Reddit apologizes for "Online Witch Hunts" regarding Boston events

Status
Not open for further replies.
People like to give GAF flack but in the thread as it was unfolding and someone posted a twitter stating Sunil's name as suspect #2 the next 3 pages were of people saying "What's your source?!" Of course there were a few out there that started sluething on that.

I do admit if Sunil resurfaces from his "unstructured life" that he stated he wanted to take he's gonna pull a Simpsons Castro. "They think I did what?!"
 
The Sunil uncle thing HAD to be a fucking troll. Everyone else should be ashamed too.
Men looked nothing alike but ignoring that, some people were acting horrendous. They wanted the drama of the man disappearing and then returning seemingly from the shadows before disappearing again.
 
People like to give GAF flack but in the thread as it was unfolding and someone posted a twitter stating Sunil's name as suspect #2 the next 3 pages were of people saying "What's your source?!" Of course there were a few out there that started sluething on that.

I do admit if Sunil resurfaces from his "unstructured life" that he stated he wanted to take he's gonna pull a Simpsons Castro. "They think I did what?!"
Yeah. After we found the source quite a few of us called bullshit. It is what is is though.
 
So when is Evilore going to be issuing an apology?

Did some people try to give out personal information here? I honestly don't know, that thread moved insanely fast and I wasn't following all the time. I know in the past, that was a one way ticket to a permaban and your post being edited as well.

The last time I remember the mods being even a little bit lenient was for the JBaird fiasco.
 
Where that twitter guy get Sunil's name from anyways? He's the one that triggered the entire thing.

If anyone, he should be shamed the most.
 
I don't remember them specifically as there were plenty of people making wild statements, but feel free to link them for public shaming purposes...

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=54527298&postcount=2251
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=54513261&highlight=#post54513261
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=54503721&highlight=#post54503721
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=54502524&highlight=#post54502524

he edited some of his posts

I knew it wasn't Sunil, why would an Indian guy bomb America? Made no sense

Some people on GAF were posting this shit too.

I tried to stop it and was ridiculed for a bit
 

Why would a Chechen kid bomb America? Makes no sense.

Before you say "Islamism", India is the country with the third-largest Muslim population. Yes they represent less than 15% of the population, but that's still almost 150 million people.
 
Can someone explain the Sunil thing?

http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/20/meanwhile-sunil-tripathi-is-still-missing/
http://abcnewsradioonline.com/natio...h-for-missing-ivy-league-student-expands.html

Sunil Tripathi is a missing student from Brown University in Rhode Island since March. He's still missing.

The bombings happened and people started thinking it could be him. People compared his photo to the suspect photos released. Became a widespread theory on the internet. His family was harassed, his mom had to delete posts of people accusing him of the bombings on the "Find Sunil" Facebook page. When the two suspects were finally being chased by the police, twitter blew up with fake name confirmations and Sunil was one of them.

It wasn't him, as we now know.
 
Why would a Chechen kid bomb America? Makes no sense.

Before you say "Islamism", India is the country with the third-largest Muslim population. Yes they represent less than 15% of the population, but that's still almost 150 million people.

In that thread I clearly said he was Hindu and I was asking others why would an educated Hindu guy raised in the west would bomb America....I was confused and it made no sense to me and I was right.

Maybe you don't know enough about Chechen's but I do. They killed a lot of Russian soldiers during the war, I became curious about them after stumbling upon the old Russian soldier beheading video on kazaa back in the day

Why would anyone intentionally bomb civilians at a marathon?

This is what Radical Islamist's have been doing for a long time, it's their style....I lived in Delhi, I saw a bomb go off and saw people die...
 
It doesn't matter what makes sense, the lesson is don't throw names out there that aren't verified.

The real lesson is that people without any experience shouldn't be trying to do someone else's job, and anyone who thinks any online website like GAF, Reddit, or 4chan is a credible source is an idiot.

That's it, really.
 
The real lesson is that people without any experience shouldn't be trying to do someone else's job, and anyone who thinks any online website like GAF, Reddit, or 4chan is a credible source is an idiot.

That's it, really.

Well that too obviously but definitely don't toss out names, that's how people get their lives tied into stuff they had nothing to do with.
 
It doesn't matter what makes sense, the lesson is don't throw names out there that aren't verified.

Oh I wasn't defending the whole "it's Sunil!" thing, just wanted to point out that Indians aren't inherently less likely than Chechens to be terrorists.
 
People like to give GAF flack but in the thread as it was unfolding and someone posted a twitter stating Sunil's name as suspect #2 the next 3 pages were of people saying "What's your source?!" Of course there were a few out there that started sluething on that.

GAF also doesn't have a history of harboring questionable behavior, or a crushing ideological adherence.
 
The most spectacular thing is that all that crowdsourced image analysis achieved exactly fuck all in identifying the bombers. Total waste of time at best, hugely destructive at worst.
 
Oh I wasn't defending the whole "it's Sunil!" thing, just wanted to point out that Indians aren't inherently less likely than Chechens to be terrorists.

His last lame is Tripathi which is Hindu and which is why I was defending him. Yes, we all know there are Indian Muslims who are engaged in terrorist activities, look at Student Islamic Movement of India and a dozen other groups.
 
Gustav's post?
it's actually the one i think that doesn't fit your list, because i read it like he ment that everyone saying it definitely is or is not Sunil should chill out.

