• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dory16

Banned
Saying "it won't hold things back" is PR speak, saying "this is console has x TFlops" is a statement of factual architecture.
Saying it's 10.2 TF isn't a statement of the factual sustained performance and Mark Cerny said it himself by acknowledging couple of percentage drops in frequency. We also had a developer in possession of a PS5 kit that said that Sony's preference was for the code NOT to run at the maximum performance that would allow it to reach 10.2 TF: https://www.neogaf.com/posts/259287438/; https://wccftech.com/playstation-5-boost-clock-design-opens-up-a-lot-of-opportunities-says-dev/

I'm surprised by your selective detection of PR speak. What cannot be selective is member treatment by the mods despite certain people going out of their way to condone it.
 
Last edited:

Dory16

Banned
I already did a long time ago and yet you still post the same pic once again(this time once again in ban review huh).
I was in the XboxEra discord for 10 days(December 31-January 10) and this is what you are looking for. At that time they let anyone who requested join. And I only stayed that long because Amber Chad said he will give me a BakaBT invite which I never got anyway.
Anyone can use any name and profile pic in discord. That profile pic in question was something I used in GAF after the Digital Foundry/Austin Evans Xbox Series X reveal and that is also when I became active again. That purple color in the name in the XboxEra discord is reserved for admins like EvilBoris. I also dont remember conversing with any of the people in your pic.
I was absent from most of Next Gen Teraflop speculation war because I was busy in real life and only occasionally posted news in xbox threads. This is also why I only have one post in the Next Gen Speculation thread.
Imagine your whole online life dedicated to talking about people you dont like because that is the only form of enjoyment you can derive.

No please explain who sends these screenshots, dont just use that card and run away.
Being part of a discord, an irc or even a dark web sub-reddit isn't a crime last time I checked. And I assume it will remain so for as long as freedom of opinion continues to mean something. Forum members should be judged based on what they say and do on this forum. What's next? People are going to have their primary school year book pictures posted on here if they where wearing an xbox t-shirt when they were 6?
 
Last edited:

SleepDoctor

Banned
Being part of a discord, an irc or even a dark web sub-reddit isn't a crime last time I checked. And I assume it will remain so for as long as freedom of opinion continues to mean something. Forum members should be judged based on what they say and do on this forum. What's next? People are going to have their primary school year book pictures posted on here if they where wearing an xbox t-shirt when they were 6?


"Oh look at that, he had an Xbox shirt on for his kindergarten picture..... someone shoot him"
 

pawel86ck

Banned
Saying it's 10.2 TF isn't a statement of the factual sustained performance and Mark Cerny said it himself by acknowledging couple of percentage drops in frequency. We also had a developer in possession of a PS5 kit that said that Sony's preference was for the code NOT to run at the maximum performance that would allow it to reach 10.2 TF: https://www.neogaf.com/posts/259287438/; https://wccftech.com/playstation-5-boost-clock-design-opens-up-a-lot-of-opportunities-says-dev/

I'm surprised by your selective detection of PR speak. What cannot be selective is member treatment by the mods despite certain people going out of their way to condone it.
I'm happy to see there are people here who can look at facts rather than blindly believe PR speak.

I wanted to continue this discussion in next gen thread rather than spaming this particular thread, but few minutes ago I was removed from next gen thread permanently for mentioning what Cerny has said in regards to PS5 GPU 2GHz clock. I'm not mad, because I'm doing everything I can to fallow the rules and try to be fair to people, but I'm not expecting people will be fair to me in return.
 

SleepDoctor

Banned
I'm happy to see there are people here who can look at facts rather than blindly believe PR speak.

I wanted to continue this discussion in next gen thread rather than spaming this particular thread, but few minutes ago I was removed from next gen thread permanently for mentioning what Cerny has said in regards to PS5 GPU 2GHz clock. I'm not mad, because I'm doing everything I can to fallow the rules and try to be fair to people, but I'm not expecting people will be fair to me in return.


Cuz they report spammed you. You weren't trolling or insulting anyone from what i saw. Yet everyone in there who throws insults and posts lies has yet to be banned.
 

MetalAlien

Banned
Something wrong with the file upload option or have I been punished?

sEbmSoH.jpg


Light theme for life!
 

Bernkastel

Ask me about my fanboy energy!
Bernkastel Bernkastel

You get a lot of shit because you're a female. Desperate, dickless virgin neckbeards will hate on you in the hopes of you showing them some attention. -Arcadia- -Arcadia- and CatLady CatLady have had similar issues.
I am a dude(I actually clarified this before), a Meitei guy if you are being specific. "Lady Bernkastel" is from Umineko, I changed it to Bernkastel to avoid confusion.
 
I am a dude(I actually clarified this before), a Meitei guy if you are being specific. "Lady Bernkastel" is from Umineko, I changed it to Bernkastel to avoid confusion.

I've never lost a boner so quick in my life.


