• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

One Piece Manga |OT3| Anything You Can Gum I Can Gum Better

Something interesting to note with Jinbei.

He was a former Shichibukai who fought Firefist Ace to a draw so we know he is very strong. Does this mean he knocks Sanji out of the monster Trio?

Also...if he was as powerful as Ace was during the Execution arc, does that mean that Luffy, Zoro and Sanji are more powerful than Jinbei and therefore more powerful than Ace who was one of Whitebeard's commanders?

Or are Zoro/Jinbei/Sanji all roughly the same strength give or take a little here and there?
Id say he knocks sanji out yes. Roughly the same strength ehhh nah he can put up a major fight but they both beat sanji
 

Geg

Member
Something interesting to note with Jinbei.

He was a former Shichibukai who fought Firefist Ace to a draw so we know he is very strong. Does this mean he knocks Sanji out of the monster Trio?

Also...if he was as powerful as Ace was during the Execution arc, does that mean that Luffy, Zoro and Sanji are more powerful than Jinbei and therefore more powerful than Ace who was one of Whitebeard's commanders?

Or are Zoro/Jinbei/Sanji all roughly the same strength give or take a little here and there?

For all we know Ace could have surpassed Jinbe by the time the Marineford arc came around. At the time they fought to a draw wasn't that before Ace even joined up with Whitebeard?
 
Id say he knocks sanji out yes. Roughly the same strength ehhh nah he can put up a major fight but they both beat sanji

That's what I was thinking but doesn't that kind of mess with Zoro/Sanji rivalry?

Unless of course after the timeskip Sanji and Zoro have both maybe surpassed Jimbei? Hard to say as we haven't really seen Zoro/Sanji go all out since the timeskip. They have to have something hidden up their sleeves.
 
That's what I was thinking but doesn't that kind of mess with Zoro/Sanji rivalry?

Unless of course after the timeskip Sanji and Zoro have both maybe surpassed Jimbei? Hard to say as we haven't really seen Zoro/Sanji go all out since the timeskip. They have to have something hidden up their sleeves.
The rivalry will always be there not like zoro is walking away unharmed but no I don’t think sanji can win when it’s all over even if it’s a last attack type thing for both of them zoro is getting back up first at the very least. As for the timeskip o they’re both hiding some shit for sure and definitely gonna grow even more
 

Man God

Non-Canon Member
FFS, I know she is saying 'weeeeedddiiiinnnnggg cake' but the panel with her just yelling WEEEEEED and the face on that wave. I am now broken

Not a user myself but I made a few fellow OP fans laugh their asses off by saying WEEEEEEEEEED in a passable impersonation of Big Mam.
 
The rivalry will always be there not like zoro is walking away unharmed but no I don’t think sanji can win when it’s all over even if it’s a last attack type thing for both of them zoro is getting back up first at the very least. As for the timeskip o they’re both hiding some shit for sure and definitely gonna grow even more

Ah well I mean of course Zoro has always been stronger than Sanji and I suppose always essentially able to rival Luffy or possibly just slightly below him. I was more figuring that Oda always seemed to have that 1st, 2nd, 3rd thing with them in terms or power levels, who they fight on the enemy team etc..

But yeah looking forward to seeing them go all out and show off what they learned. Especially looking forward to seeing more Zoro as I feel he hasn't done much post time skip.
 

Red Fire

Member
That's what I was thinking but doesn't that kind of mess with Zoro/Sanji rivalry?

Unless of course after the timeskip Sanji and Zoro have both maybe surpassed Jimbei? Hard to say as we haven't really seen Zoro/Sanji go all out since the timeskip. They have to have something hidden up their sleeves.

Why are you assuming jimbei didn't get stronger during the timeskip?

