buddha0991
Member
Both Tatsuya and Makoto have reasons to be depressed yo
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Persona Community Thread |OT4| The Golden Number
- Thread starter Dantis
- Start date
He just secretly has his middle fingers up constantly. Dat sociopath.
Green Mamba
Member
Whenever I accidentally let him run around like that I have to stop momentarily to make him get his hands out of his pockets, because it really bothers me for some reason.
buddha0991
Member
everyone in this pic is a poop
cj_iwakura
Member
I used to mimic the posture.
AquaWateria
Member
I'm not saying Persona 4 didn't have a great atmosphere because it did and I liked it, but for me compared to Persona 3 it wasn't as effective.
So yeah I get what your saying.
buddha0991
Member
Tatsuya is just a moper in IS, hes a true brooder in EP.
SloaneRisette
Member
How much Linkin Park does he listen to?
buddha0991
Member
He doesn't. Instead, he listens to pop music, ironically.
Also he stole Yukiko's gag glasses and wears them ironically too.
cj_iwakura
Member
Not as much as Yosuke.
AquaWateria
Member
I could see that but understand that
Ryoji is death itself which correlates to the theme of Persona 3 and makes even more sense when you see Agis attachment to Makoto, which connects to his backstory.
Wow i'm the complete opposite, I really like that walking / running animation
buddha0991
Member
^I don't like it, but it really does give him extra character so its all good.
Yea, Yosuke canonically listens to Linkin Park and Nickleback
Yea, Yosuke canonically listens to Linkin Park and Nickleback
SloaneRisette
Member
^I don't like it, but it really does give him extra character so its all good.
Yea, Yosuke canonically listens to Linkin Park and Nickleback
Yosuke's room shows how much of a goober he is.
Oh yeah, I mean a character of Ryoji's stature is just fine. Having to kill him or not to decide the future is pretty huge given the circumstances. The problem is that it connects you, Aigis, and Ryoji. It became jarring when the protagonist already had an insane supernatural backstory instead of you, the player, discovering it. It defeated the purpose of a blank-slate protagonist. Not to mention I didn't like Aigis hovering over me because of this sudden backstory. I felt totally out of control as the player.
That's what I mean by the execution being flawed. I have no problem with memento mori and to me it's as relatable as Persona 4's themes, but it could have gone about it better in my opinion.
Brosuke. Minutes to Midnight is underrated.
AquaWateria
Member
You know something funny Tatsuya and Makoto have had a shitty live compared to Yu who's way happier than freakin hello kitty
AquaWateria
Member
I understand, I can see where your coming from
LOL
Don't let iwakura's hilariously defensive post prevent you from taking Tatsuya seriously. He has a reason for acting super angsty, but it won't be apparent for a while.
Yeah, Charlie had it good. Moves to countryside, gets a sick power, bangs an idol. Dude is #blessed.
Different strokes for different folks, I completely understand.
buddha0991
Member
If only more people could be more understanding of that kind of thing instead of mocking it.
It's hard to argue this point. I mean, Yu didn't have a voice inside his pants constantly reminding him he couldn't fuck anyone, so it's pretty clear he wouldn't be as miserable.
I'm still trying to figure out how Yosuke had a book in his room that taught Teddie the word "glomp."
hipsterpants
Member
Girls who want Yu: A hot nurse and an idol.
Girls who want Makoto: A robot and an emotionally damaged 16-year-old.
Pretty clear who wins here.
Girls who want Makoto: A robot and an emotionally damaged 16-year-old.
Pretty clear who wins here.
cj_iwakura
Member
Tatsuya?
Fixed that for you.
buddha0991
Member
People who want Yu:
People who want Makoto:
People who want Makoto:
Emotionally damaged 16-year-old with DADDY ISSUES.
Don't leave out that all important part.
Emotional damage makes them vulnerable makes them easy.
Pretty sure this is Makoto's thought process in my version of the game.
hipsterpants
Member
P5 needs a girl like Yuko. No daddy issues/guy issues/persona users. Why can't there be any normal relationships in my persona games?
Green Mamba
Member
Drawing the next shadow and I love how pretty much every time I draw one of these I can safely say "Yep, that's a new one, never drawn that before." And occasionally "oh my god what am i drawing."
Neck jewel touching>>>>>>
I thought Yuko did have guy issues? She got body image issues anyway.
CrazyTank940
Member
lolPeople who want Yu:
People who want Makoto:
hipsterpants
Member
Well, the most normal anyway lol. Those are more one-off things though and not the focus of her S. link.
edit: ^ is her link any better than drama girl? When I play P4G I don't really want to experience that crap again.
Green Mamba
Member
Everyone's got issues. Otherwise the S.Links would be boring.
EDIT: I always felt kind of guilty for not finishing Yumi's S.Link because
EDIT: I always felt kind of guilty for not finishing Yumi's S.Link because
her dad never died. Poor guy will be living like that forever.
Uuugh, not really, imo. I'll take daddy issues over 'oh god I feel like a pedo just talking to this girl' any day. Ayane creeps me out man.
Lord Scrambles
Member
I actually really like Yumi, daddy-issues and all. It's one of those social links that make you feel like a turd bakery when you don't romance them though.
Yosuke: falls in love with a girl who hates him (he finds out after she dies)
Junpei:
falls in love with a girl that also dies, however that's because she sacrificed her life for him
Fat kid in P3 has no issues. He's just vile and repulsive and piggish, but he's personally fine with it, so no issues.
hipsterpants
Member
uh, you should probably spoil that
Oh boy
buddha0991
Member
SPOILERS AHOY MAN
Red The Hunter
Member
But character depth!
Poor Ayane, I liked her arc that she went through with her SLink.