Oh and I did revisit The Rock cuz I was in the mood for some Bayhem and we were talking about it earlier. Strikes a balance between Bay's inherent vulgarity and legitimately good character work. The script was worked and reworked over by many hands, Towne, Taranitno, Sorkin, hell even Cage and Harris mentioned on the commentary they reworked the pages themselves. No matter how twisted and wacky the dramatic shape of the film gets(including a completely fuckin' POINTLESS car chase that actually makes the film slower, if anything), the characters still work.
From the outset, this look like it could have been the Sean Connery show with Cage's Goodspeed as neurotic sidekick comedy relief, and if this was any other Michael Bay movie it might have been. Instead, everything he does has a real sense of underlying duty. He's obviously not good at violence(and he never becomes an action hero, even by the end), but he does what is necessary because lives are at stake, including his wife in San Francisco. He's a reluctant hero, highly skilled in his area of expertise but recognizably human-sized in the dramatic situation he finds himself in, and it allows the audience to root for him.
Connery's character is basically Old James Bond. A man who was programmed to be a cold bastard with disregard for women and allies who now finds himself wincing a bit getting up the stairs. He's vulnerable now, even a little sentimental. He's a man who realized how utterly alone his actions have left him, and now wants to find that human connection he missed, either through reconnecting with his daughter or more importantly in the father figure role he plays to Goodspeed. Its all very John Woo Heroic Bloodshed in a way.
Ed Harris' Hummel is the best character, in a way that might actually be a bad thing? Between his performance and the writing, Hummel's motivations are alarmingly easy to sympathize with, despite the goofy James Bond villain plot he's hitched up. His cause is just, altruistic, seeking justice for the men and women who died for a country that didn't care. He's obviously a dangerous motherfucka, he has the whole Pentagon meeting hyping him up like he's the goddamn Michael Jordan of military badasses, but he also makes sure to get those kids off the island before they take it over. He tries his hardest to talk down Michael Bahn's clan of marines from a senseless death. He steers the missile away from America into the water, because he was never planning on any more deaths, that's the point. There's been too much of that shit. This is all contrasted against his henchmen who just want to get paid, and the increasing tension boils over into the best scene in the movie where they mutiny. How often do you see that, the Stormtroopers turning on Darth Vader? Its so exciting you actually get pissed when the "heroes" come in and dissolve the situation. It was Hummel's movie all along.
This is more than anybody has ever written about The Rock and I apologize for that, ***_******