Another one joins our ranks.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTL| Not a lick of constructive conversation here
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Nah, I think it's just him blowing things up bigger than they are, like he usually does.
here it is folks, mangaf novid
"God's Beard!"
Member
Fucking mangaf is the worst word ever. At least use manGAFans or something that actually makes sense. I don't get why you need a label anyway.
Ignis Fatuus
Banned
[QUOTE="God's Beard!";56876454]Fucking mangaf is the worst word ever. At least use manGAFans or something that actually makes sense. I don't get why you need a label anyway.[/QUOTE]
You can take the Man out of the ManGAF, but you can't take the GAF out of the Man. Therefore ManGAF.
You can take the Man out of the ManGAF, but you can't take the GAF out of the Man. Therefore ManGAF.
"God's Beard!"
Member
The whole label thing creeps me out. I dunno what the whole desperation over the sense of community deal is. Hell, I can't even remember more than two or three names from these threads and I've been posting in here for years.
But there's only children in here.
But there's only children in here.
Yellow Gate END
I feel this probably could have gone on for a few more volumes and still been entertaining but at least it had a proper ending. I thought all of the characters were fun and the art was good enough but the story wasn't great. Only three people actually tried to become the head and none of them were even villians in the end. I will check out the authors other works in the future. 7/10
EDIT: ManGAF is dumb. Why not just MangaGAF?
I feel this probably could have gone on for a few more volumes and still been entertaining but at least it had a proper ending. I thought all of the characters were fun and the art was good enough but the story wasn't great. Only three people actually tried to become the head and none of them were even villians in the end. I will check out the authors other works in the future. 7/10
EDIT: ManGAF is dumb. Why not just MangaGAF?
"God's Beard!"
Member
Team Medical Dragon
For some reason I still try to keep up with this, but somewhere along the line it's become stale to the point that it's unreadable. I could literally fall asleep reading it.
For some reason I still try to keep up with this, but somewhere along the line it's become stale to the point that it's unreadable. I could literally fall asleep reading it.
"God's Beard!"
Member
Then just scrap the thought and don't use a label. The whole idea annoys me.
gundamkyoukai
Member
Who cares what it is call once people understand what people are saying .
Be it MangaGAF , Mangaf etc etc
Be it MangaGAF , Mangaf etc etc
Freshmaker
I am Korean.
He had a glowing punch that left a burn on Jiraya!!!
dakkumauji
Member
Tadashii Kodomo no Tsukurikata! 24
WOULD YOU LOOK AT THAT HAIR. IT'S LIKE A FREAKING CAPE.
WOULD YOU LOOK AT THAT HAIR. IT'S LIKE A FREAKING CAPE.
"God's Beard!"
Member
My problem other than potentially being lumped in with random people is that nobody outside of this thread is going to know what mangaf means. It's never going to read as manga readers to anybody, defeating the whole point of an already dumb idea.
Don't you hate when someone says "oh gaffers are a bunch of bandwagoning elitist gamers incapable of independent thought or reasoned discussion" or "oh, redditors are a bunch of cocksucking liberal potheads that ruin memes in 2 hours" or "wow feminists are a bunch of cunts that can't take a joke"?
Whenever you willingly label yourself you're defining your personality by a community of people you don't necessarily get along with and inviting strangers to treat you dismissively.
Crash Station
Member
[QUOTE="God's Beard!";56877368]My problem other than potentially being lumped in with random people is that nobody outside of this thread is going to know what mangaf means. It's never going to read as manga readers to anybody, defeating the whole point of an already dumb idea.
Don't you hate when someone says "oh gaffers are a bunch of bandwagoning elitist gamers incapable of independent thought or reasoned discussion" or "oh, redditors are a bunch of cocksucking liberal potheads that ruin memes in 2 hours" or "wow feminists are a bunch of cunts that can't take a joke"?
Whenever you willingly label yourself you're defining your personality by a community of people you don't necessarily get along with and inviting strangers to treat you dismissively.[/QUOTE]
So if you don't consider yourself as part of the community, why do you get annoyed at how the community decides to label themselves?
Don't you hate when someone says "oh gaffers are a bunch of bandwagoning elitist gamers incapable of independent thought or reasoned discussion" or "oh, redditors are a bunch of cocksucking liberal potheads that ruin memes in 2 hours" or "wow feminists are a bunch of cunts that can't take a joke"?
