I hate the PlayStation controller and don't care for many of PS's exclusives aside from what Naughty Dog makes. But with that said, I'm not really happy with what MS is doing, I'll just wait it out and see what the final product does with all of this backlash. However, I am not buying it day one, will probably wait a while to see if any of this mess is fixed. If not, I guess I'll just play my giant back log of Xbox360 games on my 360. I have a strong enough PC to play most games on ultra settings but for some reason I don't like playing on my PC. I do hate Keyboard and mouse though, thank you plug and play 360 controller for those PC games that support it.
But with that said, yeah I'm in a wait and see approach, so far they have me turned off but not where I will buy a PS4 or god forbid a WiiU, I'm not that desperate yet. Also Halo 1-3 disagree with your comments, Reach and 4 agree with them.