nintendoman58
Member
That's the freaking problem I have with Rebellion. I loved the original Madoka ending. It finished the story, there were no loose ends, it all just felt so perfect.
And then Rebellion comes along and just stomps all over it.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Spring Anime 2015 |OT| The Disappearance of YEAARRT!
- Thread starter TUSR
- Start date
- Status
That's the freaking problem I have with Rebellion. I loved the original Madoka ending. It finished the story, there were no loose ends, it all just felt so perfect.
And then Rebellion comes along and just stomps all over it.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
If they were to make a sequel to something with a conclusive ending, Rebellion is the way to do it. I'm glad it was made. For a "milking" it's actually super good, at least.
PdotMichael
Banned
The Empires Strikes Back of the anime world. It's glorious.
For some reason I can't say, reading the LN, one of the sentences in this quote made me chuckle.
You guys are in for a treat.
Passive Assassin
Member
Arslan OVA 1-4
It's good.
It's good.
gashikunFLCL
Member
I really like the clapping too.
Hana-chan is really the cutest thing!
Enjoy it. Episode 40 is one of the best.
Magic Knight Rayearth 17-19
Kind of an odd time and way for Ferio to regain his memories. I suppose it gets the job done. Inouva doesn't make it. The super-loyal ones never do. The bad guys would probably have more success if they didn't attack the Knights in front of the big bad Rune-Gods. Cause without that they probably wouldn't revive. And even big bad Zagato doesn't act fast enough. Well robots are cool, so whatever.
Have I mentioned how I love the evolving armor? Each iteration is cooler than the last one. The one with the Rune-Gods in particular is very awesome. Capes make everything better.
Kind of an odd time and way for Ferio to regain his memories. I suppose it gets the job done. Inouva doesn't make it. The super-loyal ones never do. The bad guys would probably have more success if they didn't attack the Knights in front of the big bad Rune-Gods. Cause without that they probably wouldn't revive. And even big bad Zagato doesn't act fast enough. Well robots are cool, so whatever.
And of course he did it all for love and for Emeraude. What a sweetie. And proves that love isn't necessarily a positive thing. He had a good presence, but they're called Rune-Gods for a reason. Time for that twist.
Have I mentioned how I love the evolving armor? Each iteration is cooler than the last one. The one with the Rune-Gods in particular is very awesome. Capes make everything better.
Yes. Anyone but Yukino pls. Can't believe that I'm rooting for the side characters now instead of the two main girls. Iroha's dynamic with Hachiman is much much better than those two in the club.
Magic Knight Rayearth 20
So yeah, season 1 of Rayearth is a classic fantasy adventure with loveable characters and charm everywhere. The plot is basic until the end, but the execution carries it all the way. Fights started out pretty good, though by the end it feels like they got lazy, even with the big scenes. It still looked good overall. Definitely a nice watch.
But it doesn't end here. Time for the next part. I remember the manga turning weird as it became more of a political thriller than adventure? Or something like that. Wouldn't call it bad, just odd. I've heard that this is where the anime really diverges, so I'm curious as to where it leads.
When I read the manga, the whole twist of Emeraude hating her duty and summoning the Magic Knights for an elaborate suicide plot blew my mind. A very interesting example of how the entire perspective of the series can change from one revelation. Emeraude was both the victim and the true villain. Hit hard. Hit the characters hard too. That ending was both abrupt and a downer. What a way to end it.
So yeah, season 1 of Rayearth is a classic fantasy adventure with loveable characters and charm everywhere. The plot is basic until the end, but the execution carries it all the way. Fights started out pretty good, though by the end it feels like they got lazy, even with the big scenes. It still looked good overall. Definitely a nice watch.
But it doesn't end here. Time for the next part. I remember the manga turning weird as it became more of a political thriller than adventure? Or something like that. Wouldn't call it bad, just odd. I've heard that this is where the anime really diverges, so I'm curious as to where it leads.
Twin Tails
Member
Simoun 12
Seems they can't be
anymore.
Also much drama in next ep.
Incest ftw?
pairs
Also much drama in next ep.
I loved the ending to bits. It's all so sad imo. And then to end it with Kalafina's Kimi no Gin no Niwa. Go check out the lyrics if you haven't already. Kajiura always writes such lovely lyrics, especially for movies she writes for. Her OST is amazing too, of course. She is always on point when it comes to film scoring.
