Yeah I know the compression on the DC ones is shit, but I couldn't find better ones from that angle.
Nice comparison. This thread is sorely needing these.
Thanks.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Next-gen Racing Graphics Face-off | (Next-gen means current-gen)
- Thread starter Gestault
- Start date
Nice comparison. This thread is sorely needing these.
Thanks.
Got'cha!
Tripolygon
Banned
That thread already exists, its the console screenshots thread. This thread is specifically to channel all bickering away from game OTs and other game related thread. Lets face it, there is always going to be bickering, it happens in every Digital Foundry Faceoffs and less so in game OTs.
eh what? make FH2 closed circuit aka corridor racer and implement all the dynamic weather stuff that driveclub simulates
wel turn 10 should do a better job because they have already learned the system as opposed to PD that will only have GT7 as there first ps4 title regadless of dev time. turn 10 would have had F5, horizon 2 and forza 6 to learn the ins and outs of the xbox one.
devs can do wonders inbetween game development cycle (NDs drakes fortune to U2)
and then you have people waiting for need for speed in hopes it will dethrone DC as the next graphic powerhouse, does that game have interior view? or is it all chase cam? i wish rockstar will bring back the midnight club series on current gen platforms
Yeah I know the compression on the DC ones is shit, but I couldn't find better ones from that angle.
Awesome comparison dude. And yea, I think Driveclub might have GT6's models and shaders beat. At least in this comparison anyway. The headlamps in particular stand out.
AgentChris
Member
DriveClub looks like real life and Forza 6 looks like a video game.
Better job of what actually?
making there games look good??? (Next Gen Racing Graphics)....
edit:
now thats how you do a comparison, same angle, same colors, same cars, same time of day
Stillmatic
Member
My favorite DC gameplay pics since the png update: http://imgur.com/a/r9hq0#0
Never linked an imgur album, so hopefully this works.
Some old jpgs:
http://imgur.com/a/5QdZ8
Never linked an imgur album, so hopefully this works.
Some old jpgs:
http://imgur.com/a/5QdZ8
Yeah, the headlights and shadowy parts of the car (front grills) definitely stand out.
Still, the models themselves are pretty even.
Thanks, I don't have DC so I got the (heavily compressed) pictures from this site that seems to have all the cars from the same angle and in the same lighting (which makes things a lot easier)
I'm trying to do more and maybe I'll add Project Cars in there as well. But I think there are only 4 cars that exist across all the three games.
Inf3cted_b3ast
Member
The guy who owns those pictures is a YTber. I immediately recognized those DC pics because he always uses them as his thumnail. Great comparison!
Tripolygon
Banned
Dull afternoon screenshots of DC
.
Tripolygon
Banned
Environmental Photomode shots, cannot play DC without taking some environmental shots.
Baroquemantic
Member
I love the city shots in Horizon 2. They look so good. I really hope Driveclub gets some city tracks.
Some great shots among them. Textures look so much crisper and more detailed in PNG.
As long as you're not expecting a sim racer. It's simcade, so closer to GRID, PGR etc.
But to answer your question, just read through the answers in this thread.
Driveclub - Is it really good now?
As a side note, the Full game + Season Pass bundle is only $20 in the US on PSN, and £16 in the UK, which is outrageously good value. I have 300+ hours in to it, and I'm still not close to being done. Played it almost every day since launch, with only a few block breaks in-between. There's just a tonne of content, more so if you're active in the community challenges, and like to compete with friends on leader boards.
Omg, fucking gifs are ridiculously hard to make for some goddamned reason. Fuck GIMP, fuck Handbrake, fuck Imgur, I'll link to Xbox DVR.
I gave this noob another chance to correct his mistake but his nooby-ness was too strong:
http://xboxdvr.com/gamer/XXVII%20BCE/video/10208478
I gave this noob another chance to correct his mistake but his nooby-ness was too strong:
http://xboxdvr.com/gamer/XXVII%20BCE/video/10208478
Cool, I like your way of thinking, and I always wanted an excuse to repost some of my personal favorites (all from photomode).
OccamsLightsaber
Regularly boosts GAF member count to cry about 'right wing gaf' - Voter #3923781
All this talk of the Forza gif not matching the real game, yet no one is posting a .webm as a counter argument.
