He's not even the worst example. How do you get a varied moveset out of Little Mac? What would make Shulk different from the other swordsmen beyond a few specials? They sound like a good idea, but they need some creativity to make them work. It's not impossible. But a bad character for fanservice's sake isn't a good trade unless they're easy to make.
I think Lil Mac's moveset would be pretty easy to make. Just give him to someone over at Namco and let them work they're magic if all else fails. He could have uppercuts, jab combos with mutiple branches, counter strikes. Shulk I'm not familiar with so idk about him.
I don't think its a burn out. The pre-Brawl period was just as long as the Smash 4 one is, but I have noticed a lot less hype than what I saw prior to Brawl's announcement. Its simply a result of nearly all the big names already being in at this point.
I expect the first four newcomers we will get will be Ridley, Palutena, Takamaru, and Mega Man (or a Namco character in place of Mega Man).
Also, in regards to the Ridley size stuff:
http://img831.imageshack.us/img831/9456/ssbmsamusvsridley.gif
I guess you do have a point now that I'm looking at it from that angle. In a way, this could result in a few more surprises. That's always a plus.
Yep, and it has been discussed to death but a Smash version of Ridley could definitely work.
I am still hyping in my pants for new character additions. There is no one really left besides some curve balls and I am ready to strikeout. If there is no Punch Out!! representative this time I will be surprised, it's just a shame that it will most likely be Little Mac.
New characters is the one of the only reason to get hyped imo. What? Lil Mac would be fine.