to Marvie & all others interested, here is the Faceoff Guide I posted awhile back:
http://www.operationsports.com/strategyguides/921/nhl-11-faceoff-guide/
I've studied it and applied it's principles and think I have the system totally figured out, here are some important points:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
BASICS
FORMATIONS
-Before the beginning of each faceoff anyone on the team can call for a specific faceoff formation by holding the LEFT STICK (UP for Aggressive, DOWN for Defensive, or RIGHT for Normal). As a center I generally am holding the direction I want to entire time during the stoppage before the faceoff, whoever inputs last gets their way.
1) In the Defensive Zone I like to use the Aggressive formation so 3 players are on the inside to defend against the deke between the legs, a shot off of a tie-up or a quick shot from the point.
2) In the Offensive Zone I like to use the Defensive formation so the defensemen as back as far as possible to prevent a counter-rush.
HOW TO WIN
-Each kind of faceoff win has a counter. There are generally 3 good ways to win (forehand scoop, backhand, deke between the legs)
-Winning depends on 4 things:
1)TIMING
2)Your Player's FACEOFF RATING
3)How Long You HOLD Your Backhand/Forehand
4)METHOD.
FLICKING TECHNIQUES
-I've found a method of flicking the stick that seems to have improved my timing, instead of just flicking the right stick UP or DOWN to win a faceoff, I instead flick it the same direction twice quickly then hold it that direction. So instead of flicking DOWN, I instead flick it DOWN, DOWN and hold DOWN. I do this because there are times where it seems the game doesn't recognize my input when I flick it once.
-Also if you didn't know you can also affect the direction of your win by holding diagonally down and right or left on any faceoff which is very important in the offensive zone for picking which defensemen you want to win the puck back to.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TIMING
Timing is different is each zone (offensive, center ice, and defensive zones).
1) In the offensive zone the timing is to start your flicking as the puck is dropping, I refer to this timing as in-between. As it's after the ref first moves his arm and before the puck hits the ground.
2) In the defensive zone you are going off first movement of the refs arm. Early bird wins, and it's really important that you are early because you can all but eliminate the threat of the deke between the legs.
3) At center ice you need to wait for the puck to hit the ice, so this is the latest timing of the 3.
Last note about timing, you sometimes have to take into account lag. If your guy is moving sluggishly during the game and these timings aren't working you need to speed them all up a notch except defensive zone where it won't matter. So center ice you flick as the puck is falling and offensive zone you flick when the ref starts to move his arm to drop the puck.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HOLDING YOUR BACKHAND/FOREHAND
As soon as possible you need to "declare" which handedness you are going to attempt to take the faceoff with by holding the RS out to the left or right to pick forehand or backhand. If both players have the similar faceoff ratings and try the same move the one who was ready for the longest will gain the advantage and win the faceoff.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
METHODS
FOREHAND SCOOP
The hands down best method of winning a faceoff against a human opponent is what I call the FOREHAND SCOOP. To do this hold the RS out towards your forehand side and flick DOWN on the Right Stick to turn your body while winning the faceoff. Only downside is you can't win this back towards your defenseman on the forehand side. For whatever reason it doesn't work as well against a CPU opponent.
The most important thing I've found is that this FOREHAND SCOOP is the counter for the DEKE IN BETWEEN THE LEGS. If you do the scoop early enough against the deke you will win every single time. **All of you forwards who are taking defensive zone faceoffs while the center is in the penalty box need to remember this**
There is a counter to the FOREHAND SCOOP, the STICK LIFT. If you are getting dominated by this scoop move even if you have a crappy faceoff rating you can beat the other player if you time the STICK LIFT properly. To do the STICK LIFT hold your stick out to either forehand or backhand then roll it around towards UP in like a (Street Fighter Fireball motion). The only downside is that you will win the puck back really slow. For this reason I never use it in the offensive zone because the other team can pretty much rush up the ice and intercept the puck before it gets back to your d-man.
More notes on the STICK LIFT. Holding to the forehand or backhand will get you 2 different results. Your player will kick the puck towards your backhand side on the backhand and draw the puck back to the forehand side on the forehand. If you absolutely want to use this move in the offensive zone you need to call for the AGGRESSIVE faceoff formation beforehand (UP on the LS) where the other winger is stacked right behind the center.
BACKHAND
This is the best way to win a faceoff against a CPU player, it is also good in the offensive zone for aiming the puck back to the defensemen on your backhand side. You should only use it for these reasons because...
The DEKE BETWEEN THE LEGS is pretty much guaranteed to work against this method, so NEVER, EVER, EVER try to win a faceoff backhand in the defensive zone against a human player. Also you are much more susceptible to get TIED UP while attempting a backhand win.
As I mentioned above the counter to the BACKHAND win is the TIE UP. So if you notice a human player is winning a lot of faceoffs from his backhand, you need to start using this counter. The TIE UP is considered a counter so it doesn't matter what your faceoff rating is, as long as you time it correctly against a backhand attempt you will tie up everytime. Like the STICK LIFT the TIE UP can be done out of either forehand or backhand grip. I've found the backhand grip seems to work better. To TIE-UP flick the Left Stick UP.
You can also seal off to specific directions on the TIE-UP. If you want your winger to the right of you to take the faceoff, instead of just flicking UP, flick diagonally UP & RIGHT to seal that direction and give that winger a better path to the puck.
Final note on the TIE UP, as some of you have seen by playing with me this can be very useful in the offensive zone to setup scoring chances. That's where I use it the most.
DEKE BETWEEN THE LEGS
We all know what this is. To do it, hold LB than flick the RS UP to deke between the legs of your opponent. It only works against backhand and neutral hand faceoff wins. It will also beat a TIE-UP and STICK LIFT most of the time. This doesn't take into account your faceoff rating either so it's all timing and taking advantage of your opponent if he doesn't know it's coming and/or how to stop it.