-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
NeoGAF Mafia |OT6| The Conversation is to Die for (Signups are now OPEN)
- Thread starter RetroMG
- Start date
Wasn't Palmer playing? What is this, I call cheats!
Uuuuugh. Those short day and night cycles combined with having to keep up with two threads, conveying messages between then AND also trying to hunt for scum ON TWO FRONTS nearly gave me a mental breakdown
Uuuuugh. Those short day and night cycles combined with having to keep up with two threads, conveying messages between then AND also trying to hunt for scum ON TWO FRONTS nearly gave me a mental breakdown
Should have just resigned yourself to messenger buy and stopped trying to scum hunt
Should have just resigned yourself to messenger buy and stopped trying to scum hunt
I kinda did that
My reads and votes sucked ass and had like 0 effort behind them. I even got some suspicion because of that. But I simply didn't had the time to also scum hunt.Crab was only really checking the schedule, we never spoke about the game itself.
Roy did well though, put in the work AND fucked Palmer, can't fault him for that.
I'd've done the opposite personally. Provide only the absolutely necessary info and laughed at anyone expecting me to transcribe their every thought and question for them.Should have just resigned yourself to messenger buy and stopped trying to scum hunt
Roy did well though, put in the work AND fucked Palmer, can't fault him for that.
I still love your remarks in the spectator thread :
Fuck roy, he plays terribly!
Damn, roy plays very well!
Ugh, roy plays horribly!
Man, roy is playing so good!.
And that flip-flopping went on for like 10 pages.
It was a difficult weekI still love your remarks in the spectator thread :
Fuck roy, he plays terribly!
Damn, roy plays very well!
Ugh, roy plays horribly!
Man, roy is playing so good!.
And that flip-flopping went on for like 10 pages.
Hyperactivity
Banned
Here is the general jist of my pm conversations with splinter:
Followed by:
oh right your last name is supposed to be the one
wtf I still can't get over it
Hyperactivity
Banned
So I'm just assuming bloodborne is gonna lynch its doctor now
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
It wouldn't be GAFia without at least one D1 doctor lynch.
When was the last day 1 doctor lynch? It has been a while.
Final Fantasy I think.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Can I get spec access to bloodborne and DP even though I'm in bar?
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
The spec thread is combined for main season, so no, you can't. Sorry, dragi~
i'd imagine bar players can barely focus on their own game let alone others :^)
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
It's not my fault I'm drunk all the time
Hyperactivity
Banned
no real need to, bar mafia has already established itself as the better game
ask yourselves: how many GOAT scum team members does YOUR game have?
Hyperactivity
Banned
i'm sure we'll be dealing with all manner of eldritch abominations, no need to add goats into the mix as well
flatearthpandas
Member
Two...
Hyperactivity
Banned
So, uh, speaking of GOAT scum...
If you're just interested, click 1st set of spoilers first
If you're just interested, click 1st set of spoilers first
This is about the Harry Potter spoilers for the Cursed Child play
We're gonna need another game now, aren't we....
better lay off the caffeine pills there jessie
it will be the first Mafia game to ever have a time travel mechanic. Why play a game now when you can play it in the past!
You don't already have your role PM? Hate to break it to you that means you don't have a cool role.
After playing unhealthy amounts of Killer Instinct and Rare Replay, I am currently devising a Rareware-themed mafia full of ridiculous and obscure mechanics. Once I get a board for it on OG, would anyone care to look over it and discuss what they think about the balance and such?
Reverse time mafia. Game starts in LyLo, but one plucky town member reverses the flow of time using the MacGuffin. Now the town has to bring back their fallen comrades one by one, but if they bring back all the Mafia as well then history repeats itself and their fate is sealed.
weemadarthur
Member
I would spectate the heck out of that.
Banjo-Kazooie or bust!
It's like a reverse Volcano Island.
The Fun Never Ends
🤔
Hyperactivity
Banned
Now that all the day 1s are over, I wanted to bring up an idea. How do the rest of you guys feel about putting the preference for night starts or shortened day 1s when everyone initially signs up. Seems like the day 1 hatred was pretty common across games.
It can work if the game start, but instead of voting people to lynch, you vote people to revive. Days are to revive, Nights play as normal, and of course you can't revive the same player twice, unless specified.
The conditions to win the game are based on this mechanic. For example, Mafia could win if they revive all their mafia players (Because they would have to convince town to revive specific players). Town wins if they revive specific roles.
Hyperactivity
Banned
have to revive one of two kings and keep them alive. There is a 3rd scum King.
if you are killed, you can't be revived, including OG players, town has to get through x number of days with an alive town King. scum wins if either there are no alive town kings or their scum King is alive
game starts with say 5 or 6 town, 2 scum.
Actually, I have other ideas, can I use this concept for a mini game this mid season
But of course. I didn't get the "jo" in my username for nothing!
YES
I like D1. The complete lack of intel forces you to make cold reads because that's all you can do.
I prefer discussing these kinds of things when no games are running, but I think the issue is the meta and not D1 itself.
Remove D1 and we'll just start hating D2. Unless you're hoping for the cop to get a red check off of RNG.
The start of the game is just difficult, there's no hiding that.
Including it in the sign up process is not a bad idea, although I suspect people will still choose games by flavour rather than day/night start
The start of the game is just difficult, there's no hiding that.
Including it in the sign up process is not a bad idea, although I suspect people will still choose games by flavour rather than day/night start
Hyperactivity
Banned
Night starts/shortened day 1 are both things. Well the 2nd has actually only been brought up, but werewolf 1 had a night start
CrimsonFist
Member
Woof 1's day 1 didn't seem much different to any other day 1's
Although not helped by the lack of a night kill.
CrimsonFist
Member
Spec thread please
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Done
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Night starts are shit. 48 hour day one, please.