I think too many people put the game on an untouchable pedestal, really. I don't think they were the best. I think it is the best
sequel in the franchise, because it brought about so many incredible new features that bested the original. But as far as the best overall game in the franchise, before HG/SS, I would have said it's Platinum.
Nobody would hate HM's if you could delete them whenever you wanted.
:l
Gen 1 had Pokemon like Jigglypuff, Jynx, Muk, Oddish, and Ditto, and you're complaining about the Gen that brought us beautiful Pokemon like Gardevoir, Absol, Blaziken, Swampert, Milotic, Salamence, Metagross, Zangoose, Kyogre and Groudon?