I'm a Be a GM mode player and I'm really unimpressed by NHL 11. There are some major glaring issues that need to be taken a look at if I'm going to invest in NHL 12, but the chances of that are slim since HUT seems to be the big money maker....
-Top prospects show up in free agency consistently. Seriously, why? I should not be able to start up my Bruins franchise and sign an 18 year old Cam Fowler because the Ducks roster was full
-Greater transparency when it comes to CHL integration. The game does a piss poor job of explaining why teenage CHL players "disappear" from your team once the season starts (Yes I do know why myself, but the casual hockey fan would be clueless where their top draft pick went)
-I should be able to sort players by not only their overall potential, but also by their OFF/DEF/ATH potential. A guy with B- over potential, but A- in OFF/ATH and a C in DEF will probably turn out pretty good, but a guy with B- overall potential with a B- in DEF/ATH/OFF is less likely to be a success.
-Contract demands are completely illogical. I recently had Adam Larsson, an 81 overall player, demand a 6 million dollar/year contract from me, while Sidney Crosby was happy to sign for 4.5 million/year
-Players improvement in their attributes shouldn't grow all at once immediately after the season ends. This creates the same issues in NHL 10, where you have a player go from an 80 overall to an 85 overall rating in an offseason, so he's demanding big bucks despite the fact he had yet to play with that ability yet. It's like giving a draft pick huge amounts of money on his potential
-Trading is convoluted and dumb. Teams are super picky about what they're looking for, and their wants never make sense. In all my dynasties, the Devils immediately have goalie problems after the first year when Brodeur retires. Logically, in their trading block they always say they really want goal tending. However, whenever I try to trade with them, they always either have a full roster or tell me they have enough goalies. Seriously what the shit EA. If the team's roster is full on goalies they shouldn't be claiming to be desperately seeking one.
Also, trading for top draft picks and top prospects is way too easy. You can pick up some really early draft picks at the trade deadline by just offering the worst team in the league your 1st and 4th rounder.
-I want to see more franchise type players appear from the draft. I've run sims on 3 dynasties going about 6 years in the future, and the scoring leaderboards in 2015 look earily similar to 2009, aside from the addition to Seguin and Hall.
I know most of you focus on online or HUT, but I'm really disappointed this year. They tacked on a few cool things, but they didn't fix the major issues in the mode. And at this point it seems like they never will.