Desperate dickless virgin neckbeards see the lady bit, the lady tag and their mind goes wild. I'm sure none of them would be bother by being slapped with a wang either 🤷‍♂️
 

Fake

Gold Member
I don't know about 'girl'. I have an image of her being a 25 stone truck driver, but whatevs.

You shouldn't not hate her for being a woman, that makes you a simp

I don't hate him because he is a girl, just because he is neutral in this console war.
Its all about pick your team and prepare for battle.

But serious, you need to be that dumb for thinking about that. We're all joking each other here in gaf no matter what. Those shit you spoke of reminds me when I was a young playing Counter-Strike in brazillian servers.
Everyone joking with each other and using shit words until a girl enter on the server and everyone stop joking for a possible white knight service to get the girl attention. Very depressing.

If you change your behavior infront a girl you're just not being yourself.
 
Last edited:
I don't hate him because he is a girl, just because he is neutral in this console war.
Its all about pick your team and prepare for battle.

But serious, you need to be that dumb for thinking about that. We're all joking each other. Those shit you spoke of reminds me when I was a young playing Counter-Strike in brazillian servers.
Everyone joking with each other and using shit words until a girl enter on the server and everyone stop joking for a possible white knight service for get the girl attention. Very depressing.

If you change your behavior infront a girl you're just not being yourself.
Arcadia is sweden? I also thought he was Einhorn🤷‍♂️

I was joking, you simp! :messenger_tears_of_joy:
 

pawel86ck

Banned
Cuz they report spammed you. You weren't trolling or insulting anyone from what i saw. Yet everyone in there who throws insults and posts lies has yet to be banned.
I'm guessing you are talking about Geordiemp. This guy really has no moral compass and make fun from everyone (even from people with health problems), but for some strange reason mods dont want to punish him for his rude behavior and I wonder why is that?
 
Last edited:
I'm guessing you are talking about Geordiemp. This guy really has no moral compass and make fun from everyone (even from people with health problems), but for some strange reasons mods dont want to punish him for his rude behavior and I wonder why is that?
Because he's a Geordie. That's what they and most Brits do.

Cunt is a term of endearment over here
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
There needs to some rule against people antagonizing some users with fake conspiracy theories in the Next Gen speculation and other related threads.

This , so much this. I am so sick of all the fake Xbox conspiracies!!!!

P.S. I saw someone posted that fake discord screen shot of you again that the guy theapp or whatever tried to stir up conspiracy controversy with a while back.

This shit needs to STOP!
 

Infamy v1

Member
Keep in mind that this screenshot first came from TheAP99. Both him and Led Guy? later said they got it from someone else. I dont remember any one from that screenshot being in the XboxEra discord group. To me it looks like someone changed his name to my then NeoGAF name and profile pic(post XSX/PS5 spec reveal) and some other ResetEra members(I dont know who they are to be honest) in their discord server, staged a drama and took a screenshot. You can use any name or profile pic you want in discord.
I also find it weird that they target me specifically. I dont participate in Next Gen speculation thread and never participated in pre-reveal tera flop speculations.

This is why when people cry about ResetEra and their hivemind/cancel culture mentality, I laugh.

NeoGAF can be a better website SO easily. It wouldn't even be hard. Except...in an attempt to stay relevant and gain back a modicum of it's lost userbase, they allowed any free email to be used and give free reign to console warriors/fanboys, and the disparity between both sides is pretty fucking vast. Saying 80% Sony fanboys seems extremely generous, but you get the picture. And these fanboys know there will be no repercussion. Maybe after 200 blatant troll posts they might get a "report me if I continue to troll" tag, which doesn't stop their routine one bit.

Look at the guy I linked earlier, Coulumb_Barrier. Straight up, blatantly mocking a developer who not only is recieving death threats from Sony fanboys (probably from him, too, given his history), but has people threatening to murder his wife and do despicable things to his child, as well. His wife can't even sleep, but this guy is victim blaming the developer (who was already cleared by Mod of War), and downplaying everything in the name of the holy console warrior crusade. Then he posts that fake Discord pic, which has ZERO correlation to the guy he is quoting, and finds a way to randomly mention your name at the end. Was he banned? Of course not.

The fake picture is incredibly transparent, too. You have a few Xbox fans that all have matching names and avatars to their NeoGAF handles, because that is what everyone on Discord does, amirite? Then you have people in the pic calling a very active moderator a "piece of shit" to try and frame things a certain way and get them banned. And like you said, ANYONE can go into any random Discord and change their name and avatar and frame a conversation.

And who was the pic posted by? A Sony superfan that became infamous and subsequently mocked on multiple gaming websites for breaking his PC when HZD was announced as going to PC, and then again when MLB The Show was announced as coming to Xbox. And he can't even get his story straight on the origin of the pic in question, amongst other things. Yet mods continue to let it be posted by the same fanboys such as Columb_Barrier, over and over, with people in multiple posts tagging Mod of War with the hope of a ban happening.

It's so fucking blatant and one-sided here. And that's why I mentioned laughing about ResetEra. It's blatant there, too, and a fucking cesspool in many ways, but this wouldn't be allowed there.
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Bill O'Rights Bill O'Rights

Since the PS5 RDNA thread was closed due to tweet being fake and OP warned could we also get the posts with a fake screen shot of one our own members, Bernkastel Bernkastel by CoulomBarrier and TLZ of removed or edited?