Lol that was amazing. That drivatar (?) really is a n00b.
Tripolygon
Banned
Tripolygon
Banned
Yessss, PNG cannot come soon enough.
while looking up an old DC gif, I came across this screenshot someone took...
not sure if there were any enhancements.
from here
http://punkandlizard.com/the-beauty-of-driveclub/
when all the special effects come together.....just wow.
not sure if there were any enhancements.
from here
http://punkandlizard.com/the-beauty-of-driveclub/
when all the special effects come together.....just wow.
Ploid 3.0
Member
You did good. Looks very clean and lined up perfectly. Edit: Seems like the sun is going down from top to bottom heh. First one is noonish.
Mothernature is a graphics/effects nut.
Inf3cted_b3ast
Member
A few of my shots I took recently
Gameplay
Gameplay
farmerboy
Member
I'm actually expecting something special from Polyphony.
They've got the talent and resources. And the time.
AgentP
Thinks mods influence posters politics. Promoted to QAnon Editor.
Since when does IQ == amount of AA? Is some Gaf invention? Image quality means different things to different groups. I hate ambiguous acronyms.
You have some sort of satisfaction? Gifs are motional, in-game screenshots aren't. Right? Also, you ignore what i said to you a few pages back. If you think ( of course you do ) that F6 is misrepresented in that gif, SAME APPLIES to DC. Both are equally compressed in that gif. Good? Good. And guess, what, difference between them is the same in that youtube video. Btw. you can also find some "juicy" DF's F6 shots too.
TBiddy
Member
Indeed. If any game was to force me to get a PS4 next to my XB1, it would be GT7. But for now, I'm enjoying my time with Forza, even though I'm (apparantly) subjected to jaggies, poor trees, hovercars and bad lighting.
The problem is that people distant to tech entered this thread, bringing fanboy arguments and behaviour into it and tried to negate a good discussion the thread once was made for.
flipswitch
Member
Just remember that DC uses physically based rendering with correct material types while GT6 doesn't. Shows how good PD artists are.
IQ = AA and AF. It's not ambiguous.
Just so you know, FH2 uses 4x MSAA, fancier and slower than FXAA that most games uses.
TheAdmiester
Member
Probably Euro spec and U.S. spec.
icecold1983
Member
msaa is neither of those.
Right, right. I wrote it too fast. Fixed.
drotahorror
Member
Hah, nice one.
TBiddy
Member
Is he floating on the ground? Looks like he has no weight. Can we get a full direct feed video of that? It's clear that the sprites are of high quality, but the lightning is dull. Obviously baked lightning. Need a side-to-side comparison with FM. Preferrably in a 10 FPS GIF if you can.
I've been thinking about the "cookie cutter" affect that seems to manifest itself in FM6 when viewed from the 3rd person cam.
Although the video below is sound comparison (a whole other hornets nest), I think the "cookie cutter" or superimposed affect on FM6 is quite apparent, it appears, at least to me, that this is caused by the lighting engine giving a different amount of luminosity to the car, than it does to the rest of the scene which makes the car pop out of the scene.
Whether this is by design or not (I always maintain that FM has gone for a more stylized look to it's IQ, rather than a wholly realistic look), I'm not sure.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_EJiHEsh7PM
Although the video below is sound comparison (a whole other hornets nest), I think the "cookie cutter" or superimposed affect on FM6 is quite apparent, it appears, at least to me, that this is caused by the lighting engine giving a different amount of luminosity to the car, than it does to the rest of the scene which makes the car pop out of the scene.
Whether this is by design or not (I always maintain that FM has gone for a more stylized look to it's IQ, rather than a wholly realistic look), I'm not sure.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_EJiHEsh7PM
Please, list out the other games which have this feature.
When you've got 24 cars on the track, it's still an absolute night mare with those puddles. Talk about downplaying. Considering the only other console sim, which is rubbish compared to FM6, just has your standard -20% grip and can't barely keep 60.
I'll iterate, new never-seen before feature = innovation.
I have to see it in motion, the jpg makes it look worse than it is.
ps: I forgot how much I hate Project Cars photomode controls, dear god.
Quoting so that people without a 4k display can compare better without putting the image urls on separate tabs.
Tripolygon
Banned
Hahaha, thank you for this. Awesome man
Similar threads
- Poll