Played SOR2 3D for about 30 minutes with Axel, thoughts so far:
This is my first time playing SOR2. SOR1 has been one of my favorite games for a long time (grew up playing it all the time on my Genesis 6PAK cartridge) but I had never realized there were any others in the series, until I saw everyone online saying that SOR2 was way better and the pinnacle of the series. Having played it now, I agree that it does a lot of things better, but I still prefer the original.
Having the extra button for special attacks is a solid addition to diversify the combat, and the dash attack is cool. Expanded moveset obviously makes the combat more interesting, but I don't feel like the combat has the same impact as the original. Axel's punches feel kind of stiff and weak. Weapon swings are a bit better though. Can you even throw knives in this? That was like the best part of SOR1, knives are severely lacking in this. Also I miss the police car
Music is overall as good as the original, some songs are better and have more going on. The boss theme is kind of shit though, but I guess it's hard to compete with the first game's GOAT boss theme.
3D looks amaaaaaazing. Way better than SOR1 3D
Regardless, M2 rules. Bring on Gunstar and Sonic 2!