Posts:


Thanks in advance
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
Bernkastel Bernkastel

You get a lot of shit because you're a female. Desperate, dickless virgin neckbeards will hate on you in the hopes of you showing them some attention. -Arcadia- -Arcadia- and CatLady CatLady have had similar issues.

I just want to say that nobody on Gaf has ever been like this to me, and it's awesome.

We all get into fights for different reasons. :messenger_tears_of_joy:

Back to your regular Ban Review thread.
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
I just want to say that nobody on Gaf has ever been like this to me, and it's awesome.

We all get into fights for different reasons. :messenger_tears_of_joy:

Back to your regular Ban Review thread.

#MeToo.
Anyone hating on me has been due to my choice of console not my gender. This week I'm becoming a Nintendrone as well as as an Xbot so I expect double the hate in the near future :messenger_beaming:
 

J_Gamer.exe

Member
Then the thread will remain closed and take this as a lesson going forward. I'll check to see if there is a perm warning on the account and remove it - however, this incident will still be referenced in case it 'occurs' again. If you're going to use a reputable source to back up a claim, then always use an archive/direct link, not a screencap please. This is different to just general speculation based on a throwaway tweet, this was an assertion based a previous chain which completely derailed the thread. There was enough of a topic there to talk about without the extra fabrication. Usually when a tweet is deleted (e.g. the Ubisoft one about the 4K dispute), you will see this in its place:


Deleted tweet link showing unavailable


There is no evidence of this anywhere in the chain or the account, or in google cache. Again, like always this is an open offer - if anyone has a link to the original please furnish us with it and the thread will be re-opened.

Hello,

Here's the links I sent to mod of war of the tweet I saw and viewed. There were 2 links on my history Im not sure why but one is it.

Edited just posted the links this way... much easier...

link

link

Hope this helps....
 
Last edited:

Mod of War: Remastered

Ω
Staff Member
Post has been updated:


Now move on from all the console war drama in this thread. It's not set up for you to complain about each other, or spreading your petty meta quarrels all over the site. Thank you.
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
SuperLupeRap SuperLupeRap permed for a ban evasion, i think it's a bit harsh, i saw people getting an additional week for that, i hope you guys reconsider the decision.

I may have missed it, but I've never seen a one week add-on for ban evasion. What I've seen is every time someone makes an alt for ban evasion, they've been permed. Sorry for Super Lupe, but this is fair and reasonable in my opinion.

If you catch a ban for bad behavior go do something else for that time, don't compound your issues by trying to evade your punishment.
 
I may have missed it, but I've never seen a one week add-on for ban evasion. What I've seen is every time someone makes an alt for ban evasion, they've been permed. Sorry for Super Lupe, but this is fair and reasonable in my opinion.

If you catch a ban for bad behavior go do something else for that time, don't compound your issues by trying to evade your punishment.
I saw "Reviewed down to ...." after a evasion perm.
Edit : We already have many members back from a perm, i don't see why he doesn't deserve another chance, make a longer sentence, he don't deserve the perm imo.
 
Last edited:

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
I saw "Reviewed down to ...." after a evasion perm.
Edit : We already have many members back from a perm, i don't see why he doesn't deserve another chance, make a longer sentence, he don't deserve the perm imo.

Oh I agree there have been several perms that have been overturned but I haven't personally ever seen it for ban evasion. Unless Coulomb barrier, was he permed for ban evasion or was it something else?

Whatever, with the exception of Brap & ED look at who have had their perms overturned in recent months. You'll need TLW, GamerNyc, Bo hazem and a few of the others to come in and lobby for Super Lupe if you want it overturned :messenger_beaming:
 

Jtibh

Banned
Hey mods.
I say this with respect but please sort your shit out cuz this is just ridiculous.

Everyone knows here i am a total sony fan and this was a jab at the other xbox thread where it was about that the ps5 doesnt have rdna2.

Honestly know your users and stop giving me warnings for no reason.

Its really coming to the point where i just dont care.


gr2571S.png
 

Xaero Gravity

NEXT LEVEL lame™
Hey mods.
I say this with respect but please sort your shit out cuz this is just ridiculous.

Everyone knows here i am a total sony fan and this was a jab at the other xbox thread where it was about that the ps5 doesnt have rdna2.

Honestly know your users and stop giving me warnings for no reason.

Its really coming to the point where i just dont care.


gr2571S.png
Tell them how you really feel
 

GHG

Member
Hey mods.
I say this with respect but please sort your shit out cuz this is just ridiculous.

Everyone knows here i am a total sony fan and this was a jab at the other xbox thread where it was about that the ps5 doesnt have rdna2.

Honestly know your users and stop giving me warnings for no reason.

Its really coming to the point where i just dont care.


gr2571S.png

Deserved in my opinion.

You shouldn't speak ill of those you claim to love.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom