i never fell into the collective that thought the ai/kleiza for barry/howard trade was ridiculous, but bell for rj is robbery any way you look at it.
if you look at it without ratings and names, as you suggest, it makes absolutely no sense for the bucks. they lose size, they lose their most dominant offensive presence, 1/2 their roster now consists of guards, and bell adds absolutely nothing to their overall game. sure bell adds some great defense to the team, but what does it matter when he's the only defensive player on the team? the bucks are going to lock down an entire team with bell?
if you look @ the trade from a ratings perspective, it's not even close. rj is capable of dominating in this game, bell is not. ratings are everything in a game that basses shot success off of individual categorical ratings--i.e; mid range shot, 3pt shot, close, dunk, shoot in traffic, etc. on this topic too, bell's 3 is only 2 points higher... that's a pretty negligible difference
also, don't take this the wrong way, this has nothing to do with you. if anyone else did this trade they would get the exact same lol's and ridicule because either way you cut it this trade is insanely one sided--looking @ ratings or not, but also the fact that he could have shopped rj and gotten much more.
with all that said, like i said earlier, grats on the trade. you never cease to amaze me with the deals you're able to secure. if you can pull this kind of trade off, it just goes to show that anyone can. the rest of us just need to step our game up.