likely be bad. Added to backlog.

I feel like this was on purpose.

Anyway, if anything I think you're my resident "someone in this might kill someone" suggestions guy. But that's really all based off of Screaming Lesson posts forever ago.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom