brotkasten
Member
I think a big problem with Metro's aesthetic is the icons are very inconsistent and ugly as fuck half of the time. Sometimes for the sake of being different it just ends up being inconsistent you get some shit like this:
There are a million custom minimalist iOS themes that are have more consistency in their icons than Metro. Inconsistency also makes it look busier and messier when you port it to platforms like mobile and X1.
That's a pre-beta screenshot from Windows 8. Some of the icons have changed. But what bothered me a lot more since Windows 8, after coming from Windows Phone at that time, were the different colored tiles in combination with the purple background.
Google has the flat design nailed down, imo, and I was hoping we'd get a significant refresh of Metro with Windows 10 on PC and phones.
It never looked or felt right to me, compared to Windows Phone.