For all the slobbering love that MSG3 gets, it amazes me how the same subset of the fanbase will shit all over Peace Walker and MGS5 when those games do an even better job of adding to the overall themes and lore of the series. Having Venom be a throwaway "clone" (in essence) was the perfect betrayal. It makes MGS4 all the more triumphant by showing the depravity these old "war heroes" sunk to in pursuit of their goals.
Good synopsis. I agree with your insights into why the story was arranged the way it was.
Plus the gameplay was super enjoyable, so there's that.
MGS3 is my least favorite game in the series. Still think it's an amazing game, just my least favorite MGS game. I rank them,
1. MGS. Sorry, nothing beats the original. Kojima was always great. When Fukushima was in grade school, Kojima was making ahead of their time games. His greatness comes from him, and he knows it. Years
before MGS came out, I played a game called Snatcher on the Sega CD. My mind was blown. To this day, the game hasn't been surpassed in its genre imo. That game was made by Hideo Kojima. I always knew he was special. Metal Gear Solid is just when the rest of you found out.
2. MGS2. This game is a work of art. From the tanker incident in the beginning, to Raiden's introduction and the "Sons of Liberty" led by the "terrorist Solid Snake," to the greatest mind-fuck end-game ever to grace your television screen, Kojima was at his most prophetic. It's like the front half of that game was written by Kojima, and the back half of that game was written by the bastard child of Nostradamus and Socrates on acid.
3. MGS4. Loved it. Every second of it. Loved how it was the first time we played as Solid Snake since the tanker incident of MGS2,
LOVED Drebin, loved how they circled back around to everything and put warm, fuzzy feelings in my heart. Loved how he restored respect to Raiden after making him the butt of some silly jokes in MGS3 to appease fan backlash. This was Kojima saying, "Fuck you, I'm not going to turn Raiden into the whipping boy, I'm going to turn him
INTO THE LEGEND." Loved the hour long cut scenes, loved Johnny shitting himself, loved everything people hated including Zero and Jack at the end. Loved the return to Shadow Moses (
A Hind D?), loved it all.
4. MGS5. Wow. What a game. The one I put the most hours in, the one I had the most fun with. The one I would play over again if I had to boot one up and play through it starting tomorrow. Unfinished, granted. But unparalleled for what it does, also. I love stealth gameplay. Thanks to this series. What it lacked in hour long cutscenes, it gave me in the intrigue of gameplay and leaving me curious with the tapes. Sometimes I listened, sometimes I didn't. But I couldn't put the game down. When I finally got the true ending, I sat and listened to countless tapes compiled on youtube to piece together what happened and what I missed. It left me wanting more, that's what many hated, but that's what I loved.
5. MGS3. The worst MGS game is still better than any shit 99% of companies put out, so this was a great game as well. I think Eva is hotter than Quiet, and that's saying something cause she's using PS2 graphics! My least favorite Shalashaska, but he's still "pretty good." Loved the fight with The Sorrow, and the solution to beating him. Kojima's most genius boss effort since MGS1's Psycho Mantis fight. The Boss is one of the most compelling characters in the series, and no one will forget that last showdown with her. To this day, I still remember what she taught me. "The basics of CQC." Thank you, Boss.