If they ended it the way Urobuchi originally intended, it would have been the ending everyone had foreseen. Everyone would cry for Homura for a week and we would have forgotten about the series after that. It would have been an unremarkable ending to a remarkable series. This ending opens doors to a new conflict. BRING ON SAYAKA (& Kyouko)!!
WEll FSN came out waaaaaaay before Fate Zero so basically, yes if you want to watch in order of airing. However Fate Zero being a prequel obviously it shows how things in FSN came to be. The recommended order is really Fate Zero then FSN. But FSN isnt actually very good no matter which studio makes it.
Well this is ANIME. I like the blue haired girl.
Show by Rock 02-06
I'm sort of waiting for the shit to hit the fan. That setting in ep 01 has this written all over it. Pls hit fan soon. Thanks. ( ﾟ∀ﾟ
And I can't be the only one screaming for Cyan to hug Retoree while she was apologising in the bath. HUG HER DAMMIT.
Eila and Sanya have got to be in this one. Eila and Sanya have got to be in this one! Eila and Sanya have got to be in this one!!!!
There's no other explanation as to why they didn't get their OVA episodeeee.
Let me guess. It's from the same folks that brought us Queen's Blade?
This post is full of lilies. Im ok with this.
Lili best girl!
Meat not best girl.
XiaNaphryz
LATIN, MATRIPEDICABUS, DO YOU SPEAK IT
I see that Saki Achiga-hen is supposed to be a prequel of sorts in terms of timeline? Should I watch that first?
Passive Assassin
Member
Arslan OVA Fin
Hopefully the remake can stand up to this :l
Hopefully the remake can stand up to this :l
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (END)
I watched it in broadcast order so the last set of episodes I saw was "The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya," the episodes where they made the movie.
Talking about the last few episodes...
Anyway I can see how the rain episode could have been the perfect ending to the series (it would be if you watched in chronological order) but I liked this ending too, it felt good to me. I really liked the series. The banter between Kyon and Haruhi was always fun. Koizumi was annoying, and Nagato and Asahina were cute in their own way. I enjoyed the music in the actual show and also liked the first opening, but not the 2nd one nor any of the endings. Endless Eight would probably be my only gripe with the series, but after understanding why they did that, I get it and it's more tolerable. Still sucks a bit though. Anyway I've heard good things about Disappearance, so I'll be sure to watch that in the next few days and post my impressions as well.
How's the anime that's airing right now? It's more of a romcom focused on Nagato right?
I watched it in broadcast order so the last set of episodes I saw was "The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya," the episodes where they made the movie.
Talking about the last few episodes...
It was interesting to see them make the movie, since you see it first thing in the broadcast order. You kind of have a feeling where they'll go in terms of filming locations and how most things will work out but it's nice to fill in the blanks. I was waiting and waiting for Kyon to blow up at Haruhi and I'm glad he finally did. (Thank god he didn't actually hit her though...) While Haruhi always believes that he'll be on her side, I think he is also the only person who can really balance her out when she gets to her real extremes, so arguments like that are needed once in a while. Haruhi would never apologize so I knew Kyon would have to, but I liked the realization he came to before he went to do so. Also was she putting her hair into a ponytail (Kyon's favorite hairstyle on her) as he walked into the club room? Hah. Ah and at the end of these set of episodes we delve further into the mysteries of what Haruhi exactly is and the hidden agendas behind Koizumi, Asahina, and Nagato. Honestly I always felt that Koizumi was untrustworthy, so I'm interested to see how this develops (I'm guessing I'll get somewhat of an answer in "Disappearance.")
Anyway I can see how the rain episode could have been the perfect ending to the series (it would be if you watched in chronological order) but I liked this ending too, it felt good to me. I really liked the series. The banter between Kyon and Haruhi was always fun. Koizumi was annoying, and Nagato and Asahina were cute in their own way. I enjoyed the music in the actual show and also liked the first opening, but not the 2nd one nor any of the endings. Endless Eight would probably be my only gripe with the series, but after understanding why they did that, I get it and it's more tolerable. Still sucks a bit though. Anyway I've heard good things about Disappearance, so I'll be sure to watch that in the next few days and post my impressions as well.
How's the anime that's airing right now? It's more of a romcom focused on Nagato right?
Oneechanbara is the closest thing it looks like.
Sllime cutie finally shows her face!
They nailed the character designs from the look of it.
Agreed.
Knew there was still material to be adabted but I wasn't aware they covered only so little. Oh well.
Something, something, broadcast order is a puzzle and it has a better ending. ;p Or so I've heard. Will be looking forward to that progression.
The only good thing about that ending is that Sayaka is now undoubtedly the best girl.