Oda has always portrayed jimbei to be roughly equal to luffy. Even though those were not serious fights, i think that was the intended message behind the mini fights after marine ford and on fishman island
 
Ah well I mean of course Zoro has always been stronger than Sanji and I suppose always essentially able to rival Luffy or possibly just slightly below him. I was more figuring that Oda always seemed to have that 1st, 2nd, 3rd thing with them in terms or power levels, who they fight on the enemy team etc..

But yeah looking forward to seeing them go all out and show off what they learned. Especially looking forward to seeing more Zoro as I feel he hasn't done much post time skip.
Who knows maybe luffy will be his own tier and the 1st 2nd 3rd will be Zoro jinbe sanji. Or maybe sanji becomes second who knows.

Zoro is in this weird spot where he’s been seen in less of a struggle than the actual captain it’s a bit annoying to me
 

daveo42

Banned
Welcome to the Green Room.
ylJNs7O.png
 

Man God

Non-Canon Member
Who knows maybe luffy will be his own tier and the 1st 2nd 3rd will be Zoro jinbe sanji. Or maybe sanji becomes second who knows.

Zoro is in this weird spot where he’s been seen in less of a struggle than the actual captain it’s a bit annoying to me

Zoro can't cut string. My boy Sanji took on Doffy head to head.
 

Anteater

Member
if luffy beat katakuri there'll be only smoothie left, are we really expecting a big mom round 2 fight? Unless Big Mom get new commanders I can't see another arc fighting the same people.
 
if luffy beat katakuri there'll be only smoothie left, are we really expecting a big mom round 2 fight? Unless Big Mom get new commanders I can't see another arc fighting the same people.
She can promote pero,daifuku and oven or compote. Luffy can focus on big mom next round the strawhats take on the others

Zoro can't cut string. My boy Sanji took on Doffy head to head.
Well pplstill think zoro could have best doffy so 🤷🏽*♂️
 

caliph95

Member
Would Big Mom kill her strongest fighter for losing a fight

She goes to war if someone beats one of them and she cares about gaining power tantrums notwithstanding
 
Or are Zoro/Jinbei/Sanji all roughly the same strength give or take a little here and there?

Jinbei is stronger than Sanji. Had Sanji spent the timeskip specifically training the whole time to improve his strength like Luffy and Zoro did, he might have kept up, but he didn't
He didn't have a specialised teacher and spent at least some of the time on his cooking skills instead.

Zoro can't cut string. My boy Sanji took on Doffy head to head.

Neither could an admiral.
 
Jinbei is stronger than Sanji. Had Sanji spent the timeskip specifically training the whole time to improve his strength like Luffy and Zoro did, he might have kept up, but he didn't
He didn't have a specialised teacher and spent at least some of the time on his cooking skills instead.
Well at least someone pays attention to the story, you mind telling the fanbase this
 

Tathanen

Get Inside Her!
Ohhhhh wait right now while typing this it dawned on me, i think he didn't want nami and co to hear that he gets beaten so he held his mouth to make no AHHH UHHH sounds

Aha there it is, I've been trying to figure that whole scene out. Coulda made that a little clearer Oda.
 

Kreed

Member
I thought it was implied by him being a fishman and master of fishman karate, and how fishman karate seems to be basically applied fluid dynamics to read and manipulate the air/water currents.

"This guy is all about maneuverability."

They've definitely been hinting at skills Jinbei could bring to the crew for a while particularly from a fighting perspective and from a crew "filled with anchors" perspective. But it really didn't distinguish Jinbei from someone like say Law or any of the "X for Nakama" fodder outside of Luffy specifically giving Jinbei a crew invite. This is the first time I've seen an example as to why the Straw Hats as a crew need a Helmsman in the story and what potential it could bring (escaping dangers, sailing places they normally couldn't, etc...).
 
Dammit, why do we have a break week after this epic chapter?

Jinbei was really awesome this week. Luffy is still getting demolished. I really don't know how he can stand up to Katakuri right now.
 
Well at least someone pays attention to the story, you mind telling the fanbase this

Ah no, I'm not some Sanji stan by any means. Based on what we know of the story so far since the time skip and in general: Zoro is the strongest non-Luffy straw hat. That gap between Zoro and Sanji has only grown over time.

