EmCeeGramr said:
I find it interesting that the krogan are essentially a metaphor for humans. If we had nuked ourselves (something that we came absurdly close to doing many times, so it's not like "hur they bombed themselves you can't trust them with science" is really a good argument, mind you), that could have been us.
That, and the salarians developed the genophage as a deterrent. They didn't think that something so devastating would actually be used, but a way to send the krogans to a screeching halt and get them to listen up. The turian military, however, believed in a policy of retaliating with full force, and immediately bombed the krogans with the genophage once they got it.
They also apparently didn't consider the possibility of the krogan society collapsing even more. They thought it would just stop them from overpopulating. Instead, the krogan became nihilists, abandoned their civilization and colonies, and spent the next thousand years working as mercenaries and pirates. Now the krogan as a species are dying out, there's almost no hope for their society to recover, and the resilient ones still alive are ten times as determined to tear out throats. The problem just changed forms.
The Salarians knew. They're not stupid.
I dont see how people can lable the genophage as pure evil that shouldnt have been done. Its a criticism that can only be said looking back, not when the decision was made. I mean really, summary of the Krogans and their relationship with the rest of the galaxy;
- Krogans split atom and blow themselves up because they're too socially and culturally devolved to handle it.
- Krogans live in wasteland, nomadic tribes, trying to rebuild their culture. Idealy they would be left this way until they can advance enough to handle their own species.
- Salarians say hi and give them the tech, biased because they need strong forces for the Racnhi wars. Arguably a mistake.
- Krogan win Rachni wars and are respected and praised across the galaxy.
- Their fast breeding in the hostile world of Tuchunka was unchecked in space, and like a wildfire they spread at an unexpected rate.
- They started taking territory from Council races and acting aggressively. They even began to settle in already owned Council colonies. Despite being told not to.
- When finally pressured and told to get the fuck out, they dared the Council to take their worlds back. No negotiation. No reasoning. Just a "go fuck yourselves, we're cunts and we dont care".
- War with the Krogan for nearly three centuries. Why? Because the Krogan defied galactic laws, acted hostile, and initiated the whole thing because they couldnt keep their species in check.
- Krogan on the verge of winning because they breed too fucking quickly. Turians say hi, and start fucking their shit. Krogans start plummiting asteroids into Turian worlds.
- Krogans refuse to surrender. Turians say hi to the Salarians, cue Genophage.
The Salarians made the mistake of contacting the Krogan to begin with. The Turians and Salarians make the mistake with the Genophage. But the Krogans made the mistake of starting a war with
everybody.
So what do you do pre-Genophage? Sit on your hands and say "oh but life is too precious" and let the Krogan keep killing your own species for land?
The galaxy needs decision makers!