I've been plowing through Lucha Underground and just finished Aztec Warfare. Overall, I'm really digging this promotion. It feels fresh, and packs in plenty of content into one hour of television. To break it down by category:
The Wrestling: My only real exposure to watching Lucha Libre is from being a huge WCW fan when I was a child. Of course I have familiarity with certain Luchadores since then, such as Mysterio and Mistico, but modern Lucha Libre is a new game for me. It is fast, frantic, and fun. There are times where I think that match psychology gets thrown out the window and it becomes a glorified spotfest. Sometimes, it can be enjoyable, other times I kind of just roll my eyes at it. Some wrestler's are more guilty of this than others, but for the most part the matches are an overall success. It's refreshing to see some wrestling that incorporates more moves than the standard bodyslam/headlock fare that the WWE has become guilty of. I do have issues where some wrestlers use moves as if they are a CAW from a game. I might be going into Stone Cold territory here, but some moves need to be protected. For instance, an F5 shouldn't be used as a regular move with no real impact. Just because you can spam every finishing move in the history of wrestling doesn't mean you should. There has also been plenty of times where the match flow will come to a halt and stand like an idiot as their opponent prepares to do their move. An example is from a triple threat with Pentagon, Drago, and Fenix. Pentagon and Drago were fighting outside of the ring, but stopped to walk over to Dario's office so they could catch Fenix. It's a cool spot, but getting there could have gone much smoother.
Presentation: I'm loving the gritty atmosphere brought on by the production. The LU temple has a great look, it's something that I wouldn't find out of place in a comic book. Despite being a well polished production, everything appears dirty even down to the ring. It contributes to the Underground aspect and helps in the illusion that you're not watching a typlcal wrestling program. I've read that the backstage snippets are reminiscent of Spanish Soap Opera's. I really have no knowledge of that, but I like the approach that is taken to film these snippet's like a tv show. Of course some of the wrestler's aren't that good at acting, and there may have been a couple segments too much of Dario and Konnan nodding at each other, but it's a fresh perspective on an aspect of wrestling that's been around for decades.
Character Work: Nine episodes in and I'm really appreciating the amount of work that is going in to build these characters. Despite many of them having similar appearances, there are distinct personalities displayed. You'll get a few duds here and there, but the main performers are doing a good job at standing out. Special mention goes to Dario Cueto, he plays the standard "asshole boss" character, but he brings a lot to the program.
Commentary: I like it, but sometimes I'm a little mixed on the Striker/Vampiro combo. I appreciate that Striker has this vast knowledge on wrestling history, but sometimes he goes a little overboard with his references. It's nice to have these callbacks, but he averages about one a minute. I also have issues with how he calls of the moves from the performers. Why does a sitdown powerbomb have to be called a bubbabomb? Moves have been copied and stolen for years now, so why not give the wrestlers a little more personality and quit attributing their moves to other wrestlers? As for Vampiro, I find him a little dull at times, but hopefully I'll warm up to them. Lucha Underground could do a lot worse than Striker/Vampiro, just look at the WWE.
To wrap it up, I'm very much enjoying myself with Lucha Underground. I feel as if the program is really starting to find itself, and I'm looking forward to the rest of the season.
Bonus Fav Five:
5. Sexy Star - Aside from some headscissor's/arm drag's I don't know much of her ring work yet. I might be in love though, especially after her Ms. Marvel costume. I bet she won't be here next time I do a fav five, but we'll see.
4. Johnny Mundo - John Morrison has always been solid. He's done good so far in LU.
3. Drago - Incredible look. I flipped out the first time I saw him use his crucifix/trap pin.
2. King Cuerno - He uses his moves to build his character. His suicide dive is insane, and he brings a good level of intensity to his matches.
1. Prince Puma - This guy is the real f'n deal. He has a lot of high risk spots, but he also knows how to use a match to tell a story. Even if that match is under ten minutes long.
The Potential is there Five:
5. Chavo Guerrero - He is trying his damndest to have an actual personality, we'll see if he can escape the shadow of his family name. I liked him going absolute HAM with the chairs.
4. Mil Muertes - He should be the Brock Lesnar of LU, a monster that plows through everyone. It's still early though, but his in ring work has been lacking.
3. Fenix - He does some crazy shit, but that's all I see in him. I've yet to feel engaged by any of his matches outside of "hey, go jump off of that." I also don't like the spot where he cartwheel bounces off the ropes to do a cutter to the opponent behind him. It doesn't look natural.
2. Big Rick - I believe that's Ezekiel Jackson isn't it. He's being a fairly solid "big guy", but I think he can do more.
1. Pentagon Jr. - He's the reason I decided to start watching, but he hasn't been given much to work with yet aside from some tag matches.
Special Mention Category:
1. Pimpinella Escarlata - I don't know much about Exotico, but that's the funniest damn entrance ever seen. Very entertaining character.
TL;DR - Lucha Underground is cool.