AHHHH that avatar is so cute!
Came in exactly 1 month early, I bought this for the 2D mechs, tummies, and dat launch sequence.
I might buy it for Hana. Does it come with anything special or just a standard release?
Bro its not even a contest that she's the best Caster.
Yeah mofu Caster is easily the best.
Not even a contest!
Honestly this was one of the most boring shows I have ever watched.
Im sure not everyone will think that but the slow pacing, the plain art style, and the lack of memorable character personalities just made this a dull experience for me.
Basileus777
Member
No, especially since it's a lot worse than the original series. It's about separate (worse) characters, there's nothing to be gained by watching it first.
Terrible. Skip it and watch Disappearance.
Further thoughts on Madoka Magica Rebellion:
Ignoring the first atrocious fan fiction level first 30 minutes, this was both amazing and atrocious movie, The movie turns a dark, but bittersweet story of love and sacrifice into an absolute tragedy borne from suffering, thereby annihilating everything that was the point of the finale of the original show. Homura's selfish decision overrides Madoka's choice and makes her sacrifice count for nothing. Seriously, that ending is completely meaningless. No magical girls got saved from despair. What was once a climax is just an event. That love is now an obsession. That hope is now not giving a fuck at all except Madoka. That impetus to save Madoka devolved into how she could keep her for herself.
At the same time here is the thing, it was done really well, and I can see why she did what she did as screwed up as it is. At the very least the movie was off its rockers towards the end (well, it was kind of off its rocker at the beginning as well, what's up with the cake song?), and whether that is awesome is something only you can decide (I liked that movie went full on crazy). If there was any way to screw up with the status quo established previously, this is a great way to go about it. And if the original show were a tragedy, it would be something like this. Aside from the first 30 minutes I can't decide whether it's good or bad, it's both! The difficulty comes from the fact that the movie is not isolated from the show and so it overrides the show's beautifully built up climax, but at the same time it feels like a logical progression, as if it couldn't have happened otherwise. God why would they do this to me? ;_;
Ignoring the first atrocious fan fiction level first 30 minutes, this was both amazing and atrocious movie, The movie turns a dark, but bittersweet story of love and sacrifice into an absolute tragedy borne from suffering, thereby annihilating everything that was the point of the finale of the original show. Homura's selfish decision overrides Madoka's choice and makes her sacrifice count for nothing. Seriously, that ending is completely meaningless. No magical girls got saved from despair. What was once a climax is just an event. That love is now an obsession. That hope is now not giving a fuck at all except Madoka. That impetus to save Madoka devolved into how she could keep her for herself.
At the same time here is the thing, it was done really well, and I can see why she did what she did as screwed up as it is. At the very least the movie was off its rockers towards the end (well, it was kind of off its rocker at the beginning as well, what's up with the cake song?), and whether that is awesome is something only you can decide (I liked that movie went full on crazy). If there was any way to screw up with the status quo established previously, this is a great way to go about it. And if the original show were a tragedy, it would be something like this. Aside from the first 30 minutes I can't decide whether it's good or bad, it's both! The difficulty comes from the fact that the movie is not isolated from the show and so it overrides the show's beautifully built up climax, but at the same time it feels like a logical progression, as if it couldn't have happened otherwise. God why would they do this to me? ;_;
Sabegebul 6-10
How can someone be so cruel and lovable at the same time.
2 more episodes, I really don't want this to end.
Its a delicate balance. Too far and you get Cross ange. Too likeable and the character is unbelievable. Momoka is right in the middle. Just enough of a jerk to be effective, but not so much that shes a despicable bitch. Absolutely masterful.
Madoka Magica was a phenomenon. Far beyond the usual anime discussion, the OT for it was incredibly busy and full of specula. Websites were made discussing the imagery and plot. Predictions to the ending. Discussion of the art and execution. Oh man it was amazing. The show was a phenomenal success saleswise as well.
Soma is all about that though. thats its main selling point. Its literally food porn. The reactions are way over the top and fanservicey. Perhaps Gourmet Girl Graffiti would more fit your tastes.
I cant wait till you see the ending. This will be excellent.
Madoka was my gateway show to participation in animegaf. Easily one of the most fun fanbases to participate in for discussion and speculation for a series as it was airing. The delay because of Japan's national disaster made that huge gap of time for rampant speculation after we basically got the plot bomb of major revelations the last episode before that delay.
(Also that Captain Earth question you asked; it's a standard release)
It goes in a quite interesting and unexpected direction. Keep watching. You will see it start to develop but there is a lot of little side stories and filler.
Its quite a satisfying ending though.
I love how it ends ad its pretty much the only thing Homura could do in that situation given how she feels and what she is prone to do. Honestly dont see why people dislike it so much especially in the context of the show.
Aww I thought it was gonna surprise you but you already know the ending from the manga. Boo.
Basileus777
Member
It's somewhat amusing as a troll, but as a way to structure a story, it's just terrible writing.
please put all of this in spoiler tags.
Thanks AWESOMEBEAR. I will hold off on buying this until later. Trying to concentrate on getting LE's mostly and getting standard releases later.
SliceSabre
Banned
The order would be Saki, Saki Achiga-hen episode of Side-A and then Saki the Nationals.
Saki Achiga is a side story/prequel of sorts that involves a different school. I can't say much about it because spoilers. Some people like Basileus777 don't like it for some...questionable things that happen, but it is an important side story regardless of what you may think of the things that take place.
Jex
Member
Isn't Rebellion another one of those fan mock-ups like Darker than Black 2, Gunslinger Girls 2 and the Usagi Drop manga? I'm pretty sure they don't exist.
Ohhh no Mr Jex. These certainly exist. You cant undo what has been done!
InfiniteNine
Rolling Girl
Tell that to Homura.
Sometimes we do crazy things in the name of love.
Are those like the E7 movie and sequel season?
It's all good!
I had my preorder locked in at $30 somehow, so I decided to go through with it.
Most standard releases I usually wait for the Christmas sales.
WEll I can go today at least. Its open for 6 hours today.
Mainly I go to see artist alley and the dealers room. Artist alley might be a no-go because most artist leave on Sunday. Dealers room might be picked clean of the good stuff but Ill go check it out I guess.
Fuck Im so mad at myself.
KyoAni stealing from...themselves
R_thanatos
Member
I really , REALLY disagree with the bolded... there is like an entire discussion between homura and madoka in rebellion about those loose ends in that supposed "perfect ending.
That "perfect" ending ignore the character that did the most behind the scene work in the franchise and whose goals weren't completed. The original ending was alright , good even ...but let's not act as if everything was solved
Who doesn't?
Dedication Through Light
Member
Would prefer Hayama...but Iroha is best fem choice and best canon choice.
ultimatemegax
Member
Having finished the second Euphonium novel, I've become annoyed at the producers and publicity staff emphasizing the four girls for merchandising/sales reasons over the other aspects of the concert band. Euphonium's charm is its ability to weave tales from many members together into one narrative, but thus far Oohashi, Nakamura, and Saito have been content to only push Kumiko, Hazuki, Sapphire, and Reina (with the KyoAni Shop adding Asuka, Haruka, and Kaori). It really reeks of trying to sell this show to otaku and ignoring your other possible revenue streams (literally no Taki/Shuichi merchandise?!). I wouldn't be surprised if those three (and probably Hideaki Hatta) pushed for the additional content needed to space the first novel into a cour to focus on those four for the merchandising reasons alone.
This isn't a complaint about the work itself; I'm still immensely enjoying the show. I personally feel the other aspects surrounding it don't really depict the Euphonium novel as well as it could/should be. (And watching the first PV after reading the novel emphasized that back in March for me)
This isn't a complaint about the work itself; I'm still immensely enjoying the show. I personally feel the other aspects surrounding it don't really depict the Euphonium novel as well as it could/should be. (And watching the first PV after reading the novel emphasized that back in March for me)
Show By Re-Kan!! 07
The CG is still fun to watch. So it can work in anime, as long as it's going for a heavily stylized look, as this show and Etotama prove. I like how they're integrating bands outside of the core five into the plot, such as the ghost band in this episode. Makes me hope that the Sentai band can make an appearance later.
The CG is still fun to watch. So it can work in anime, as long as it's going for a heavily stylized look, as this show and Etotama prove. I like how they're integrating bands outside of the core five into the plot, such as the ghost band in this episode. Makes me hope that the Sentai band can make an appearance later.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I like Iroha as a character a lot better than either Yui or Yukino actually. Yukino seems to get pissed off over basically anything and refuses to admit Hachiman is her friend for some insane person reason (even though she is completely aware of how he is) and Yui doesn't really have any hidden depths.
Cornbread78
Member
They need to give us a Yui story arc at some point. It's been all Hiki and Yuki for awhile now In terms of depth. We know she likes Hiki but can't come clean about her feelings. I think Hiki knows it too...
- Status