Whenever you willingly label yourself you're defining your personality by a community of people you don't necessarily get along with and inviting strangers to treat you dismissively.[/QUOTE]
So if you don't consider yourself as part of the community, why do you get annoyed at how the community decides to label themselves?
gundamkyoukai
Member
[QUOTE="God's Beard!";56877368]My problem other than potentially being lumped in with random people is that nobody outside of this thread is going to know what mangaf means. It's never going to read as manga readers to anybody, defeating the whole point of an already dumb idea.
Don't you hate when someone says "oh gaffers are a bunch of bandwagoning elitist gamers incapable of independent thought or reasoned discussion" or "oh, redditors are a bunch of cocksucking liberal potheads that ruin memes in 2 hours" or "wow feminists are a bunch of cunts that can't take a joke"?
Whenever you willingly label yourself you're defining your personality by a community of people you don't necessarily get along with and inviting strangers to treat you dismissively.[/QUOTE]
Being a member of GAF \ certain internet boards going to get you label .
Just being in certain threads or talking about certain topics it's the same way .
There are good and bad aspects of it but i not going to worry my head if it don't effect me offline .
Don't you hate when someone says "oh gaffers are a bunch of bandwagoning elitist gamers incapable of independent thought or reasoned discussion" or "oh, redditors are a bunch of cocksucking liberal potheads that ruin memes in 2 hours" or "wow feminists are a bunch of cunts that can't take a joke"?
Whenever you willingly label yourself you're defining your personality by a community of people you don't necessarily get along with and inviting strangers to treat you dismissively.[/QUOTE]
Being a member of GAF \ certain internet boards going to get you label .
Just being in certain threads or talking about certain topics it's the same way .
There are good and bad aspects of it but i not going to worry my head if it don't effect me offline .
Well, there is one way, if they decide to do some sort of Golgo 13 styled Spinoff with the characters doing stuff years later. But this defiantly seems like something that should have a nice ending in a few years. I'm expecting it to make it to around 200 chapters.
AlphaDragoon
Member
To be fair, the Mario 6 page chapter that just popped up seems different from that big one that came out a few weeks ago.
Seems like the one we saw before was the original concept he'd been working on since 10 years ago and this new one is the actual thing he's shopping to editors.
brotkasten
Member
Trinity Seven 3-7
This is finally getting somewhere. I think I even saw something that resembled your average shonen plot, even if it was full of cliches. The bluntness of the MC is somewhat refreshing. This really might be another regular read for me, mostly because all the harem stuff isn't that bad/creepy yet. When they talked about being partners, I didn't expect that they're supposed to be a couple, though. That was fast.
This is finally getting somewhere. I think I even saw something that resembled your average shonen plot, even if it was full of cliches. The bluntness of the MC is somewhat refreshing. This really might be another regular read for me, mostly because all the harem stuff isn't that bad/creepy yet. When they talked about being partners, I didn't expect that they're supposed to be a couple, though. That was fast.
Neoriceisgood
Member
Is it me or did Bleach have more backgrounds than usual this week?
brotkasten
Member
You almost fooled me.
I think so. One Piece also had content that mattered and Narutu had good content. What a week.
Neoriceisgood
Member
Could've made a joke about how OP wasn't cluttered for once man, I'm ashamed of you.
brotkasten
Member
He said "content that mattered", that's pretty much the same.
Iinari Princess 1-3
A princess who goes to a Japanese school goes to the schools roof to fart but is seen by the MC. So she does the obvious thing and gets him to kiss her foot and become her lover. The MC takes advantage of this chance and gives her arse a squeeze, this isn't enough for him though so he proceeds to lick her pussy why he's down there. This is borderline H that sits on the very edge. I like that the main girl is totally fine with all the sexual stuff they do and isn't telling the MC off like so many main girls do.
A princess who goes to a Japanese school goes to the schools roof to fart but is seen by the MC. So she does the obvious thing and gets him to kiss her foot and become her lover. The MC takes advantage of this chance and gives her arse a squeeze, this isn't enough for him though so he proceeds to lick her pussy why he's down there. This is borderline H that sits on the very edge. I like that the main girl is totally fine with all the sexual stuff they do and isn't telling the MC off like so many main girls do.
Brotkasten's got me covered.
brotkasten
Member
Trinity Seven 8-10
I bet stuff like Fairy Tail would be much easier to read, if it wouldn't take itself so seriously and rather have an approach like this.
Levi continues to be the best girl.
The more serious parts, where Arata learns his stuff were okay and I suppose I shouldn't complain about this, but the constant groping of the teacher's tits is starting to annoy me.
Now that we have six of the Trinity Seven, I guess it's going to be about finding the last girl next. But I really hope that Arata's book is actually super evil or something. Just to mix things up a bit.
I bet stuff like Fairy Tail would be much easier to read, if it wouldn't take itself so seriously and rather have an approach like this.
Levi continues to be the best girl.
The more serious parts, where Arata learns his stuff were okay and I suppose I shouldn't complain about this, but the constant groping of the teacher's tits is starting to annoy me.
Now that we have six of the Trinity Seven, I guess it's going to be about finding the last girl next. But I really hope that Arata's book is actually super evil or something. Just to mix things up a bit.
gundamkyoukai
Member
Kaichou wa Maid-sama
Last arc was no that great but last 2 or 3 chapter were good .
Good to know it's ending soon which is the reason i start back reading .
Side note i read more manga than i thought i would since the big 3 was on break .
Last arc was no that great but last 2 or 3 chapter were good .
Good to know it's ending soon which is the reason i start back reading .
Side note i read more manga than i thought i would since the big 3 was on break .
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Trinity Seven 8-10
I bet stuff like Fairy Tail would be much easier to read, if it wouldn't take itself so seriously and rather have an approach like this.
Levi continues to be the best girl.
The more serious parts, where Arata learns his stuff were okay and I suppose I shouldn't complain about this, but the constant groping of the teacher's tits is starting to annoy me.
Now that we have six of the Trinity Seven, I guess it's going to be about finding the last girl next. But I really hope that Arata's book is actually super evil or something. Just to mix things up a bit.
It's a harem manga man. Guess what his book actually is.
brotkasten
Member
His magic book is the Kama Sutra?
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Just keep reading. 
Trinity Seven 27
Good for levi.
But man the magic system is pretty much just pure bullshit.
Trinity Seven 27
Good for levi.
But man the magic system is pretty much just pure bullshit.
brotkasten
Member
Trinity Seven, 11-14
I guess we're at the predictable part of the story, where the former and lost member of the Seven vanished a while ago and is back now, but super evil or whatever. Her outfit is questionable at best. The fight was quite boring as well and couldn't even be saved with that hot sister-on-sister scene. Now it's on to the training arc, yay!
I guess we're at the predictable part of the story, where the former and lost member of the Seven vanished a while ago and is back now, but super evil or whatever. Her outfit is questionable at best. The fight was quite boring as well and couldn't even be saved with that hot sister-on-sister scene. Now it's on to the training arc, yay!
brotkasten
Member
One Punch-Man (superhero who defeats his enemies with one punch. it's amazing as it sounds and has fantastic art)
Molester Man (short and sweet, nothing like the title suggests)
7 Seeds (longer read with a slow beginning, but absolutely worth it)
Berserk
Green Blood (spaghetti western, fantastic art, relatively short)
Makai no Ossan
BassForever
Member
Post your list lol that way we know what you've already read
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
It'd take me a long ass time to post what I've read...
The ship salvaging sounds cool though ill give that a bash
Dedication Through Light
Member
Undertaker Riddle
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Alright, if you want to give that a crack, heed my advice: like 7 seeds, give it a few chapters for it to really develop. The main character can be annoying, but it gets incredible, much like 7 seeds.
Also has some of the best bromance in manga.
brotkasten
Member
Trinity Seven, 15-18.5
One of the most heartwarming scenes I've ever read in a manga.
Now this second round is much better. Very little training, but a jump to a different fight instead. It was nice to see the headmaster a bit in action, even though his Muten Roshi-style defeat was a bit lame. That Araten's Grimoire is a BDSM loli is kinda ... disgusting? I don't know. I definitely don't like it. I hope she won't be in her human form all the time now. I can't say the last fight ended as expected, but it didn't surprise me either. Neither does the other super evil mage, who's apparently the lost cousin. Eh, whatever.
(On a different note: Pythagoras being an ancient mage definitely explains his math)
One of the most heartwarming scenes I've ever read in a manga.
Now this second round is much better. Very little training, but a jump to a different fight instead. It was nice to see the headmaster a bit in action, even though his Muten Roshi-style defeat was a bit lame. That Araten's Grimoire is a BDSM loli is kinda ... disgusting? I don't know. I definitely don't like it. I hope she won't be in her human form all the time now. I can't say the last fight ended as expected, but it didn't surprise me either. Neither does the other super evil mage, who's apparently the lost cousin. Eh, whatever.
(On a different note: Pythagoras being an ancient mage definitely explains his math)
Yes, read this now.
- Status