Can't wait to be able to read the whole thread - I've been a fan of MGS1, finished it something like 10 times back in the day and twice in the last few years. Due to not having PS2 until like 2 years after PS3 came out, I missed out on anything past 1.
Now I've finally gotten around to playing through the HD collection. Finished 2 today and I'm speechless. What an amazing game. I think the gameplay was a little bit more enjoyable in 1 for me, but having fresh MGS plot to go through made up for that. It felt weird and I loved it - and the second half was amazing - I love those cutscenes and twists and mindfucks.
Now I'm playing through 3 (want to beat them all in order of release) and this time around I'm loving both the plot and the gameplay so far. Refined TPP MGS gameplay, challenging but definitely fair and fun stealth mechanics and all the little bits of polish make this game an outstanding experience. I've just beaten The Pain for anyone who's wondering. I've managed to keep myself largely MGS Spoiler-free over all those years so I'll approach the thread very cautiously for now, but I might keep sharing impressions until I can properly read the thread and engage in discussion