Yup. I thought this was pretty clear even that night, and was surprised anyone interpreted it differently. Why else put "not" in parentheses?
 
That's a shitty apology, and an unnecessary one too. They shouldn't apologise they should just reconsider their moderation policies and try to prevent this kind of thing next time around. Otherwise it's just meaningless words.
 
Reddit community members who participated in the witch hunt are assholes, and the people here who were dead convinced it was him too are in the same boat. They were so adamant it was him, despite the iffy evidence. This is why the professionals are professionals and we have a legal system. Too many people too quick to blame.
 
His last lame is Tripathi which is Hindu and which is why I was defending him. Yes, we all know there are Indian Muslims who are engaged in terrorist activities, look at Student Islamic Movement of India and a dozen other groups.

True. There is Hindu terrorism but as you said it's not really directed towards the US. I'll stop derailing the thread now.
 
I think people were blaming Sunil because he is brown. Let's face it most westerners can't tell the difference between an Hindu surname vs Arab surname. I even had someone PM me, asking if he was Arab or not...ignorance is bliss

True. There is Hindu terrorism but as you said it's not really directed towards the US. I'll stop derailing the thread now.

Yes, there is a small right wing Hindu terrorist movement in India and they mostly attack Muslims in India these days, in the past they have attacked Christians for forcing conversions and Sikh's for demanding a separate state. But the Hindu terrorist movement is minuscule compared to the global Radical Islamic movement...there are all kinds of right wing religious groups (Buddhist, Christian, Jewish...no religion is immune)
 
His last lame is Tripathi which is Hindu and which is why I was defending him. Yes, we all know there are Indian Muslims who are engaged in terrorist activities, look at Student Islamic Movement of India and a dozen other groups.

This was my reasoning, too.

Never doubted the kid.

It makes me lol when people think I pick one suspect or another because they are brown.
 
 
yeah, as fucked as the sunil stuff was, the random circling of brown dudes was incredibly embarrassing. Don't forget that 17-year old brown dude who had to go to the police to clear his name.

This is a problem I saw. I was under the impression people were circling browns for the sake of it, then I was told otherwise... now its clearly part of the bad identification of the net.

MThanded, I feel robbed of my racism and bigotry rant that you stifled.
 
My favorite bit of misinformation was the guy posting here that the police had the cell phone companies to cut off cell phone traffic to prevent another bombing.
 
What I really don't get is how people treated this as some kind of Valve ARG, drawing clues and pointing fingers for their own amusement.

I said this before way back when the PS4 was revealed, it annoys me when people on internet forums smugly declare "it's (insert baseless opinion here), and you're stupid and will eat crow soon enough if you don't agree". It's one thing to think something, it's another to declare it as an objective fact. I said it in reference to people proclaiming with 100% certainty that the PS4 can't possibly have more than 3-4 gigs of RAM. Like, duh, you're a complete dumbass if you think it'll have more. What kind of stupid, stupid person would think otherwise?

The worst part is that this is much, much worse. We're not talking about fucking video games here, we're talking about the internet pointing its collective finger as a suspect of a major terrorist attack without so much as a hunch, and people on both GAF and Reddit (and I'm sure a bunch of other corners of the internet) doubled down and stubbornly declare their hunches as irrefutable fact with the same smugness as their wild video game predictions.

What is it about "being right" that compels people to do this shit? If you do that on gaming side I'd just shake my head and sigh, but to do that in an occasion like this is deplorable. It's like people treat everything the same when they're on an internet forum.
 
My favorite bit of misinformation was the guy posting here that the police had the cell phone companies to cut off cell phone traffic to prevent another bombing.

That was quite possibly an innocent misunderstanding, the media reported the same thing. The truth is that the network actually did go down, but it was capacity rather than a deliberate attempt to prevent another detonation.
 
Basically people looking for their fifteen minutes of fame and trying to become an Internet hero. The problem comes when they only have access to publicly available data, which may not even be relevant, and they try to jam that square peg into the round hole. Which is what happened figuratively speaking with the whole Sunil angle.

Edit: Also the falsely accused teenage track athlete.
 
This was my reasoning, too.

Never doubted the kid.

It makes me lol when people think I pick one suspect or another because they are brown.
That's very admirable, but at the same time it sounds like your suspicions in this case (or lack thereof) relied purely on his faith, which is almost just as discriminatory.
 
That was quite possibly an innocent misunderstanding, the media reported the same thing. The truth is that the network actually did go down, but it was capacity rather than a deliberate attempt to prevent another detonation.

Yeah, the fact that cell phone service goes down anytime there's a disaster should have made it an obvious reason. Jumping to farfetched conclusions just elevates the drama for no reason.
 
Yeah, the fact that cell phone service goes down anytime there's a disaster should have made it an obvious reason. Jumping to farfetched conclusions just elevates the drama for no reason.

No arguments here. I really hope that the lessons about taking a deep breath and thinking about the consequences of what's reported and done in these situations don't get lost amid the triumphalism around catching the perpetrators.
 
That's very admirable, but at the same time it sounds like your suspicions in this case (or lack thereof) relied purely on his faith, which is almost just as discriminatory.

That's only if you ignore that faith's primary country and its relation to our country.

Good effort, though.
 
lol, I'm so glad I didn't participate in any of that nonsense, leave the investigation to the actual authorities.
 
It was obvious as hell that they weren't the same person. Some posters blew my mind that night. That overlay gif threw me over the edge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom