i don't know what it is, but ive have hit the wrong button in madden 17 more than i can ever remember. i dont know what to blame. i didn't have this problem since we moved over to ps4...
I've hit wrong buttons, but mostly it's the game not recognizing button presses, leading to pressing it multiple times, until it finally goes "oh, you want to throw the ball? Here, let me put it in the flat now that the CB has come down into the zone and now he's running the other way with the ball touchdown."