Of course it makes sense given that Sanji is primarily a cook and a Fighter second where as Zoro is a pure bred fighter who only cares about getting stronger. Was enevitable.

And judging by what we know so far I would say everything indicates that Jimbei is definitely stronger than Sanji too by presumably a solid margin. I guess what I'm saying is that Jimbei is kind of an unknown for exactly how powerful he is, does he top Zoro? Maybe we will have to wait and see.

Also as I think we can all agree both Sanji and Zoro are hiding something/haven't really gone all out yet. Like some people have surmised Sanji could be hiding Okama kempo but be ashamed to use it and Zoro could have some kind of "limit release" where he could open that eye. (Could Luffy still be hiding some tricks? He seemed to go mostly all out on Doffy so it looks like his next stage will be Awakening of his DF that was teased in Dressrossa)

As a side note it would be interesting (although probably unlikely) if the next time we saw Mihawk if he too was missing an eye/had a scar on one. It could indicate that Zoro advanced to such a level that he was able to injure Mihawk while training (let's say pushing himself to his max while Mihawk underestimated him or something). Although to be honest it's very unlikely I just like throwing shit out there as a bunch of "what if's?" so don't take this as a serious theory or "fanboy wet dream" or whatever. I can already sense the backlash comments :(
 
Ah no, I'm not some Sanji stan by any means. Based on what we know of the story so far since the time skip and in general: Zoro is the strongest non-Luffy straw hat. That gap between Zoro and Sanji has only grown over time.

Of course it makes sense given that Sanji is primarily a cook and a Fighter second where as Zoro is a pure bred fighter who only cares about getting stronger. Was enevitable.

And judging by what we know so far I would say everything indicates that Jimbei is definitely stronger than Sanji too by presumably a solid margin. I guess what I'm saying is that Jimbei is kind of an unknown for exactly how powerful he is, does he top Zoro? Maybe we will have to wait and see.

Also as I think we can all agree both Sanji and Zoro are hiding something/haven't really gone all out yet. Like some people have surmised Sanji could be hiding Okama kempo but be ashamed to use it and Zoro could have some kind of "limit release" where he could open that eye. (Could Luffy still be hiding some tricks? He seemed to go mostly all out on Doffy so it looks like his next stage will be Awakening of his DF that was teased in Dressrossa)

As a side note it would be interesting (although probably unlikely) if the next time we saw Mihawk if he too was missing an eye/had a scar on one. It could indicate that Zoro advanced to such a level that he was able to injure Mihawk while training (let's say pushing himself to his max while Mihawk underestimated him or something). Although to be honest it's very unlikely I just like throwing shit out there as a bunch of "what if's?" so don't take this as a serious theory or "fanboy wet dream" or whatever. I can already sense the backlash comments :(
Lol not tou
 
We saw Mihawk and Perona on the cover of 826. He's fine.

Oh yeah I forgot about that. Well there ya go, I'm generally just throwing shit at the wall to see what sticks.

It will be interesting to see what happens with the Katakuri fight. Will Luffy surprise him somehow and manage to injure him enough to escape?

It would seem weird if he beat Big Mom's strongest fighter before "really" taking them on.

But it would make sense if he injures him and manages to escape back to the Sunny. That leaves a wall for Luffy to overcome and a kind of grudge for the next time they fight?

Or maybe Luffy will just do some crazy shit and beat him.
 
Big Mom is completely self-centered. She doesn't care about the care of her family. I could see her killing one of her children who fails her, no matter how powerful they are. That being said, I don't see Katakuri getting beat this arc.

With the crew safe, I think Luffy will use Gear 4 to escape rather than simply win the fight. This whole arc has been about how out of league the Strawhats are. I don't see Oda giving Luffy a win against the no.2 of Big Mom's crew at this point in time.

One thing I really liked about this chapter was them showing off Jinbe's helmsman skills which will no doubt be useful the deeper into the New World they go( along with Carrot's lookout skills as well).
 

Ray Down

Banned
Nah he ain't escaping without beating Kata it will be a tough fight.

And now Magi is over...just sort of ended.

What's your guys biggest fear of One Piece ending?
 
My man Jimbe. Can do no wrong, honestly.

Luffy gonna have to do something to deal with this ass whupping. I think he is going to have to escape.

Nah he ain't escaping without beating Kata it will be a tough fight.

And now Magi is over...just sort of ended.

What's your guys biggest fear of One Piece ending?
Oh snap, time to get back into it.
 
Nah he ain't escaping without beating Kata it will be a tough fight.

And now Magi is over...just sort of ended.

What's your guys biggest fear of One Piece ending?

Honestly it's too early for me to even say what the ending could be (the One Piece is literally impossible to predict), and any "bad ending" I can think of seems too out of left field for the series.

Well the raw for Magi final chapter is just out.

Also saw this on Oro found it funny:

S9rn6US.png

lol
 
So now that jinbei is pretty confirmed to be next nakama,
where you at carrot fanshits?!

You thought the busty little rabbit would be nakama but it was the T H I C C fish bro all along!!
 
Well at least someone pays attention to the story, you mind telling the fanbase this

I think the bigger problem is there isn't really a good bar for some of the non-fighting skills in one piece.

Yes, we got told Chopper is a much better doctor (but hasn't done anything new of note other than his rumble balls improvement), nami is apparently better as a navigator, but we can't really tell other than the manga saying she is. The same goes for Sanji, he was supposed to become a better cook, but we don't really have any evidence that he is other than the manga saying so, please believe us. Like, maybe he only developed the ability to tell ingredients from the smell of the finished cake during the break, but we don't actually have any way to know that.
 

Principate

Saint Titanfall
So now that jinbei is pretty confirmed to be next nakama,
where you at carrot fanshits?!

You thought the busty little rabbit would be nakama but it was the T H I C C fish bro all along!!

Who said there would only be 1? Luffy worry's more about Carrot than he does about Chopper for a whole two arcs.
 

Ray Down

Banned
With OP I see us spending a lot of time on an epilogue.

My biggest fear is reading the final chapter and being like...well that was a chapter.

Like I didn't care for Naruto towards the end but I like the final chapter.

Less said about Bleach the better.
 

Red Fire

Member
So now that jinbei is pretty confirmed to be next nakama,
where you at carrot fanshits?!

You thought the busty little rabbit would be nakama but it was the T H I C C fish bro all along!!

Huh? Everyone already knew jimbei was gonna be the next strawhat except for those few who thought he would die. Everyone rooting for carrot said she would be the next one after jimbei.

Ain't nothing over yet #teamcarrot
 

Principate

Saint Titanfall
With OP I see us spending a lot of time on an epilogue.

My biggest fear is reading the final chapter and being like...well that was a chapter.

Like I didn't care for Naruto towards the end but I like the final chapter.

Less said about Bleach the better.

Clearly Luffy will die in the final few chapters as a final screw you to ensure there isn't a sequel (I'm not going to say two piece because while the name will be dumb jump seems to prefer esoteric dumb). So that tis franchise will not drag out for another 20 years.

Huh? Everyone already knew jimbei was gonna be the next strawhat except for those few who thought he would die. Everyone rooting for carrot said she would be the next one after jimbei.

Ain't nothing over yet #teamcarrot

There's 11 members of BB crew (twelve if you count Stronger). Add in carrot and you can have match ups for everyone.
 
It sort of feels like Oda is positioning this side of the crew to have some sort of power-up/growth, but it's hard to tell whether Luffy's competence is something new or just the serious side of him that crops up now and then.

Deliberately lying to his crew, even if it's to keep their heads on straight, feels like something new for him.
 
Top Bottom