• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

South Park: Snow Day | Review Thread

Draugoth

Gold Member

south-1080x609.jpg


Game Information​

Game Title: South Park: Snow Day
Platforms:
  • Xbox Series X/S (Mar 26, 2024)
  • PlayStation 5 (Mar 26, 2024)
  • Nintendo Switch (Mar 26, 2024)
  • PC (Mar 26, 2024)
Trailer:
Publishers: THQ Nordic, Question Games

Review Aggregator:

Captura-de-tela-2024-03-25-153125.png


OpenCritic - 63 average - 30% recommended - 27 reviews

Critic Reviews​

AltChar - Semir Omerovic - 80 / 100
In a nutshell, South Park: Snow Day! is a great game that offers plenty of the classic South Park humour on top of engaging and fun combat and an interesting main story. While it's quite short and strongly focuses on co-op which some may find as a drawback, I still think it's worth the 29,99€ price point.
Atarita - İdil Barbaros - Turkish - 60 / 100
While South Park: SNOW DAY! is a South Park product with it’s humor, story and character dialogues; the game itself unfortunately lacks this quality. If you're not a South Park fan, this game will appeal to you at first, but after a while you might get bored as if you've been buried under the snow.
CGMagazine - Zubi Khan - 7.5 / 10
South Park: Snow Day! successfully translates the flat, construction paper aesthetic of the show into a fun, modern 3D co-op action title priced appropriately for the amount of content available at launch.
COGconnected - Rhett Waselenchuk - 69 / 100
South Park: Snow Day by no means lives up to its predecessors. Still, it manages to be worthwhile for those invested in the franchise.
Checkpoint Gaming - Victor Tan - 8 / 10
South Park: Snow Day! brings a snow day to life by letting children direct power struggles between nations. The trademark humour of the series returns, making you laugh every step of the adventure. A robust combat system helps you coordinate with your allies while encouraging exploration and taking advantage of your environment. Even if you are alone, AI bots are trustworthy allies who do their best to help. Upgrades are also handled nicely, giving you a variety of playstyles for your character. While chaotic combat and satire might not be for everyone, this remains a solid game to play with others.
Digital Trends - Giovanni Colantonio - 1.5 / 5
South Park: Snow Day! brings the cartoon’s up-and-down foray into gaming full circle. The co-op adventure underwhelms with sloppy action, repetitive combat, and a poorly implemented roguelite structure. Fans of the show’s first few seasons may get some laughs from its throwback humor, but the fun setup gets flushed down the drain like Mr. Hankey.
Downtime Bros - Sam Harby - 5 / 10
If you enjoy fighting endless waves of enemies in simple combat, then there might be something here to enjoy. But for most, South Park: Snow Day! is a decidedly skippable spin-off game, even if you’re the most diehard of South Park fans.
GGRecon - Joshua Boyles - 2 / 5
What’s unforgivable is that, at its core, South Park: Snow Day! isn’t remotely fun to play. Its combat and progression systems aren’t engaging, and only the most hardcore of South Park fans will find a glimmer of hope in the bulletproof humour that’s borrowed from the cartoon.
GameGrin - Alana Dunitz - 9 / 10
South Park: Snow Days! This game is full of humour and personality, combined with great visuals and music. It's so much fun to play!
Gameblog - SutterCane - French - 6 / 10
South Park Snow Day could have been one the worst games of this iconic series, but it's not ! If you like the humor and you're cherish all these characters, you could have an enjoyable moment alone, or with friends. Playing this game in co-op eliminates this feeling of artificial difficulty. The experience feels a little bit old, but there are cool elements like playing cards. Give it a shot if you love South Park and don't expect a great game.
Gamer Escape - Justin Mercer - 6 / 10
South Park: Snow Day!’s most prominent issue is one of fundamentals. The game’s namesake is very much intact and handled exactly in the way you would hope as a fan of the show, but the meat and potatoes of the actual gameplay leave much to be desired. Its humorous, surprisingly robust roguelike elements and attention paid to its source material simply aren’t enough to offset the detriments to its simplistic combat and repetitive structure.
GamingTrend - Adam Moreno - 85 / 100
