I'm watching all the old lightsaber battles and the Ep 1 and 2 ones... are just terrible. There's no tension, the camera is dead still the entire time, and there's no sense that someone is getting the upper hand in the fight. It's just dudes wailing sticks at each other until someone uncharacteristically leaves themself wide open for a killing blow.
Tickets locked in! Best thing about being in New Zealand is that I get to watch blockbusters before all you Americans
It actually releases on Thursday 17 December here, but I was too late to get good seats for opening day.
![]()
Unlimited Powaaaaah is definitely not a high.
The Order 66 montage
The wordless moment between Anakin & Padme
The Opera Scene
The Opening Assault
The Padme's Funeral/Vader's Birth montage
Granted, there's some really mediocre shit inbetween, but those moments feature solid filmmaking from Lucas, solid enough to make you remember he was the guy who helped edit The Godfather and made THX 1138.
Jedi's got:
The Space Battle
The Throne Room
The speeder bike chase
...and that's it, really. Jabba's Palace takes too goddamn long. The ewoks aren't good. The ground battle isn't good. Han Solo's character is neutered and kneecapped. Chewie is a punchline. Fisher's performance is almost as bad as Christensen's in Sith, and in the brother/sister reveal, she's actually WORSE than he is in that movie.
Williams' music elevates the throne room like crazy - that fight isn't as good as Empire. The music is better than the fight is.
What do people think about Darth Vader in general?
Yes, I don't know why people love it so much. It has a lot of creativity but it also just draaaags. Even as a kid I thought the structure was very boring. It's just a series of people showing up and failing until the actual fun part, the sarlacc.
Another big problem with Revenge of the Sith just was that Lucas thought people would care about his Clone Wars series.
Making the first part of the movie even more jarring and messy for most people.
As mentioned earlier in this thread, if there's one change I like in the special edition of ROTJ, it was replacing Yub Nub with Victory Celebration at the end.
I dunno, it just feels more fulfilling and conclusive than a random ewok song.
The first show here in the US in Colorado is 7PM on December 17th.
Except when they fly over Naboo and a fucking Gungan yells "Wesa Free!" I want to throw my remote at the television.
How big is Ford's role in this film?
Phantom Menace gets too much hate in a reality where AOTC exists.
Jar Jar for me is ''fine''. He doesn't ruin the movie, he is just stupid. AOTC Anakin however is unbearable.
Oh god lol. I mainly refering to the music itself. Those CG cities and shit stick out like a sore thumb so much.
Its hard for a lot of people to articulate why exactly they hated The Phantom Menace because its such a clusterfuck of a film, so they point to Jar Jar. In fact, you can make an argument that Jar Jar was the only thing you could understand clearly in the movie. He had some kind of motivation and a character arc. He was annoying, yes, but ironically, he was the most realistic and understandable thing in the film.
I know I'm late to this discussion, but just wanted to point out that the scenes you mention from ROTS are each like a single minute long, maybe two minutes max, whereas the ROTJ scenes are 5-10 minutes each.
Mike Stoklasa of RLM fame brought a rather interesting point about Jar Jar...
http://slpmode.com/a-v-club-milwauk...etailed-and-very-late-takedowns-of-star-wars/
Honestly, I definitely see what he means. In a film filled with so many passionless, dull, inhuman drones, Jar Jar is really one of the very few characters that has some sort of charisma and character to him. Doesn't mean he wasn't obnoxious of course, but still.
They also did not mention the rescue from Jabba's palace.
Hell Luke's entrance was boss all by itself.
The return to Dagobah.
Luke and Leia's conversation on Endor...
Mike Stoklasa of RLM fame brought a rather interesting point about Jar Jar...
http://slpmode.com/a-v-club-milwauk...etailed-and-very-late-takedowns-of-star-wars/
Honestly, I definitely see what he means. In a film filled with so many passionless, dull, inhuman drones, Jar Jar is really one of the very few characters that has some sort of charisma and character to him. Doesn't mean he wasn't obnoxious of course, but still.
Which conversation are we talking about here?They also did not mention the rescue from Jabba's palace.
Hell Luke's entrance was boss all by itself.
The return to Dagobah.
Luke and Leia's conversation on Endor...
Which conversation are we talking about here?
I cant take people serious who claim that this movie is bad because of Ewoks.Even the Ewoks aren't that terrible.
I don't know if that film actually had a middle though.
Very big.
AVC: Can the blame be placed solely on George Lucas?
MS: Im honestly not a George Lucas ruined my childhood personI dont care that muchbut I consider myself a George Lucas disappointed my adulthood person. You see, Im not convinced that George is this genius filmmaker that hes always been portrayed as being. My impression of the man is this: I see him as a guy who had a neat idea to make a space adventure movie in the spirit of the old Flash Gordon serials. Modernize it a little, make it share a lot of visual elements with World War II, add some mythological elements to it and call it Star Wars. Then get a whole bunch of other people to make it work somehow. Then take all the credit for it. Then use your influence as an idea man to produce such hits as Howard The Duck, The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles, and Radioland Murders.
There's no call for this, man.
YOU DIDN'T NEED TO DO THIS
![]()
![]()
I know I'm late to this discussion, but just wanted to point out that the scenes you mention from ROTS are each like a single minute long, maybe two minutes max, whereas the ROTJ scenes are 5-10 minutes each.
Can someone please tell me which songs are used in the trailer?
You mean like when the technology advanced USA was owned by the Vietnam?Storm troopers are completely dumbed down for the sake of Ewoks. The latter are fine, but it's painful to watch the alleged elite soldiers chosen by the emperor himself behaving like total buffoons.
You mean like when the technology advanced USA was owned by the Vietnam?
Worst parts about RotJ: The instant-explosion trope is everywhere, it looks dumb. Forest chase also didn't age very gracefully.
Storm troopers are completely dumbed down for the sake of Ewoks. The latter are fine, but it's painful to watch the alleged elite soldiers chosen by the emperor himself behaving like total buffoons.
The movie is also the worst victim of the special editions, even though I also prefer the new song.
If the ending consisted of throne room and space battle only, it would without a doubt be the second best in the series. Great ending to a simple but well made and classic good vs. evil adventure.
I'm not a ewok hater but they could have totally done with primitives vs technological empire more effectively with wookies