olimario said:
I don't know how you can consider BG&E fresh or better than everything else this generation. It was pretty cut and paste action adventure with poor puzzles, poor combat, poor stealth sections, decent controls, and a great story.
I didn't say it was better than everything else this generation. I said it was my favorite. There's a difference, most notably that I could never possibly say what the best game is, as I haven't played them all, or even 1% of this generation.
How is it fresh? It's a new universe, a great story, excellent art direction and the gameplay blends many different things well: photography, combat, stealth, racing, etc.
As for combat: fighting multiple enemies was infinitely more intuitive than any other action adventure title I've played.
Puzzles: They made sense within the world and were intuitive. I didn't sit around trying to figure out any lame confusing nonsensical puzzles that a lot of other games include. Figuring out how to avoid guards and whatnot was great.
Controls: I had no problems here.
Stealth: Kicked ass. Certainly better than Zelda and other action adventure games I've played. And no, I haven't tried stuff like Splinter Cell.
It may not be revolutionary, but it was a hell of a lot more interesting than The Wind Waker.
I would say Prime is much more polished, much more fun, and much more original than BG&E.
Super. Originality (Zelda with lasers and a different perspective?) and lots of polish don't make a game fun though. Prime's immersion was its strength, but the arbitrary switching of visors and weapons to combat nearly identical enemies all the time was just a chore. Maybe that's why I'm not looking forward to it. I never even bothered to complete the game because of those frustrating dual metroids at the end and the lame as hell final boss.
But you're going to disagree, and that's fine. I'll stick with my own opinions though. I have fun with what I play, and you have fun with what you play. Just don't get all offended what not everyone on GAF is gagging for even more Metroid. It's not as inexplicable as you might think, and after all, you asked.