If you love South Park, this will be the best $30 you could spend to have another adventure with all your favorite characters. With a completely different game style than the most recent South Park games, Snow Day! gives you five chapters of the main story totaling 5-6 hours, side quests that can be done more than once on multiple difficulties, and plenty of cosmetics for you to unlock. Solo play gets a little difficult during the ending of the story, but with friends, it should be an enjoyable time for all!
God is a Geek - Chris White - 7.5 / 10
South Park: Snow Day! is a pretty good roguelike with tons of different cards to make each run feel different, complete with that SP humour.
IGN - Travis Northup - 3 / 10
Aggravating hack-and-slash combat and surprisingly sparse jokes make South Park: Snow Day! dull, toothless, and a big step in the wrong direction for South Park games.
Nintendo Life - Jaimie Ditchfield - 4 / 10
South Park: Snow Day! has a lot of potential with some of its roguelike-inspired mechanics but ultimately fails to deliver an engaging experience whether you're playing it solo or in co-op. Combat feels unresponsive, the technical issues are numerous (on Switch at least), and the writing is some of the weakest in the series.
PSX Brasil - Vanessa Ferreira - Portuguese - 70 / 100
It doesn't make as much of an impact, but it offers what is needed to entertain.
Push Square - Ken Talbot - 6 / 10
A sporadically fun co-op brawler, South Park: Snow Day is a step back for the franchise. Card collecting and gag-filled combat will keep fans entertained, but there are plenty of better ways to have good times with weapons.
Shacknews - Sam Chandler - 8 / 10
Quote not yet available
Slant Magazine - Aaron Riccio - 2 / 5
Despite being occasionally funny, the game is never fun.
Spaziogames - Marcello Paolillo - Italian - 7.1 / 10
South Park: Snow Day! sets aside the RPG elements of previous titles, in order to offer a multiplayer action game with pronounced roguelike mechanics, unfortunately quite repetitive in the long run.
The Beta Network - Anthony Culinas - 7 / 10
While it may not be as riveting as its turn-based contemporaries, South Park: Snow Day! showcases an enjoyable 3D action battle system built for 4 players online, combined with the iconic comedic writing of Trey Parker and Matt Stone.
The Nerd Stash - Patrick Armstrong - 8 / 10
A third-person roguelike brawler that celebrates immature humor and co-op destruction.
TheSixthAxis - Nick Petrasiti - 6 / 10
After the successes of both Stick of Truth and The Fractured But Whole, South Park: Snow Day! is a big change of pace that left me with mixed feelings. It's an enjoyable game with some nice ideas, but at the same time, you'll be left wondering was this it?
Thumb Culture - 3 / 5
The jokes were funny, and the game does play really well with no glitches. But (and this is what hurts the most), the game overall just isn't long enough. I managed to finish the game in just over two hours. When completed there was no real reason to keep on playing.
The game lacks anything for the player to work towards. If players enjoy collecting trophies, they can add some longevity that way.
Try Hard Guides - Erik Hodges - 7 / 10
South Park: Snow Day! bravely departs from the series’ previous installments, offering something new and interesting as well as a continuation of a beloved story for fans. While the plot is interesting and full of that usual South Park charm, fans might not find too much of a reason to engage in the game’s intended replayability, with the game clocking in at a short but satisfying 4-5 hours.
VideoGamer - Antony Terence - 5 / 10
Snow Day’s moment-to-moment slapstick humor and inventive combat are undermined by unfulfilling progression and an acute lack of content.
Worth Playing - Cody Medellin - 7.5 / 10
South Park: Snow Day! is a good South Park game, but it's just a fine one when viewed without the license. The action is good, as is the inclusion of roguelike elements, but the camera distance can make the gameplay feel cumbersome. The inclusion of multiplayer is great, but the lack of local play is disappointing. While the different card combinations and level elements add some replayability, the presence of only five stages make the game feel short; the disappointment is lessened by the lower-than-expected price tag. It's a fun game, but you'll want to temper your expectations.
 

whyman

Member
From 1.5 to 8… that is a huge range. I mean the game seems to run, that’s more then some AAA that has received high scores managed.
 

StueyDuck

Member
Am i the only one who thinks this looks like dumb fun considering it's a budget title?



has anyone actually played it, or are we all focusing on that one IGN review. I'd love to know what a non game journo who actually is a massive fan of south park thinks.
 
Top Bottom