I basically copied anything that wasn't a video to a usb stick and then moved it onto the harddrive of the new xbox. Instructions for using a usb stick with your 360, skip to step 3Hardyboy1224 said:
Soo you'd need to haul out your old/broken 360, stick it with a USB stick, set up the USB stick, then go to System Settings, Memory, select your harddrive, scroll down to NHL10, there's a button you can press for more info (maybe x or y?) and youll be given a prompt to delete copy or move, so youd just click move and select your usb stick.
after all that you can pop the usb stick into your new 360 and go to Memory again but this time selecting the USB stick, and moving the NHL stuff to your 360's harddrive.
(I basically did the above for all my games, had like maybe 200mb of save data to move over)
Edit: Just saw your post where you said you used a thumb drive, so you already know how to do everything :lol If your NHL saves are still on your thumb drive make sure you load from that when you fire up NHL, if you select harddrive it will ignore anything on your thumb drive
