Hey everyone, I just finished S2 and figured I'd post my thoughts. Short version, I thought it was a step above S1 in nearly every department but as a whole felt really unfocused and lacking overall narrative cohesion and a strong theme.
Before I begin I want to point out I know fuck all about the comics and have only general knowledge as it relates to DD, Punisher, and what ever else Marvel related that is a part of this show. I can only judge the show based off of what I was shown and not any pre-existing knowledge. I guess I'll start out with the good stuff. I loved the "new" costume, I loved the majority of fight scenes (seriously how can they be that damn good), I loved Jon Bernthal as The Punisher, and I liked Elektra, for the most part.
The funny thing is that while I enjoyed damn near every individual episode once the entire season was over I realized that as a whole the season wasn't that great. Honestly, upon reflection it felt like the season basically went off the tracks once The Punisher arc "concluded" with his capture and his brief trial. Now, what tipped me off that something was wrong with the season as a whole was in fact the ending of the season. In the last moments of the finale Karen seems to have begun to settle into her new job as a journalist and begins to write a piece about "being a hero." We cut to shots of ordinary people in the city on Christmas Eve doing ordinary things interspersed with shots of Matt walking to his office, bag in hand. She ends her piece with some poetic nonsense about how, "we are all heroes." Following this Matt walks in to his law office, opens the paper bag he is carrying and announced he is Daredevil to Karen. Boom. End credits.
The problem is that entire sequence, which has the feel of being a wonderful, epic, poetic moment has not been earned. It is almost entirely disconnected from the events that transpired throughout the season. It reminded me a lot about the ending of TDKR where we get this great classic Nolan montage as Bruce Wayne is given a eulogy and the city begins to rebuild itself in the wake of Bane. However, everything about that montage is built up throughout the film. The movie is about the city and people of Gotham and those citizens learning to rise up and take their city back, in the end this is accomplished through the inspiration and sacrifice of The Batman. The entire movie, hell the entire trilogy, is built up to this moment and it concludes the arc of the major characters in the trilogy.
To contrast lets go back and look at this similar scene at the end of DD S2. Karen talks about what it means to be a hero, for some reason. We get shots of ordinary people who haven't faced any real threat or hardship that they knew of the whole season. And, we get Matt walking to and eventually telling Karen the truth, for some reason. As a whole DD S2 lacks an overall central theme. Rather, we are given a series of really cool events that are loosely tied together to keep the plot moving. These events are indeed very cool and feel satisfying to watch as they unfold but when you piece them altogether they do not make a perfect puzzle board. Seriously, if I asked you what was the central theme of DD S2?
To be fair a lot of themes are thrown around but none of them really seem to stick for too long. From the initial trailers and the first few episodes I figured the theme would revolve around "justice" and "identity," mainly in the form of The Punisher. Frank challenges Matt's worldview and mission as he learns that his way does not always succeed in protecting the city and the people he cares about. Furthermore, he must grapple with his own identity issues as both his lives bleed together forcing him to figure out who the real Matt Murdock is, the lawyer or the vigilante? The problem is that these themes are handled haphazardly and seemingly abandoned at the drop of a dime only to pop-up once or twice later on near the end.
Basically, once the Punisher is captured the "justice" theme is apparently dropped and Matt never really has to ponder again the nature of his mission. I thought the trial of Frank itself would be the natural evolution of this theme as vigilantism itself was put on trial but that never really happens. Disappointingly the trial is quickly glossed over and Matt barely participates in it. After which Matt becomes free to pick up the mantle full-time since Foggy already knows what he does and they have no clients, thus grappling with his identity isn't really a problem.
So when the end comes and he reveals his secret to Karen I'm left scratching my head as to why? This is the same guy who confessed his undying love to Elektra and was ready to run away with her just before she was stabbed but I guess a week later is ready to start a relationship with Karen. Why? Hell, why does he harbor any feelings towards her at all besides her being an attractive female?
At the end of everything I felt unsatisfied with a lot of the elements and the characters. There seemed to be no stakes this season, no super main baddie, no driving theme, and a lot of characters were used to drive plot instead of having a real arc, especially Karen. She just happens to be the center of everything for the sole purpose of keeping the plot moving, I honestly find her insufferable at this point. And I still do not understand Foggy, at all. The entire season just felt like one big setup for another season as we are dropped further information The War, Blacksky, while they setup The Punisher, setup Kingpin, and move other characters into more convenient plot positions.
Any way, that's what I thought. I know that sounds all bad but like I said I enjoyed almost every episode it's just when viewed at as a whole I realized the shortcomings of the season.